Author Topic: SOS: Save Our Skywalker, Luke Skywalker (v3)
Charlemagne19  26816 posts
Registered: Jul '00
6408_Jedi Outcast
Date Posted: 4/26/08 5:36pm Subject: RE: SOS: Save Our Skywalker, Luke Skywalker (v3)
NewStaryknight posted:


My point is, if we the fans, who are not professional writers, can think up scenarios and plots for Luke to get into for future books, then the likely hood that they can be thought up by the actual people who write stories like these for a living increases IMHO.


Well I am a professional author. happy

Just a so far unsucessful one.

:-)

But yes, I have faith Troy will do something INTERESTING, I just worry that so far we've seen less than we could have.

 

Post Reply | Quote Reply | Active Topic Notification | Private Message | Post History
NewStaryknight  1217 posts
Registered: Dec '07
14372_Leia and Luke
Date Posted: 4/26/08 5:38pm Subject: RE: SOS: Save Our Skywalker, Luke Skywalker (v3) - Date Edited: 4/26/08 5:39pm (1 edits total) Edited By: NewStaryknight
Charlemagne19 posted:
If I had to give ten examples of a Post-LOTF set of adventures, they'd probably look like this.

10 Post-Legacy of the Force Luke Plots

1. Luke Skywalker goes on a mission to deal with a large number of Jacen Solo Loyalists who've seized a massive fleet around Adumar and its infrastructure to making bombs (they intend to conduct a terror campaign across the galaxy in Jacen's name). Luke has to deal with his feelings towards his nephew's mass murder of so many people and insane philosophy. We gain a depth of feeling for Luke feeling he's lost a son, failed Jacen Solo as a mentor, and his own inner torment.

After Luke is nearly killed (the GAG bomb Luke Skywalker from the skies---which even Luke is hard pressed to survive), he's visited by the ghost of his father who helps him come to terms with this loss.

2. Luke Skywalker is dead! That's what the headlines read as the Jedi Council fear their mentor has been killed. The Jedi are thrown into chaos as a young padawan is adopted by a mysterious Jedi Master known as "Biggs." We get an outsiders' view from the little girl on the New Jedi Order. The Jedi Council must cope with a terrorist plot by Chiss Joiners to blow up the temple.

In truth, Luke Skywalker used his Fallassai illusions to fake his death as a test for the Jedi. The Jedi Council proves it can function without him and Luke resumes his place, with his new padawan. However, Luke also says that from now on, he's going to feel free to go where the Force wills him on missions that he feels need his touch.

Kyp Durron is named "Senior Jedi Master" under the Grandmaster and manages the Council when Luke's off kicking butt.

3. Luke Skywalker finds himself face to face with Darth Krayt. Darth Krayt takes Luke Skywalker to Dromuund Kaas and the Sith Lord blasts Luke Skywalker for his constant failures to bring peace to the galaxy. The two duel as Krayt wages a cat and mouse game using his various students as pawns. Luke Skywalker slays most of them before facing down Krayt. Krayt is badly wounded as Luke says that it's not his responsibility to bring peace to the galaxy, it's his responsibility to TRY TO and to keep working at it no matter what.

Krayt has a "ambiguous death" as Luke has wounded him that he must enter a healing trance for a century.

4. Luke Skywalker heads to the Unknown Regions and finds himself face to face with the Celestials, a vast race of ancient and powerful beings that have enough power to devastate the whole of the galaxy with their vast Star Forge like manufacturing units and huge armies of superpowerful droids (including Landos Vuffi Raa). The Chiss have been fighting them for thousands of years.

To totally subvert the usual cliches, Luke Skywalker successfully discovers the resting place of the original Celestials (a race of Near-Humans and awakens them), thus ending the huge galaxy spanning war before it begins.

5. Luke Skywalker has a most unusual moment where a bunch of GAG terrorists go to elaborate lengths to steal Luke's hairbrush off all things. Tracking them down, he finds they're part of the Cult of Vergere that reveres the Sith Pigeon's teachings and were Lumiya's former followers. Luke discovers they intended to create a super-child from Luke's DNA and Lumiya's to once more carry out their Sith dreams. Luke confronts Vergeres and Lumiya's Sith ghosts in their ancient temple on the Dxun's Moon.

In the end, Luke Skywalker defeats them as he makes his peace with their ghosts (Lumiya's spirit actually apologizing to him for all the pain she caused him) and Luke forgiving her. Then he breaks up the cult before taking their children to better lives.

6. Luke Skywalker discovers Callista has been murdered! Rushing almost immediately to her side, he finds that this is a trap instead by a Corporate Sector Authority Executive whom believes Luke Skywalker as a Jedi Knight possesses an ability to cure the Executive's incurable disease. He finds that Callista actually isn't dead when he discovers that she's in fact a prisoner and meets her daughter, a Jedi Knight that she trained herself. There's some back and forth as to whether Callista's daughter is Luke's child and they deal with the topic frankly. Ultimately, she has a father though and they eventually defeat the executive's horde of Dark Side creatures taken from Korriban and weird traps he's set up.

In the end, Luke helps the man by allowing him to suffer no pain and foresees after his forgiveness that he'll devote the rest of his life to making the galaxy a better place.

7. Luke finds himself marooned on a planet wracked by a brutal occupation by Killik Joiners that have seperated from the Hive and adopted the worst elements of Imperials. In truth, Luke discovers they're attempting to gain the individuality of humans. Luke can't fight an entire Killik planet by himself but leads the resistance against them and we get a reminder of Luke the Rebel in miniature.

In the end, he manages to seperate all of the Joiners from the Nest Queen's leadership before destroying her. Strangely, the Ex-Joiner that Luke Skywalker has a romance with decides to help them reach the stars and teach them about individuality.

8. Luke Skywalker has to deal with the most awkward challenge of his career. Luke Skywalker discovers that because of his defeat of Supreme Overlord Shimmra and the Resurrected Palpatine, a Cult has emerged around Luke (though one might genuinely call it a religion since it spans several worlds at this point). A lot of humor is derived from the fact that Luke finds out about his father's supposed Virgin Birth here and while he intends to set them straight, he'd disturbed that a lot of the leaders of the cult were people he'd saved in the past and are genuinely looking for meaning in a ravaged galaxy.

Luke discovers and thwarts a plot by Die Hard Imperial Loyalists to poison the majority of Luke Skywalker's faith in order to turn Galactic sympathy against him. In the end, he reaffirms that he's just a man and that he hopes they'll revere the values he holds rather than him. Thus, his religion turns to veneration of the Force itself.

Some funny romantic tension with the female religious leader who adores Luke as a moral guide.

9. Another funny "You don't see Luke Skywalker in many situations like this" moment, which is what I think authors should do more of instead of rehashing old plots. Luke Skywalker has been left the entire fortune of Tagge Co. by its last surviving Baron. Suddenly a multi-quadrillionaire, Luke intends to sell his shares and set up a foundation to help rebuild Post-Yuuzhan Vong damage.

Luke, unsurprisingly, is betrayed by the Tagge heirs who he finds out hate him because he destroyed the Empire/killed Baron Tagge/destroyed the Yuuzhan Vong when they collaborated/defeated Jacen Solo and thus pretty much ruined their fortunes. Thus, they intend to clone Luke and use his good name to rebuild their Empire. Luke rather easilly defeats the spoiled brats despite their armies of mercenaries before finding out that they're just the front men for the Last of the Emperor's High inquisitors.

Tremayne has set up explosives or some similiar moral trap all over the city of Tagge with the usual supervillain "Which one will you save" business. In the end, Luke realizes, Tremayne wants Luke to kill him because he has nothing else. Luke denies him this final dignity and the last of the Emperor's Dark Jedi takes his own life.

10. Luke Skywalker is infected by a Yuuzhan Vong disease quite by accident that strips him of his Force Powers for the better part of three months until his body forces out the disease. Luke insists on carrying out his duties as normal and ends up on a comedy of errors where with a grown beard, no one recognizes him and we get to see Luke on the other side of the law when he ends up "commandeering" a smuggler's ship to go chase after one of Jacen Solo's few remaining War Criminal Henchmen.

Luke briefly flirts with a widowed mother that's part of the ships crew (much like "Dark Times" heroine)



Like these Charles. These are great ideas. You should give DR a resume. peace

 

Post Reply | Quote Reply | Active Topic Notification | Private Message | Post History
ChildOfWinds  6266 posts
Registered: Apr '01
14696_Luke Skywalker
Date Posted: 4/26/08 7:09pm Subject: RE: SOS: Save Our Skywalker, Luke Skywalker (v3)

Emperor_Time :

I think it because Zayne acts like a model jedi like Luke whereas Cade does whatever he feels like,

Unfortunately, Luke hasn't exactly been written like a "model Jedi" in LotF. sad He was shown as irrationally angry in Sacrifice when Lumiya brought Ben's boots, and, of course, he killed Lumiya for revenge. sad Plus, I don't exactly think that kidnapping people, as in Betrayal, is what a Jedi should be doing. And we have him attacking Jacen in Inferno (after seeing Ben in the Embrace of Pain) before Jacen makes the first move.

I'm really disappointed that Luke HASN'T been written as a model Jedi. Now when he's the Jedi Grandmaster, you would think that he would especially be portrayed as a great example for the other Jedi.

Lord_Riven :

LR, I certainly don't mind that you enjoy reading about Cade. I know that you also enjoy reading about Luke. You can certainly be a fan of more that one character.

I was just lamenting the fact that it seems that a great many posters on these boards no longer want to read about Luke Skywalker. They want him to be killed off or put into a supporting, background role. Meanwhile, many of those same people can't get enough of Cade. C19 had been discussing a "make-over" for Luke for the "modern fan". Unfortunately, if that were done, I fear the character would be remade more like Cade. Anti-heroes, and dark, very flawed, morally ambiguous characters seem to be the rage today.

For myself, I prefer a more "straight-arrow" hero, who always does what is right, no matter how difficult it may be, and who has a strong moral compass which keeps him on the right path. As I said in my response to ET above, I'm annoyed that the books have been turning Luke into a more "grey" character who makes some morally bad choices. I really wish this hadn't been done. I think it has really hurt the character.

We've had a lot of Luke, and I'm sure most people enjoy Luke being heroic and kicking butt, but that said, he's the bread and butter of Star Wars.

I don't think that a lot of people believe that anymore. You and I may agree that no character will probably ever really replace Luke, but I think we're in the minority. sad

And I've been saying for a long time that doing mega-series is not such a good idea.

Jedi Ben

I'd say Luke is who we'd like to think we'd be if put in his position while Cade is who'd we'd probably be,

I hope I wouldn't be like Cade! wink

Rather the question raised is what potential for heroism exists in such a battered individual? For while few of us have Cade's experience of life, lots of people do feel battered by life,

I'd say that Luke was "battered by life" too. But he didn't give up, didn't become cynical or refuse to do what he could to help others.

Part of the appeal of heroic characters is they get to change the world for the better which isn't something people see happening in their own lives, no matter how much they may want to.

Good point!

Of the two characters, Cade is the better to explore these themes with, but the idea that that means being opposed to Luke is something of a false construct to me.

That's not what I was trying to say. I was just saying that today's readers seem to prefer to read about the rogues, anti-heroes, morally ambiguous characters like Cade, than the heroic, "good guy", who does what's right, who lives by a strong moral code and won't break it, as Luke used to be. I find that disappointing.

 

Post Reply | Quote Reply | Active Topic Notification | Private Message | Post History
Charlemagne19  26816 posts
Registered: Jul '00
6408_Jedi Outcast
Date Posted: 4/26/08 7:14pm Subject: RE: SOS: Save Our Skywalker, Luke Skywalker (v3)
That's not what I was trying to say. I was just saying that today's readers seem to prefer to read about the rogues, anti-heroes, morally ambiguous characters like Cade, than the heroic, "good guy", who does what's right, who lives by a strong moral code and won't break it, as Luke used to be. I find that disappointing.

rolling_eyes

Marlene, they were saying that in the 1930s.

tongue

 

Post Reply | Quote Reply | Active Topic Notification | Private Message | Post History
ChildOfWinds  6266 posts
Registered: Apr '01
14696_Luke Skywalker
Date Posted: 4/26/08 8:01pm Subject: RE: SOS: Save Our Skywalker, Luke Skywalker (v3)

Dawud786

Meanwhile, the kid is pretty kriffing chipper considering. I can't recall ever seeing him (Zayne) mope and lament the raw deal he's been given. Never saw that with Luke Skywalker either.

I agree with you. I see a lot of Luke in Zayne. Maybe that's why I like the character so much. You're right that Zayne had every reason to be cynical after what his Masters did to him, but he hasn't let the hand he's been dealt drag him down. Luke too has had a difficult life but hasn't given up.

I do hope that we'll find out someday that Zayne is an ancestor of Luke (and Leia).

Charlemagne19

You misunderstood me, C. It doesn't need to be either or. One doesn't have to dislike Luke to like Cade. I was just pointing out that Cade seems to be more popular than Luke with the posters on this board. I've seen so many posts saying that it's time for Luke to die or to turn the Grandmastership over to someone else and "retire". They want him dead or shoved into the background. I find it disappointing that so many seem to prefer the dark, brooding, rogue anti-hero that is Cade to the compassionate, responsible, slave to duty, more traditional hero, that is Luke.

In my case, I find that I am not looking forward to anything new with Luke Skywalker but the Shadows of Mindor because I'm almost certain that Del Ray is going to screw it up.

C, where's your optimism??? That comment sounds more like *me*. You're the one who usually tries to put a positive spin on things. wink

Unfortunately, except for Shadows of Mindor, you're right: It appears that there's not much to be excited about in future books if you're a Luke fan. sad Del Rey doesn't seem to have a plan for Luke. sad

I'm not "distressed" about similarities between Cade and Luke, C, because I don't think there ARE any similarities. I don't see anything of Luke in Cade, physically or in character traits. As you said, Cade is the "Anti-Luke".

However, these Expys manage to generate more interest than the original because people are willing to take chances and tell the stories that Luke Skywalker SHOULD be telling about tham than they are with the real thing.

It's frustrating to see Luke languishing in LotF and not really making any positive contributions or accomplishing anything of importance. sad

Luke will almost certainly outlast Cade Skywalker but I think a lot of the reason he has interest in him is because the similiarities of Luke rather than the differences.

Can you explain what you see as similarities between Cade and Luke?

NewStaryknight :

Just because there have been no hints of anything cool coming from Luke in the future doesn't mean there won't be.

I think Denning will do a great job with Jaina, Leia, and Han. Things don't look as good for Luke. sad I really hope I'm wrong and you're right that "Luke may end up doing something truly awesome in the book". But after eight books that haven't been very kind to Luke Skywalker, I have to say that my hopes aren't very high. But I would certainly cheer if Denning surprised me and gave Luke a really meaty, important, and competent role to finish off the series. The book is rumored to have only 299 pages though, so I don't know if that's enough page space for an interesting side role for Luke. We already know that Leia, Han, Jaina, Zekk, and Jag are going after Jacen/Caedus. sad

 

Post Reply | Quote Reply | Active Topic Notification | Private Message | Post History
NewStaryknight  1217 posts
Registered: Dec '07
14372_Leia and Luke
Date Posted: 4/26/08 9:16pm Subject: RE: SOS: Save Our Skywalker, Luke Skywalker (v3)
^^Those five characters you just mentioned are the only ones they mention in the blurb as doing anything. There are other characters like Ben, Tenel Ka, Allana, Saba, Corran, Kyp, Kyle, Niathal, and an assortment of others including Jacen/Cadeus himself. The Invincible blurb doesn't even mention them, but does that mean there not going to get a good part in the story and contribute in some way? No. Just cause it sounds like Luke may not confront Cadeus directly doesn't mean he won't play a role. I agree he may not get to be the big hero at the end, but I'm sure he'll do something. NJO had Luke be inactive for the most part but when the last book came he went all out, so hopefully we get the same thing (I mean we already got the big death in the family in the middle of the series again so why stop there)?

 

Post Reply | Quote Reply | Active Topic Notification | Private Message | Post History
Charlemagne19  26816 posts
Registered: Jul '00
6408_Jedi Outcast
Date Posted: 4/26/08 9:39pm Subject: RE: SOS: Save Our Skywalker, Luke Skywalker (v3)
Well on a short list.

1. They're both blonde.

2. They're both in their early twenties.

3. They have the last name Skywalker.

4. They were both orphaned as teenagers.

5. They're both Force Sensitives with legendary levels of power.

6. They both are motivated to their heroic moments by a brown haired Princess who they seem to adore.

7. They both own R2-D2.

8. They both are being educated by Ghosts who tell them to pursue the higher calling of the Jedi Knight.

9. They both witnessed their mentors/father figures murdered by the Sith and reacted violently.

10. The Sith want to corrupt them more than destroy them.

11. The Jedi survivors are in disagreement whether he's their last hope or not.

12. They're both snarky towards authority.

13. They both reject the offers of the Sith but come close to succumbing to their own anger over dead family.

14. Both have their best friend being the pilot of a Tramp Freighter with an alien Co-Pilot.

15. Both have a dramatic revelation that an enemy is actually their parent.

16. Both feel it is their personal responsibility to confront the Sith (albeit for drastically different reasons)

17. Both initially reject their destiny.

18. Both are proficient in using blasters as well as lightsabers.

19. Both are also skilled pilots.

20. Both attempt to commit suicide at two points (Luke for drastically different reasons)

21. Both are the product of secret marriages by their parents.

22. Both measure themselves by deceased ancestor idols and feel themselves coming up short.

Cade's personality is certainly different from Lukes in most respects. His years of slavery mixed with the slaughter of his family have embittered Cade tremendously against the galaxy. He actively despises the universe and its populous so that he feels no real impetuous to go help the universe. Luke on the other hand was actively embracing his destiny as a hero. The bitter cynicism and self-hatred Cade Skywalker feels is really all that seperates him from Luke and that's pretty much a MAJOR divide with an idealist like Luke.

But in most respects, they're deliberately set up to be similar.

 

Post Reply | Quote Reply | Active Topic Notification | Private Message | Post History
Dawud786  2660 posts
Registered: Dec '06
42320_Luke Skywalker
Date Posted: 4/27/08 9:47am Subject: RE: SOS: Save Our Skywalker, Luke Skywalker (v3)
You know, with all the talk earlier of re-introducing Luke Skywalker... here's my thought on this, and I hope it works out: I want to see the Thrawn Trilogy animated and released directly to DVD like Marvel and DC have been doing with some stuff. To me that's the best way to provide a jumping on point for all this continuity, and reintroduce the character. TTT is the perfect thing to do it with because they could adapt the comic adaptations instead of the novels directly. The comics already have the cinematic streamlining down. Or they could do Dark Empire I & II, maybe even Empire's End and make it BETTER. They could even make it retcon the fiasco to make it fit better with what people think the Balance of the Force should mean for Palpatine and his clones. Like, confirm Mara's suspicions that they were all just delusional clones and Lumiya's belief that they weren't actually Sith because they didn't earn it through struggle and training... it was just downloaded into them.

Stang, they could even do a streamlined NJO that way.

My suspicion, if the Clone Wars cartoon is successful we could possibly see this. It would work, they have to know it would. I'm sure the Marvel animated features are selling well... how much better would Star Wars do?

 

-----signature-----
Post Reply | Quote Reply | Active Topic Notification | Private Message | Post History
ChildOfWinds  6266 posts
Registered: Apr '01
14696_Luke Skywalker
Date Posted: 4/27/08 12:10pm Subject: RE: SOS: Save Our Skywalker, Luke Skywalker (v3)

Charlemagne19 :
CoW: I was just saying that today's readers seem to prefer to read about the rogues, anti-heroes, morally ambiguous characters like Cade, than the heroic, "good guy", who does what's right, who lives by a strong moral code and won't break it, as Luke used to be. I find that disappointing.

C19: they were saying that in the 1930s.


Then they're still doing that, C! Definitely time for a change! tongue

Well on a short list.

applause applause applause Amazing, C!!! I never thought anyone could come up with so many similarities between Luke and Cade. To me they are like night and day, complete opposites.

Some comments:

6. They both are motivated to their heroic moments by a brown haired Princess who they seem to adore.

Good point! I hadn't thought of that. I also hadn't thought about the fact that ghosts tell both of them to pursue the higher calling of being a Jedi knight and that the Jedi survivors are in disagreement over whether he's their last hope.

As for owning Artoo, I haven't read the recent issues. Is Artoo staying with Cade or is he with K'Kruhk?

12. They're both snarky towards authority.

I'd say that's more true of Cade than Luke. Luke was quite respectful of Obi-wan Kenobi and of Yoda.

13. They both reject the offers of the Sith but come close to succumbing to their own anger over dead family.

I'll admit, that's another good one as well as the point about both having their best friends the pilot of a Tramp Freighter with an alien co-pilot.

15. Both have a dramatic revelation that an enemy is actually their parent.

This was certainly true of Luke. Has Cade found out that his mother is an enemy yet?

17. Both initially reject their destiny.

Well, Luke only did this because he felt he had a responsibility and duty to his Aunt and Uncle.

20. Both attempt to commit suicide at two points (Luke for drastically different reasons)

Yes, Luke wanted to avoid becoming a Dark Lord of the Sith.

So what was the second time? Do you agree with Ben that Luke was thinking about committing suicide in Fury? Or do you mean when Luke threw away his lightsaber and was willing to be killed by Palpatine with Force lightning?

21. Both are the product of secret marriages by their parents.

Sheesh! There really ARE more similarities than I thought. Plus, as you said, they're both great pilots.

22. Both measure themselves by deceased ancestor idols and feel themselves coming up short.

So what "ancestor idol" does Luke measure himself by??? Certainly he can't want to try to "measure DOWN" to Anakin????


Cade's personality is certainly different from Lukes in most respects.

Yes, I guess it's personality that I was primarily thinking about when I said that Luke and Cade are vastly different. As you said, Luke is an idealist and he actively embraced his destiny as a hero. Luke considers it his duty and responsibility to "save" and protect the galaxy and its inhabitants. Luke is also much more compassionate and caring about others than Cade is.

So while they might have had similar situations in their backgrounds, Luke reacted to those situations very differently than Cade did. And I find Luke's personality a lot more appealing than Cade's.


 

Post Reply | Quote Reply | Active Topic Notification | Private Message | Post History
ChildOfWinds  6266 posts
Registered: Apr '01
14696_Luke Skywalker
Date Posted: 4/27/08 12:32pm Subject: RE: SOS: Save Our Skywalker, Luke Skywalker (v3)
NewStaryknight
There are other characters like Ben, Tenel Ka, Allana, Saba, Corran, Kyp, Kyle, Niathal, and an assortment of others including Jacen/Cadeus himself.

Well, we already know that Jacen will be facing Jaina and company. So we know his part. I think we know what Niathal will be doing as well. The others are basically secondary characters. It's Luke and Ben that don't seem to have important roles, and they SHOULD! If Ben had been older, he probably would be the one facing Jacen. That would be only right and fair, especially since Jacen tried to turn Ben into a Sith.

But getting back on topic, from what I've heard about Invincible, Luke's role seems to be twofold: 1. First to be indecisive about whether he should do his duty and confront Jacen, or whether he should send Jaina instead because he's afraid he might kill Jacen for revenge as he did with Lumiya. He apparently decides to be a wimp and send Jaina. sad (And, this seems to me to have been a manufactured excuse just to allow Jaina to face her brother and not Luke. It once again diminishes Luke, as far as I'm concerned. I don't think Luke would need to worry about falling to the dark side at this stage of his life and experience. And the very fact that he has a healthy caution about the dark side would keep him from falling, in my opinion.)

2. For some very strange and inexplicable reason, Luke apparently will put an illusion of his face on Jaina, without Jaina even knowing it. HOW will this help??? I simply can't imagine. Adding his Force strength to Jaina's would be a far more valuable help in my opinion!

If those are Luke's sole contributions to Invincible, I will be HIGHLY annoyed! sad

NJO had Luke be inactive for the most part but when the last book came he went all out, so hopefully we get the same thing

That's what I was hoping, but now that it's practically confirmed that Jaina will be the one to confront Jacen and be the big hero of Invincible, I know that's not going to happen for Luke anymore. It seems that he may be the only major character who will be a background character in Invincible. sad


Dawud786

You know, with all the talk earlier of re-introducing Luke Skywalker... here's my thought on this, and I hope it works out: I want to see the Thrawn Trilogy animated and released directly to DVD

Well, that might not be a bad idea. The Thrawn Trilogy would be a good "jumping on" point. But I think C was suggesting a slightly altered characterization to please the more "modern" audiences. (Or am I misunderstanding, C?) I wouldn't want a more morally ambiguous Luke.

As for DE, NO thanks!!! I really hate DE. I think it greatly damaged Luke's character too. I'm all for declaring DE an Infinities story!

 

Post Reply | Quote Reply | Active Topic Notification | Private Message | Post History
Jedi Ben  9355 posts
Registered: Jul '99
23785_James Bond Jedi
Date Posted: 4/27/08 1:14pm Subject: RE: SOS: Save Our Skywalker, Luke Skywalker (v3)
COW,

You know what's really funny about you and DE? It isn't the story you loathe as much as the botched follow-up in the novels.

Now back to your earlier post:

I hope I wouldn't be like Cade!

* Perhaps not totally, but in part?

I'd say that Luke was "battered by life" too. But he didn't give up, didn't become cynical or refuse to do what he could to help others.

* But Luke had a childhood which Cade didn't. Unlike Luke, Cade saw the galaxy turn on the Jedi, kill his father and then he ended up with Rav, where he had to treat his former life with total contempt to survive.

* Luke may have come to find Tattoine restrictive but he was fairly safe and had friends. When the Empire did destroy his life he was able to get off the planet, join the rebellion and enact a fearsome retribution upon that same Empire by destroying the Death Star. He was able to get satisfaction that was denied Cade.

That's not what I was trying to say. I was just saying that today's readers seem to prefer to read about the rogues, anti-heroes, morally ambiguous characters like Cade, than the heroic, "good guy", who does what's right, who lives by a strong moral code and won't break it, as Luke used to be. I find that disappointing.

* The funny thing here is this point could as easily apply to Han Solo as to Luke!

JB

 

-----signature-----
Excellence: "You are the forum's Quick Ben."
SW EU fans: John Ostrander needs your help!
http://www.comix4sight.com
Post Reply | Quote Reply | Active Topic Notification | Private Message | Post History
NewStaryknight  1217 posts
Registered: Dec '07
14372_Leia and Luke
Date Posted: 4/27/08 1:36pm Subject: RE: SOS: Save Our Skywalker, Luke Skywalker (v3) - Date Edited: 4/27/08 1:39pm (1 edits total) Edited By: NewStaryknight
ChildOfWinds posted:
NewStaryknight
There are other characters like Ben, Tenel Ka, Allana, Saba, Corran, Kyp, Kyle, Niathal, and an assortment of others including Jacen/Cadeus himself.

Well, we already know that Jacen will be facing Jaina and company. So we know his part. I think we know what Niathal will be doing as well. The others are basically secondary characters. It's Luke and Ben that don't seem to have important roles, and they SHOULD! If Ben had been older, he probably would be the one facing Jacen. That would be only right and fair, especially since Jacen tried to turn Ben into a Sith.

But getting back on topic, from what I've heard about Invincible, Luke's role seems to be twofold: 1. First to be indecisive about whether he should do his duty and confront Jacen, or whether he should send Jaina instead because he's afraid he might kill Jacen for revenge as he did with Lumiya. He apparently decides to be a wimp and send Jaina. sad (And, this seems to me to have been a manufactured excuse just to allow Jaina to face her brother and not Luke. It once again diminishes Luke, as far as I'm concerned. I don't think Luke would need to worry about falling to the dark side at this stage of his life and experience. And the very fact that he has a healthy caution about the dark side would keep him from falling, in my opinion.)

2. For some very strange and inexplicable reason, Luke apparently will put an illusion of his face on Jaina, without Jaina even knowing it. HOW will this help??? I simply can't imagine. Adding his Force strength to Jaina's would be a far more valuable help in my opinion!

If those are Luke's sole contributions to Invincible, I will be HIGHLY annoyed! sad

NJO had Luke be inactive for the most part but when the last book came he went all out, so hopefully we get the same thing

That's what I was hoping, but now that it's practically confirmed that Jaina will be the one to confront Jacen and be the big hero of Invincible, I know that's not going to happen for Luke anymore. It seems that he may be the only major character who will be a background character in Invincible. sad





*Sigh* I don't know what to say that can convince you that Luke is going to play a big role in the end. We don't even know the machinations or the meaning to why he's force projecting his image onto Jaina. For all we know, its a ligh side version of the force phantom trick Lumiya and Alema kept using, so that if Jaina is hurt then Luke takes the damage and not her, but I don't know. All I'm saying is you got to try and have a little faith. There has never been a final book yet that the Big 3 haven't seen alot of action.

If you want to worry about something, worry about them getting killed. Because its more likely to me that one of them gets killed off than it is them not getting to do anything.

 

Post Reply | Quote Reply | Active Topic Notification | Private Message | Post History
Jedi Ben  9355 posts
Registered: Jul '99
23785_James Bond Jedi
Date Posted: 4/27/08 1:43pm Subject: RE: SOS: Save Our Skywalker, Luke Skywalker (v3)
On the issue of faith in authors, with regard to scepticism about Denning's upcoming finale for LOTF, I'll just say this:

With Luceno, his prior book had been the awesome Cloak of Deception, a PT work that was greatly liked and a far better example of his skills than the AOC duology. The fear was not that he would not try to do a good job, but that he had so much to attend to and take care of in one volume. Fortunately he was up to this Herculan labour - it took some 530 pages but he did it.

With Denning, it's a different story with his stock yo-yo-ing up and down depending on your view of the DN trilogy, plus Tempest and Inferno books and he has but 299 pages to finish the story! It's as if DR can't resist setting their authors Mission Impossibles! wink

 

-----signature-----
Excellence: "You are the forum's Quick Ben."
SW EU fans: John Ostrander needs your help!
http://www.comix4sight.com
Post Reply | Quote Reply | Active Topic Notification | Private Message | Post History
Rouge77  7464 posts
Registered: May '05
6464_Anakin Solo
Date Posted: 4/27/08 1:49pm Subject: RE: SOS: Save Our Skywalker, Luke Skywalker (v3)
I would guess that it is probably Denning's own choice to make Invincible as short as it will be; that if he would have liked to make it longer, he could have done it - considering that we are getting 416 pages and 448 pages long hardcovers this year.

 

-----signature-----
Recipient of the Confederation Ewok with "Rebel Yub"® Action!!
Kill Ben Skywalker, the new Jar-Jar!
Post Reply | Quote Reply | Active Topic Notification | Private Message | Post History
Dawud786  2660 posts
Registered: Dec '06
42320_Luke Skywalker
Date Posted: 4/27/08 4:16pm Subject: RE: SOS: Save Our Skywalker, Luke Skywalker (v3)
CoW, you never liked DE? Really? I find that hard to believe. That and TTT really brought SW back in its day.

Maybe it's just me, but I have nothing but fond memories of that time period, even Bantam. In hindsight it had some really low points, but I don't recall complaining about it back then. Of course, I wasn't a user of the inter-nerd so I didn't communicate with other EU dweebs.

 

-----signature-----
Post Reply | Quote Reply | Active Topic Notification | Private Message | Post History