Author Topic: The Jedi Way - Jedi Discussion Thread - What Do Jedi Eat?
ardavenport 
Registered: Dec '04
22348_Luke Skywalker
Date Posted: 4/1 4:52pm Subject: RE: The Jedi Way - Jedi Discussion Thread: Living in the Galaxy or Who Pays for All That?
Well, maybe the Jedi aren't quite 'living it up' at the Temple. There are probably a lot of things that make the Jedi lifestyle less appealing to the general public no matter how lavish the Temple looks.

- no relationships allowed
- no parties
- no possessions
- no intoxicants (legal or illegal)
- only intellectual or quiet hobbies allowed, excluding violent martial arts
- no furniture (lots of space in the Temple, but they seem to like big empty spaces)


LadyLunas posted:
A fair portion of the budget would probably go to utilities (power, sewage, water, etc.). One could even stretch that to include food (Coruscant being what it is), even if the Jedi do try to make themselves as self-sufficient as possible. The other parts would be Temple upkeep, service to the small fleet of ships they have, and necessary goods (clothing, etc.). I don't think the Jedi would draw a salary, but they could possibly have a very small yearly stipend determined by rank.


I've speculated that Jedi are given a stipend of some kind, partly for practical reasons of just getting around outside the Temple and partly for appearances if the Republic didn't comprehend not paying them. OTOH, Jedi could be like monks who are not allowed to own even money. They are obviously allowed to USE money on missions as we saw in TPM, but it is possible that they personally don't receive any money at all.

LadyLunas posted:
There's probably also a section of the budget (either Senate or Jedi, haven't been able to figure out which) set aside to fund the missions. Qui-Gon had a credit amount issued to him in TPM. Probably the Republic, as the Jedi work under that name. But would that be from the Judicial Department budget, then? Or the Senate, as that's who the Order appears to be directly answering to in RotS.


Can you imagine the Jedi having to show up at the Senate budget committee? Or an audit about what they spend on the annual budget for missions? The money would have to originate from the Senate, but it's possibly administered through the Judiciary budget. I strongly suspect that this was changed to the Chancellor's office during the Clone Wars.

LadyLunas posted:
As for suspicions of and about Jedi, I would think it varies planet to plant and person to person. Those people who have come in contact with Jedi, who have been affected positively in some manner, would be far more willing to accept them. People impacted negatively, as well as those who have only heard the stories, would be far more skeptical. It's all perspectives and prejudices. What is the truth?


I think that there are probably a lot of misconceptions about Jedi, most of them harmless, but a few of them exaggerated. Padme, an educated senator, thought that Jedi were 'not allowed to love' which is a bit of a simplification, but does make me think that even people who work in proximity of Jedi don't really understand them.

 

-----signature-----
Links to all fics -- http://boards.theforce.net/Message.aspx?topic=25405090&brd=10304&start=26223917
The Heart of the Jedi -- http://boards.theforce.net/b/b1/26013327
---- Qui-Gon, Obi-Wan, JA and everything you wanted to know about lightsabers
Post Reply | Quote Reply | Active Topic Notification | Private Message | Post History
Darthbane2007 
Registered: Oct '07
13725_Lando and Han
Date Posted: 4/1 5:00pm Subject: RE: The Jedi Way - Jedi Discussion Thread: Living in the Galaxy or Who Pays for All That?
ardavenport posted:
Well, maybe the Jedi aren't quite 'living it up' at the Temple. There are probably a lot of things that make the Jedi lifestyle less appealing to the general public no matter how lavish the Temple looks.

- no relationships allowed
- no parties
- no possessions
- no intoxicants (legal or illegal)
- only intellectual or quiet hobbies allowed, excluding violent martial arts
- no furniture (lots of space in the Temple, but they seem to like big empty spaces)




Oh come on, you know they break out the booze and lower the disco ball when nobody is looking on friday nights!

 

Post Reply | Quote Reply | Active Topic Notification | Private Message | Post History
LadyLunas 
Registered: Aug '05
19077_Princess Leia
Date Posted: 4/1 9:22pm Subject: RE: The Jedi Way - Jedi Discussion Thread: Living in the Galaxy or Who Pays for All That?
ardavenport posted:

I think that there are probably a lot of misconceptions about Jedi, most of them harmless, but a few of them exaggerated. Padme, an educated senator, thought that Jedi were 'not allowed to love' which is a bit of a simplification, but does make me think that even people who work in proximity of Jedi don't really understand them.



So true! And it just reminds me of a passage in Ambush at Corellia where Mon Mothma and Luke are talking about the future of the Jedi Order. This was published way back in '95, so I don't know how much (if any) of the text had information from the Prequel Trilogy influencing it. But Mothma, looking back on it from a post-Prequel world, I am utterly amazed at what she's saying - don't let the Jedi distance themselves from the population, but make them be a part of it.

It all ties in together, what we're discussing. What the Jedi are is not necessarily what the public sees. They see a small group of religious warriors who never seem to mingle, never seem to have any emotion, and do the bidding of the government. If they did "let loose" and relax, it would be in private, so the individual Jedi would not embarrass the Order or themselves. They don't let themselves be seen as "human", due in large part to training, but also due to tradition.

Viewed in this light, Mothma was warning Luke not to follow in the steps of the old Order, and not to make the same mistakes they did. It's experience talking. If the old Order had been able to relax their traditions, the galaxy could have been a much different place.

 

-----signature-----
Darth Real Life hates me. Therefore, I battle him constantly.
Currently, he's winning. So I'm lurking.
Beginnings: http://boards.theforce.net/the_saga/b10476/23441427/p1/?0
Normal students? In the Jedi Temple? Read USJS!
Padawan of SakuraTsukikage.
Post Reply | Quote Reply | Active Topic Notification | Private Message | Post History
Darthbane2007 
Registered: Oct '07
13725_Lando and Han
Date Posted: 4/6 7:18am Subject: RE: The Jedi Way - Jedi Discussion Thread: Living in the Galaxy or Who Pays for All That?
Which brings me to my next question: How do Jedi, particular of the old republic, do for fun? Did the temple have some sort of Gym/Recreational area, where the Jedi would spend their off time from missions as such?

 

Post Reply | Quote Reply | Active Topic Notification | Private Message | Post History
Alexis_Wingstar 
Title: PT Rewrite Contest Winner
Registered: Sep '06
6596_Luke Skywalker
Date Posted: 4/6 8:32am Subject: RE: The Jedi Way - Jedi Discussion Thread: Living in the Galaxy or Who Pays for All That?
Darthbane2007 posted:
Which brings me to my next question: How do Jedi, particular of the old republic, do for fun? Did the temple have some sort of Gym/Recreational area, where the Jedi would spend their off time from missions as such?


[voice=borg]Fun is irrelevant.[/voice]





















































tongue

 

-----signature-----
"Change. It can be good. It can be bad. It can be expected or come as a thief in the night. Invited or not, it always comes."
~Koria Rimstar-Cor
"Tender Shadows", co-written w/ The Musical Jedi
See my profile for links to this and my other fanfics
Post Reply | Quote Reply | Active Topic Notification | Private Message | Post History
ardavenport 
Registered: Dec '04
22348_Luke Skywalker
Date Posted: 4/6 8:15pm Subject: RE: The Jedi Way - Jedi Discussion Thread: Living in the Galaxy or Who Pays for All That?
Darthbane2007 posted:
Oh come on, you know they break out the booze and lower the disco ball when nobody is looking on friday nights!


While I don't consider Jedi to be such killjoys as to be Borg-like tongue I am awfully strict with them in my fics. So, no wild parties. If Jedi were asked to host a party it would turn out to be more like a wine and brie thing.


LadyLunas posted:
So true! And it just reminds me of a passage in Ambush at Corellia where Mon Mothma and Luke are talking about the future of the Jedi Order. This was published way back in '95, so I don't know how much (if any) of the text had information from the Prequel Trilogy influencing it. But Mothma, looking back on it from a post-Prequel world, I am utterly amazed at what she's saying - don't let the Jedi distance themselves from the population, but make them be a part of it.


I haven't read that one. If it was '95 then it's just coincidence that it fits in well with the PT. Everything about TPM was Top Secret before it came out (though I was too busy avoiding spoilers then to know for sure) and Lucas wasn't even finished writing it in '95.

It's a timely warning for Luke and new Jedi Order. But I think it would be hard to follow. The nature of the Jedi and their philosophy to selflessly serve others with the Force naturally leads to some separation. And I think their 'no attachments' rule evolved because of past problems. The 'no possessions' wouldn't separate them so much from non-Jedi, but the 'no personal attachments' would. But if Jedi become involved with someone then that puts that person at serious risk. Just look at how Vader got Luke to Bespin in TESB.

At the end of the NJO series Luke decides to de-couple the Jedi from the Republic government. I think THAT would definitely be an improvement. That was at the heart of their downfall.

In retrospect, when the Republic was breaking up, the Jedi should have let it and not gotten into that. This probably would have led to a huge upheaval in the Order, possibly fracturing it with some leaving Coruscant or maybe them all getting kicked off (especially with Palpatine running things), but they would not have been so vulnerable if they were scattered. And viewed from a distance, they might have figured out what Palpatine was.

But the Jedi Order tried to hang onto their old arrangement when they didn't see that they needed to change and that did them in.

Darthbane2007 posted:
Which brings me to my next question: How do Jedi, particular of the old republic, do for fun? Did the temple have some sort of Gym/Recreational area, where the Jedi would spend their off time from missions as such?



That's a tough question. It would certainly depend on the individual and their species. Things that Jedi might do for fun:

- Reading
- Art (though anything produced like paintings or carvings would have to be given away)
- gardening
- non-competitive sports
- cooking
- academic topics like history, literature, philosophy
- music
- lying on warm beaches
- camping / picnicking
- puzzles

Things that they might be allowed to do with limitations:
- hunting
- competitive games
- performing
- attending performances
- fattening foods
- animal care

Things that Jedi would be forbidden to do:
- gambling (when not on duty tongue )
- addictions
- collecting beer bottles
- collecting anything
- night-clubbing
- eating competitions
- selling anything
- blowing things up (again, when not on duty)
- pets (in terms of ownership)

However, I think that being a Jedi is mostly a full-time occupation and hobby and that Force abilities require constant practice to keep them active, like an athlete keeping in shape. So, that won't leave a lot of time for other activities.

 

-----signature-----
Links to all fics -- http://boards.theforce.net/Message.aspx?topic=25405090&brd=10304&start=26223917
The Heart of the Jedi -- http://boards.theforce.net/b/b1/26013327
---- Qui-Gon, Obi-Wan, JA and everything you wanted to know about lightsabers
Post Reply | Quote Reply | Active Topic Notification | Private Message | Post History
Darthbane2007 
Registered: Oct '07
13725_Lando and Han
Date Posted: 4/7 11:10am Subject: RE: The Jedi Way - Jedi Discussion Thread: Living in the Galaxy or Who Pays for All That?
ardavenport posted:
Darthbane2007 posted:
Oh come on, you know they break out the booze and lower the disco ball when nobody is looking on friday nights!


While I don't consider Jedi to be such killjoys as to be Borg-like tongue I am awfully strict with them in my fics. So, no wild parties. If Jedi were asked to host a party it would turn out to be more like a wine and brie thing.

Who drinks wine anymore?!






ardavenport posted:
Darthbane2007 posted:
Which brings me to my next question: How do Jedi, particular of the old republic, do for fun? Did the temple have some sort of Gym/Recreational area, where the Jedi would spend their off time from missions as such?



That's a tough question. It would certainly depend on the individual and their species. Things that Jedi might do for fun:

- Reading
- Art (though anything produced like paintings or carvings would have to be given away)
- gardening
- non-competitive sports
- cooking
- academic topics like history, literature, philosophy
- music
- lying on warm beaches
- camping / picnicking
- puzzles

Things that they might be allowed to do with limitations:
- hunting
- competitive games
- performing
- attending performances
- fattening foods
- animal care

Things that Jedi would be forbidden to do:
- gambling (when not on duty tongue )
- addictions
- collecting beer bottles
- collecting anything
- night-clubbing
- eating competitions
- selling anything
- blowing things up (again, when not on duty)
- pets (in terms of ownership)

However, I think that being a Jedi is mostly a full-time occupation and hobby and that Force abilities require constant practice to keep them active, like an athlete keeping in shape. So, that won't leave a lot of time for other activities.




So the Jedi are like mindless robots?

 

Post Reply | Quote Reply | Active Topic Notification | Private Message | Post History
The_Face 
Title: Fan Fic Manager, now with real butter flavor
Registered: Feb '03
6345_Wraith Squadron
Date Posted: 4/7 3:08pm Subject: RE: The Jedi Way - Jedi Discussion Thread: Living in the Galaxy or Who Pays for All That?
More like members of the clergy.

Or more accurately/less relatably, monks. The Force is a "hokey religion", and they're its devoted followers. They spend a lot of time meditating, they train in a martial art, they learn more about this mystic force from their elder members, they wear nifty brown robes... Pop the Temple onto a mountain in Tibet and they'll fit right in. And they were raised in this lifestyle from extremely young ages (Anakin was, what, nine when he was "too old"?).

Yes, the Jedi are real people with flaws and individual personalities and desires, but they are also (from infancy) part of an ancient monastic order of galactic peace-keepers. It's important not to swing too far in either direction (robotic or overly loose). You can distinguish a real character without having them get wasted Saturday nights.

 

-----signature-----
What's up with the 'now with more real butter flavor'??
- Frieda
*
Galaxy of Suspects, a CorSec Mystery: http://boards.theforce.net/Message.aspx?topic=28083207&brd=10476
Post Reply | Quote Reply | Active Topic Notification | Private Message | Post History
ardavenport 
Registered: Dec '04
22348_Luke Skywalker
Date Posted: 4/7 4:27pm Subject: RE: The Jedi Way - Jedi Discussion Thread: Living in the Galaxy or Who Pays for All That?
Darthbane2007 posted:
Who drinks wine anymore?!


Well, I'll bet that crowd at the opera in ROTS drinks it by the tank! But since this is the GFFA it's probably blue wine. mischief


The_Face posted:
Or more accurately/less relatably, monks. The Force is a "hokey religion", and they're its devoted followers. They spend a lot of time meditating, they train in a martial art, they learn more about this mystic force from their elder members, they wear nifty brown robes... Pop the Temple onto a mountain in Tibet and they'll fit right in. And they were raised in this lifestyle from extremely young ages (Anakin was, what, nine when he was "too old"?).

Yes, the Jedi are real people with flaws and individual personalities and desires, but they are also (from infancy) part of an ancient monastic order of galactic peace-keepers. It's important not to swing too far in either direction (robotic or overly loose). You can distinguish a real character without having them get wasted Saturday nights.


Agreed! Lucas was very un-subtle about patterning the jedi after shaolin(or howeever it's spelled) monks. Jedi occupy a bizzare niche of being both clergy and law enforcement in the Old Republic. And the requirements for that a pretty demanding.

But you'll still have a wide variety of personalities among any group of Jedi. They would certainly all socialize in different ways. That would not be affected by them all adhering to a Jedi code that forbids material possessions and attachments.




 

-----signature-----
Links to all fics -- http://boards.theforce.net/Message.aspx?topic=25405090&brd=10304&start=26223917
The Heart of the Jedi -- http://boards.theforce.net/b/b1/26013327
---- Qui-Gon, Obi-Wan, JA and everything you wanted to know about lightsabers
Post Reply | Quote Reply | Active Topic Notification | Private Message | Post History
Darthbane2007 
Registered: Oct '07
13725_Lando and Han
Date Posted: 4/18 9:06am Subject: RE: The Jedi Way - Jedi Discussion Thread: Living in the Galaxy or Who Pays for All That?
dianethx posted:
I haven't really made anything up. It frustrates me that there's very little real information as to living quarters and if the Padawans live with their masters or not. There seems to be barracks in the Complete locations book. So I can't figure out if it's more barracks or more individual rooms.

What I want to know is how long it would take to get from one side of the Temple to the other. What if you had to get somewhere fast? I know there were horizontal turbolifts but surely they must have done a heck of a lot of walking!


I know this question that mioght be old, but has there ever been a story or info about the Jedi Temple in Star Wars Insider yet?

Because I think that some sort of story is due. It could tell us a little more about the temple in general.

 

Post Reply | Quote Reply | Active Topic Notification | Private Message | Post History
Darthbane2007 
Registered: Oct '07
13725_Lando and Han
Date Posted: 4/29 9:38am Subject: RE: The Jedi Way - Jedi Discussion Thread: Living in the Galaxy or Who Pays for All That?
Another question I have is, When the Jedi are/were bought to the temple, were they already named or do the Jedi name them as soon as they arrive? For all we know, Obi-Wan could have been named Baloo Babaloo, and the Jedi decided to change it to Kenobi.

 

Post Reply | Quote Reply | Active Topic Notification | Private Message | Post History
dreamshell 
Registered: Apr '08
23701_Luke's Hand
Date Posted: 4/29 1:44pm Subject: RE: The Jedi Way - Jedi Discussion Thread: Living in the Galaxy or Who Pays for All That? - Date Edited: 4/29 1:56pm (1 edits total) Edited By: dreamshell
The only case of the Jedi naming a child that I know of is Baby Ludi Billane, who they renamed Aris-Del Wari;

http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Aris-Del_Wari

"After the groundquake of Ord Thoden, a team of Jedi rescue workers found a Force-sensitive child in the ruins of the Ord Thoden capital Domitree. Presuming the child's parents to be dead, the Jedi named the child Aris-Del Wari and decided to train her in the ways of the Force."

It doesn't end there, though;

"When Jonava Billane recovered and learned her child, Ludi, had survived and been rescued by the Jedi, she traveled to Coruscant and petitioned to be reunited with her daughter. However, the Jedi Council rejected her petition, arguing that giving back the child to her would be too dangerous now that the baby's mind had been opened to the Force."

Reactions were mixed;

http://www.holonetnews.com/46/jediwatch/1337_1.html

I'm obsessed with this incident, because I think it gives insight into a huge flaw in the Order and its policies. The resulting anti-Jediism is, in my opinion, very understandable.

 

-----signature-----
"The Jedi... the Sith... you don't get it, do you? To the galaxy, they're the same thing; just men and women with too much power, squabbling over religion, while the rest of us burn." -- Atton Rand
Post Reply | Quote Reply | Active Topic Notification | Private Message | Post History
G__Anakin 
Registered: Apr '06
43741_Fan Art - Jedi Padawan
Date Posted: 4/29 1:49pm Subject: RE: The Jedi Way - Jedi Discussion Thread: Living in the Galaxy or Who Pays for All That?
Darthbane2007 posted:
Another question I have is, When the Jedi are/were bought to the temple, were they already named or do the Jedi name them as soon as they arrive? For all we know, Obi-Wan could have been named Baloo Babaloo, and the Jedi decided to change it to Kenobi.


Whie kept his name.

 

-----signature-----
Knighted by Courtney_Solo hugs
- - - My fanfic - - -
Jedi Sith - http://boards.theforce.net/Message.aspx?topic=26751105&brd=10476&start=26759554
Post Reply | Quote Reply | Active Topic Notification | Private Message | Post History
Darthbane2007 
Registered: Oct '07
13725_Lando and Han
Date Posted: 4/29 2:07pm Subject: RE: The Jedi Way - Jedi Discussion Thread: Living in the Galaxy or Who Pays for All That?
dreamshell posted:
The only case of the Jedi naming a child that I know of is Baby Ludi Billane, who they renamed Aris-Del Wari;

http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Aris-Del_Wari

"After the groundquake of Ord Thoden, a team of Jedi rescue workers found a Force-sensitive child in the ruins of the Ord Thoden capital Domitree. Presuming the child's parents to be dead, the Jedi named the child Aris-Del Wari and decided to train her in the ways of the Force."

It doesn't end there, though;

"When Jonava Billane recovered and learned her child, Ludi, had survived and been rescued by the Jedi, she traveled to Coruscant and petitioned to be reunited with her daughter. However, the Jedi Council rejected her petition, arguing that giving back the child to her would be too dangerous now that the baby's mind had been opened to the Force."

Reactions were mixed;

http://www.holonetnews.com/46/jediwatch/1337_1.html

I'm obsessed with this incident, because I think it gives insight into a huge flaw in the Order and its policies. The resulting anti-Jediism is, in my opinion, very understandable.


Of course, it also goes to say that the mother had a couple of supporters try to storm the Jedi Temple, but Yoda or some other jedi stopped them with a mind trick. Afterwards, the mother was too busy trying to sign deals to make a Holo-movie about her situation to care about the baby, which was still taken by the Jedi to some location off Coruscant to continue Jedi training.

But that does raise the question. When looking for potential Jedi, before the whole ruusan reformation, how did Jedi go getting new members? Did that include getting force sensitive children, or did they go to different locations, like a Military Recruitment thing like us, and test potential people to see if they have a high Midi-Count?

 

Post Reply | Quote Reply | Active Topic Notification | Private Message | Post History
dreamshell 
Registered: Apr '08
23701_Luke's Hand
Date Posted: 4/29 3:36pm Subject: RE: The Jedi Way - Jedi Discussion Thread: Living in the Galaxy or Who Pays for All That?
Oh, I'm not saying the mother wasn't despicable too, but the way the Jedi simply refused to hand over a child to its own mother is plenty reason for contempt.

 

-----signature-----
"The Jedi... the Sith... you don't get it, do you? To the galaxy, they're the same thing; just men and women with too much power, squabbling over religion, while the rest of us burn." -- Atton Rand
Post Reply | Quote Reply | Active Topic Notification | Private Message | Post History