Author Topic: mace windu is the jedi traitor. proof here!
Rebel Scumb  11889 posts
Registered: Feb '99
6883_Chance Cube
Date Posted: 7/19/03 11:41am Subject: RE: mace windu is the jedi traitor. proof here!
All of the points made by the_homeless_jedi are idiotic, however these are my two favorites:

"7. he is the one who erased the archives. only a jedi could do that."

And Mace is the only Jedi? You don't find it more likely that it could be, say... Anakin the jedi we KNOW for a fact turns evil and IS in league with Sidious.

"8. he is spying on yoda. notice how he is always around him. watching him. cautiously."

So does that mean YOU are spying on your school chums and family members? You're always around them.

 

-----signature-----
The Clone wars cartoon is everything I ever wanted from the prequels.
Locked Topic | Active Topic Notification | Private Message | Post History
Galacticus90210  72 posts
Registered: Jul '03
6456_Yoda - Concentraaaate!
Date Posted: 7/19/03 12:15pm Subject: RE: mace windu is the jedi traitor. proof here!
Hah. I like how he has "a different lightsaber." I get alot of joy out of making fun of threads like this--When people think that they have things all figured out.

 

-----signature-----
Feel the Force... One Last Time
--Star Wars Episode III--
Locked Topic | Active Topic Notification | Private Message | Post History
Mr_Mwindu  2786 posts
Registered: May '02
Date Posted: 7/19/03 9:52pm Subject: RE: mace windu is the jedi traitor. proof here!
mace is no traitor, and im still waiting to see the proof that the title of this ridiculous thread promised

 

-----signature-----
Accept No Substitutes
Locked Topic | Active Topic Notification | Private Message | Post History
Grilled-Sarlacc  15488 posts
Title: Former Head Admin
Registered: Jul '01
6243_2-1B
Date Posted: 7/19/03 9:57pm Subject: RE: mace windu is the jedi traitor. proof here!
There is none. Just fanboy wishes.

 

-----signature-----
Hi. I like Star Wars.
Locked Topic | Active Topic Notification | Private Message | Post History
Jabba-wocky  20811 posts
Registered: May '03
44296_YJCC War Rhino
Date Posted: 7/20/03 11:15am Subject: RE: mace windu is the jedi traitor. proof here!
*blinks*

I have to admit I'm confused. You ignore the fact that all previous evidence has been completely blasted away. Then you ignore ousley's theory, which is the most plausible take on the Mace thing I've seen (despite its flaws). Instead, you claim that the arugment put forth by Viking is the ultimate proof.

Ignoring the fact, that as Viking himself said its just postulation. And the posutlation itself ignoring the fact that Obi-wan cut someone in half and he was still a good guy. And further ignoring the fact that Lucas himself said Boba's role in EPIII would be a) no bigger than his one in AOTC and b)that he would be to small to fit into any Mandalorian armor. Meaning he probably won't be killing Mace anyway.

 

-----signature-----
ays Darius the king: 8 of my family (there were) who were formerly kings; I am the ninth (9); long aforetime we are kings.
All Hail His Excellency, Barack Obama
Roma vincit
Tearing Up a Lane (TERRIN UP A LAAAANE!!!)
Locked Topic | Active Topic Notification | Private Message | Post History
Ian_McDiarmid-TheGod 
Registered: Jul '03
6179_Palpatine
Date Posted: 7/20/03 11:24am Subject: RE: mace windu is the jedi traitor. proof here!
This thread is most amusing. What happens when Episode 3 is released and Mace is shown not to be a traitor?

 

-----signature-----
Convicted FIGS Heretic.
Slave of FIGS.
My soul belongs to the true Ian McDiarmid, The God.
Locked Topic | Active Topic Notification | Private Message | Post History
jedi_master_ousley  30789 posts
Title: Manager Emeritus
Registered: Jun '02
43742_Obi-Wan Kenobi
Date Posted: 7/20/03 2:35pm Subject: RE: mace windu is the jedi traitor. proof here! - Date Edited: 7/20/03 2:37pm (1 edits total) Edited By: jedi_master_ousley
Then you ignore ousley's theory, which is the most plausible take on the Mace thing I've seen (despite its flaws).

I'm glad you like my theory. happy Though, if you don't mind me asking, what are the flaws? I'm just asking because I want my theory to not have any holes in it. wink

 

-----signature-----
I steal candy from babies to prevent childhood obesity.
Locked Topic | Active Topic Notification | Private Message | Post History
Jabba-wocky  20811 posts
Registered: May '03
44296_YJCC War Rhino
Date Posted: 7/20/03 8:17pm Subject: RE: mace windu is the jedi traitor. proof here!
Ousley, mostly because I'm having problems conceptualizing how it would work. Because I cna only see us hardcore fans understanding (and loving) that, unless its spelled out for the audience. But I'm afraid if you come right out and say it, removes all the tension/danger from the SW films because it looks like everyone knows what's going to happen and they're just waiting for the blocks to fall in place.

But maybe if someone just explained why Mace did what he did, people would be smart enough to see how wise it was by ROTJ. That would even be added tension to the movie. What do you think about striking a balance between those two things?

 

-----signature-----
ays Darius the king: 8 of my family (there were) who were formerly kings; I am the ninth (9); long aforetime we are kings.
All Hail His Excellency, Barack Obama
Roma vincit
Tearing Up a Lane (TERRIN UP A LAAAANE!!!)
Locked Topic | Active Topic Notification | Private Message | Post History
jedi_master_ousley  30789 posts
Title: Manager Emeritus
Registered: Jun '02
43742_Obi-Wan Kenobi
Date Posted: 7/20/03 8:45pm Subject: RE: mace windu is the jedi traitor. proof here! - Date Edited: 7/20/03 8:54pm (2 edits total) Edited By: jedi_master_ousley
Well, I'm thinking that Anakin will have turned and other Jedi will go after him. Mace could start yelling about "ANAKIN IS THE CHOSEN ONE! HE WILL BRING BALANCE: IT'S MORE IMPORTANT THAN ANY OF US HERE!" and the other Jedi just don't care, so Mace helps Anakin fend them off and is killed in the process.

Somehow Mace will have to verbally portray what he's doing and why he's doing it. Or instead of doing it in battle, he expresses this to the Council.

Look at this from his private journal in Shatterpoint
. It is set six months after Attack of the Clones, after his ex-apprentice, Depa Billaba has fallen out of the light side of the Force (in a sense; she hasn't turned to the dark side, more neutral) during her time on a mission to Haruun Kal, Mace's homeworld. He went to rescue her, and this is after they get back. Mace has been keeping a private journal the entire book for the Jedi Archives.

    Palpatine looked from Yoda to me, his face a mast of compassionate concern. "Who would have thought that fighting a war could have such a terrible effect on a Jedi? Even when we win," murmered. "Who would have thought such a thing?"

    "Yes," I could only agree. "Who would have thought it indeed?"

    "Wonder one must," Yoda said slowly, "if that might be the most important question of all..."

    There followed a long, uncomfortable silence, which Palpatine finally broke. "Ah, sadly, questions of philosophy must wait for peacetime. We must focus on winning this war."

    "That's what Deapa did," I said. "And look what it did to her."

    "Ah, but such a thing could never happen to -- say, for example -- you." Palpatine said warmly. His lips wore an enigmatic smile. "Could it?"

    I didn't tell him that it could. That it nearly had.

    I think about that a lot, these days. I think about Depa. About everything she said to me.

    And did to me.

    I think about the jungle.

    She was right about so many things.

    She was right about her Jedi of the Future. To win this war against the Separatists, we must abandon the very thing that makes us Jedi. Yes, we won on Haruun Kal -- because our enemy broke under the club of Kar Vastor's monstrous ruthlessness.

    Jedi are keepers of the peace. We are not soldiers.

    If we become soldiers, we are Jedi no more.

    Yet I do not despair.

    She was wrong about some things too.

    You see, she lost fighting someone else's war. She was fighting the wrong enemy.

    The Separatists are not the true enemies of the Jedi. They are the enemies of the Republic. It is the Republic which will stand or fall in the battles of the Clone War.

    Even the reborn Sith are not our enemy. Not really.

    Our enemy is power mistaken for justice.

    Our enemy is the desperation that justifies atrocity.

    The Jedi's true enemy is the jungle.

    Our enemy is the darkness itself: the strangling cloud of fear and despair and anguish that this war brings with it. That is poisoning our galaxy. This is why my dreams of Geonosis are different now.

    In my dreams, I still do everything right.

    But I do in my dreams exactly what I did in that arena.

    If the prophecies are true -- if Anakin Skywalker truly is the Chosen One, who will bring balance to the Force -- then he is hte most important being alive today. And he is alive today because my Jedi instincts were working just fine.

    Because my mistake on Geonosis wasn't a mistake at all.

    If I had done as Depa said I should have -- if I had won the Clone War with a baradium bomb on Geonosis -- I would have lost the real war. The Jedi's war.

    Anakin Skywalker may be the shatterpoint of our war against the jungle.

    And if he is -- if Anakin is the being born to win that war -- it does not matter if every Jedi in the galaxy dies.

    As long as Anakin lives, we have hope. No matter how dark it gets, or how lost our cause may seem.

    He is our new hope for a Jedi future.

    May the Force be with us all.


This is one of the reasons that I feel so strongly that Mace will save the galaxy, hence going out in a blaze of glory.

As for portraying it one the screen, it would have to work similar to how I said earlier in this post -- Mace will have to make a big statement about it. He will have to announce that Anakin is more important than all the Jedi combined, because the real war cannot end until balance is brought to the Force.

I think him screaming it while trying to defend Anakin from a swarm of Jedi, saying that balance to the Force is the only way the Jedi will ever win, that Anakin is the only way this can happen, and as I said that he will tell them it's more important than any of them there, and that will be the blaze of glory he will go out in -- fending off a bunch of Jedi.

Even having never read the book, nor had it ever been written I feel that from Mace's portrayal in the film he would feel this way. And even if you do not particularly care for the EU, it could still play out that way in the movies.

Oh, and if anyone wants anything from the Shatterpoint excerpt explained better, just let me know. happy

Edit(s): Spelling and clarity.

 

-----signature-----
I steal candy from babies to prevent childhood obesity.
Locked Topic | Active Topic Notification | Private Message | Post History
Mr_Sith  6459 posts
Registered: Jun '03
42090_Darth Revan
Date Posted: 7/20/03 9:27pm Subject: RE: mace windu is the jedi traitor. proof here!
GL isn't making SW to please just US Fans. He makes it to please the WHOLE Audience which consists of every day people. SLJ has said that he will go down in a Blaze of Glory/not go out like a punk. How is he going to do that as a Traitor? The Formal Audience usually hates the Bad Guys. If Mace is a Traitor and he goes down in a Blaze of Glory then there is something totally screwed up.

 

-----signature-----
So I see, said the blind man....
*Winner of the Third Installment of the '05 Jedi Draft*
Locked Topic | Active Topic Notification | Private Message | Post History
jedi_master_ousley  30789 posts
Title: Manager Emeritus
Registered: Jun '02
43742_Obi-Wan Kenobi
Date Posted: 7/20/03 9:41pm Subject: RE: mace windu is the jedi traitor. proof here!
Did you take the time to read my whole post?

I said that even without reading Shatterpoint or knowing it exists, the point can be portrayed on screen.

As I said, Mace can try to get accross the point that Anakin is the only one that can win the war, and that Anakin is more important than the Jedi.

He can point out that if Anakin really is the Chosen One, then Anakin is the one who will bring balance to the Force, not the rest of the Jedi.

Even if the book didn't exist, the theory still makes sense. No, I'm not saying that's what we'll see in the movie, I'm presenting it as a theory.

Who is to say that someone wouldn't have thought of this idea anyway? Instead of looking to the deeper meaning of my post, you concentrated on the fact that I posted an excerpt from the EU that supports the films.

 

-----signature-----
I steal candy from babies to prevent childhood obesity.
Locked Topic | Active Topic Notification | Private Message | Post History
effortless_skill  3902 posts
Registered: Mar '03
18648_Mace Windu
Date Posted: 7/21/03 10:51am Subject: RE: mace windu is the jedi traitor. proof here!
blaze of glory it will be hasn't any one read rick's hyper space chat ? he says mace windu's scenes are unforgetable ,that almot made me cry cause mace windu's death has to special

 

-----signature-----
True Skill comes with out Effort | Li Mui Bai CROUCHING TIGER
Mace Windu is The Most Gifted Lightsaber user Ever.
Count Dooku Was never Second to Yoda....
Mace Windu Owns All.....
Locked Topic | Active Topic Notification | Private Message | Post History
Mr_Sith  6459 posts
Registered: Jun '03
42090_Darth Revan
Date Posted: 7/21/03 1:34pm Subject: RE: mace windu is the jedi traitor. proof here!
I know. I was just saying that Mace WONT be a Traitor.

 

-----signature-----
So I see, said the blind man....
*Winner of the Third Installment of the '05 Jedi Draft*
Locked Topic | Active Topic Notification | Private Message | Post History
Devilanse  5148 posts
Registered: May '02
6609_Anakin Skywalker
Date Posted: 7/21/03 1:36pm Subject: RE: mace windu is the jedi traitor. proof here!
What happens when Episode 3 is released and Mace is shown not to be a traitor?


But but but but but but but....

What if it shows that he is? If you think this thread is garbage, then why post? Adding little smart aleck comments won't make you right.

Its a 2-way street here. Everyone is allowed to have their own crackpot theories if they want to. If you can't make simple honest discussion about it....don't post.

Why can't Mace be the bad egg? George did promise a dazzling twist in the story centered around what could be a turncoat in the midst of the Jedi ranks.

Could he have been talking about Dooku? Probably...but that doesn't make anyone else's ideas about the story any less valid than yours...unless you happen to have the completed EIII script in your hands at this moment.

 

-----signature-----
WAR!
laugh
Locked Topic | Active Topic Notification | Private Message | Post History
Mr_Sith  6459 posts
Registered: Jun '03
42090_Darth Revan
Date Posted: 7/21/03 6:58pm Subject: RE: mace windu is the jedi traitor. proof here!
Its a 2-way street here. Everyone is allowed to have their own crackpot theories if they want to. If you can't make simple honest discussion about it....don't post.

The Thread Title is Called "mace windu is the jedi traitor. proof here!"

There is no proof. We are making a simple Honest Discussion about it. While it is still possible he is a Traitor, we've shown more proof that he isn't than you have that he is.

Bad Guys do not go out in a Blaze of Glory.

 

-----signature-----
So I see, said the blind man....
*Winner of the Third Installment of the '05 Jedi Draft*
Locked Topic | Active Topic Notification | Private Message | Post History