| Author |
Topic:
Clone Wars Ongoing Continuity Discussion
|
000
Registered:
Oct '05
|
Date Posted:
5/12 6:27pm
Subject:
RE: Continuity implosion in process
|
Sinrebirth posted:
I'm slightly concerned that we're devolving into the same cycle we've had since, oh, Path of Destruction? The Revelation spoiler thread was a farce, and I believe (having not entered the thread I may be assuming) there was a near-farce in the Invincible spoiler thread from a few summary lines. This is our fourth inferno of debate in the row, people! Let's keep it optimistic!
While I'm unaccountably optimistic about this particular project, I think you're being a bit unfair, Sinre. I can certainly understand people feeling put-out over this, especially given the three examples you cited above.
|
|
|
Quote Reply |
Active Topic Notification |
Private Message |
Post History
|
Jedimarine
Registered:
Feb '01
|
Date Posted:
5/12 6:35pm
Subject:
RE: Continuity implosion in process
- Date Edited:
5/12 6:42pm (2 edits total)
Edited By:
Jedimarine
|
Havac posted:
I'd feel a lot better about this if there had been an announcement from Chee saying, "Well, we're changing things around for the TV series, but we've spent the last six months looking at how we can make this work, and here's the definitive official timeline for all prior sources and what we're doing with them. Dark Rendezvous is going to be set one year ABG, Jedi Trial is set ten months ABG, The Cestus Deception is staying where it is and any references to 'padawan' should be read as 'former padawan', The Siege of Saleucami is staying exactly where it is now," etc, etc, etc. In short, I'd feel a lot better if I felt like they had an actual handle on what they're doing, a plan, a fix ready to drop in place, instead of just saying, "Well, it's all canon, and we'll let Wallace and Pena retcon it out eventually. Then we'll probably ignore that retcon whenever we need to, too."
Do they know?
I mean...this strikes me as a case of the right hand not knowing what the left is doing.
Seriously...when GL or whoever was in charge of this project got started...did they look at the upcoming releases...the standing story...the chronologies...etc.
Or was is in it's own wing...detached...memos going here and there but nothing concrete being laid down.
Did Chee or Pena or anybody know? Cause if they did, they've been "hushed" about it.
Probably better to not tell people in that department...better to task them with "retconing" then having them slow down the process by balancing things as it develops.
This is a statement by George...this is his baby...and to prove it, he can steer it right into the ground and leave it to his staff to try to "pull up".
____________
It's funny...I started out this morning on this thread feeling fairly indifferent about it all...but it's just been pecking at me all day...how can they do this?
And the only thing I can up with...well...got edited. 
But seriously...it takes serious stones to pull this maneuver and expect the masses to hold on...ESPECIALLY in the face of outspoken criticism of the material in recent years.
Part of me thinks this might be the torpedo that LFL thinks fans want. Part of me thinks that perhaps the supportive voices for the EU within LFL haven't got the ear they may have had. Part of me thinks George is just determined not to settle for the critical see-saw his recent offerings have been.
In any event...I think this is a "put in it's place" light on what we have...the continuity was great, until it ran into a GL pet project. I'll be curious how staunchly continuity will be asserted after this...will the rules still apply to everyone but George?
_______________
Time for my moment of Optimism:
Maybe...just Maybe...this movie will be the epic we've all been praying GL could deliver since 1983...and our worlds...both real and imagined...will be hardcore rocked in an awesome way.
_______________
*sigh*
I almost bought that...I love books too much to sell out to the notion though.
Star Wars made me love READING...this is not the message to send people like me.
-----signature-----
A voice for my thoughts has been lost.
RIP George Carlin
I wonder if heaven is ready for the 7 words.
|
|
|
Quote Reply |
Active Topic Notification |
Private Message |
Post History
|
Jedimarine
Registered:
Feb '01
|
Date Posted:
5/12 6:39pm
Subject:
RE: Continuity implosion in process
|
The2ndQuest posted:
rechedelphar posted:
so basically everyhting that happened now has a different time frame?? is anything being eliminated?
We don't know if the timeframe is being changed or if any sources are being eliminated yet. This could all amount to a simple footnote retcon to explain away an offhand reference in the new show, for all we know. People are jumping to conclusions. Hopefully Leland or Pablo can shed some light on the situation.
Great!
So where are they?
Did they really think this wouldn't be caught?
Why don't we have a comment on patched in from TOS or the forums there.
It's awful quiet...people I know who don't frequent SW boards were messaging me today about it...it's gotten around.
Are they waiting for us to cannibalize each other before posting a statement...or were they truly caught off guard and are trying to word it carefully while not sounding as lost as we are about it?
again...right hand vs. left...perhaps LFL is not as united a house as we all like to think. 
-----signature-----
A voice for my thoughts has been lost.
RIP George Carlin
I wonder if heaven is ready for the 7 words.
|
|
|
Quote Reply |
Active Topic Notification |
Private Message |
Post History
|
Sniper_Wolf
Registered:
Nov '02
|
Date Posted:
5/12 6:39pm
Subject:
RE: Continuity implosion in process
|
Master_Keralys posted:
I guess I'm curious why this was thought to be a good idea...  I'm sure we'll get through it. But my frist thought definitely was, "Well, we can fix most everything except Quin." :P It seems unwise to me to go down this road, but to be fair it's not exactly new.
Is it worth noting that it seems that the decisions we've seen in other eras/settings before this in terms of a more fluid approach to canon were actually a reflection of this, which we of course were unaware of but which has obviously been well known for a long time?
And, here's the big one, why as a businessman does GL seem to have so little respect for the EU? I certainly get the desire to do your own creative thing, but he's definitely been distancing himself from it recently (comments in interviews going farther than ever before, and so on). Interesting change from his previous not-caring but largely hands-off approach.
- Keralys
Vector Prime busted the character death bubble, this appears to bust the "special status" bubble. Even with this alleged timeline reshuffle Star Wars fans still have the best kept auxillary universe. Lets not dillude ourselves with the "importance" of the EU. Virtually all secondary material for franchises is not canon at all. Trek has no standing, Alien EU has to be rewritten with every film, anything Joss Whedon is not involved with for Buffyverse, and so forth. So Star Wars is now given a treatment more similar to other franchises. This something we, the EU nuts that memorizes everything regarldess of quality, will just have to get used to.
If you look at the franchise from a business POV, though I do not have hard numbers right in front of me, the EU will almost assuredly make less cash the television series. Rather we like it or not the supermajority of people consider Star Wars a six film saga making a television series a more logical stepping stone than prose or comics for attracting people who just watch the films. The novels still sell though they are not runaway bestsellers, the comic medium overall is a niche market, and so on. Lucas can do whatever he wants from a business perspective because any possible losses will be worth the potential gains, and more than likely 99.9% of the EU fanbase will stay with the publications.
I'm not saying I am a big fan of this. My posts have shown I like one big story with minimal continuity errors. However like Greedo shooting first if these timeline changes do pan out the fanbase just has to deal with it.
-----signature-----
Winner of a Super Golden Ewok™ award.
I name you Sword of the Jedi. Always you shall be in the front rank, a burning brand to your enemies, a brilliant fire to your friends.
|
|
|
Quote Reply |
Active Topic Notification |
Private Message |
Post History
|
dizfactor
Registered:
Aug '02
|
Date Posted:
5/12 7:07pm
Subject:
RE: Continuity implosion in process
|
My $0.02:
I think anyone who doesn't think this is a continuity reshuffle is deluding themselves. I think anyone who doesn't think a continuity reshuffle is a positive thing is also deluding themselves.
Seriously, if you watched the CW micro-series straight through, and you weren't aware of the ENORMOUS KLUDGE they used to warp that storyline to fit the ridiculous timeline of the rest of the EU, the new timeline would seem totally normal. The Battle of Muunilinst happens shortly after AOTC, Anakin is knighted almost immediately afterwards, then the montage represents about two and a half years of time (now being covered with the new series), and then we see the mission to Nelvaan right at the end of the war. Perfect. It makes sense in terms of storyline and character development. The current situation is absurd, and if this fixes it, I'm all for it.
Dreadnaughts of Rendili is literally the only thing that could be seriously affected by this that's worth saving, and I'd be willing to make that trade to fix the timeline.
In general, though, everyone needs to take this less seriously. If the continuity works, that's great, but if not, the stories usually still work on their own.
-----signature-----
"Play is going to be for the 21st century what steam was to the 19th century."
Julian Dibbell
"You gotta love an elite killing force that you can fool by putting on a hat."
Gryph
|
|
|
Quote Reply |
Active Topic Notification |
Private Message |
Post History
|
The2ndQuest
Title: :
-Games
-LACWAC
-Lit Mod of Death
Registered:
Jan '00
|
Date Posted:
5/12 7:16pm
Subject:
RE: Continuity implosion in process
- Date Edited:
5/12 7:20pm (1 edits total)
Edited By:
The2ndQuest
|
Jedimarine posted:
Great!
So where are they?
Did they really think this wouldn't be caught?
Why don't we have a comment on patched in from TOS or the forums there.
Well, maybe you should calm down a bit and be patient 
These changes weren't outright announced in an overt way yet (it almost seems like they're updating the entries for a CW 3D update and just haven't posted the news update article)
This was only posted about here, on our uber-eagled-eyed-super-geek messageboard, not long before noon today.
I, uber SW Lit geek whose been spending all day surfing the net in a comic shop, didn't notice the discussion about it until 8 hours later.
At that point in time, only 1 other person, besides myself, had posted in Leland's TOS continuity thread about the situation, and one other since.
Give the man a chance!!  He probably hasn't checked the board in that small 2 hour window- he's not paid to hawk over that TOS thread for the very second we post something in it. I'm sure we'll hear from him within the next day or two, but give him a chance to respond (and posisbly confer with what the official psosition is on the situation, if he wasn't aware of it).
dizfactor posted:
Seriously, if you watched the CW micro-series straight through, and you weren't aware of the ENORMOUS KLUDGE they used to warp that storyline to fit the ridiculous timeline of the rest of the EU, the new timeline would seem totally normal.
There was no enormous kludge. The only two tweaks were moving the Asajj two-parter earlier (and as it was a standalone and effective prologue, that was perfectly natural) and having the timeline jump to war's end be prior to the Knighting rather than after it (making the montage be about "Anakin as a Knight" rather than "Anakin during the war", which fits even better given the themes of Volume Two).
-----signature-----
K'Kruhk, 140 ABY: "Why haven't I come forth earlier to share my Jedi knowledge with Skywalker?
Well, it's kinda a long story, see, I had this freaking sweet hat..."
"If I don't die, I don't feel like I'm getting my money's worth." - Drew_Atreides
|
|
|
Quote Reply |
Active Topic Notification |
Private Message |
Post History
|
Jedimarine
Registered:
Feb '01
|
Date Posted:
5/12 7:26pm
Subject:
RE: Continuity implosion in process
|
Patience isn't the point. It's not like I'm gonna lose sleep over this.
It's why this was done this way
was it a goof? Was there a statement that was delayed but a prearranged update went forward...did something get published early?
as you said...we have some hawk-eyes...and they know that...so either they didn't expect the reaction or they didn't care to respond to it straight away. Or they didn't know anything about it.
"What is said" will be interpreted differently...simply by "when" it's delivered.
Should be interesting whether it'll be comments or a statement...that could be significant.
-----signature-----
A voice for my thoughts has been lost.
RIP George Carlin
I wonder if heaven is ready for the 7 words.
|
|
|
Quote Reply |
Active Topic Notification |
Private Message |
Post History
|
dizfactor
Registered:
Aug '02
|
Date Posted:
5/12 7:34pm
Subject:
RE: Continuity implosion in process
|
The2ndQuest posted:
There was no enormous kludge.
Oh, please. Any outside observer coming into the micro-series would not assume that there was a huge gap of multiple years between the escape from Grievous on Hypori and Ki-Adi Mundi talking about his escape from Grievous on Hypori in the Council chamber. In fact, they would probably think it was bizarre and awkward and unnecessary, because it is bizarre and awkward and unnecessary.
It's all done to preserve the way-too-late date of Anakin's knighting, but there are few if any stories with Anakin as a padawan that would suffer from being pushed up the timeline. The only issue is the scar and Dreadnaughts of Rendili.
The2ndQuest posted:
The only two tweaks were moving the Asajj two-parter earlier (and as it was a standalone and effective prologue, that was perfectly natural) and having the timeline jump to war's end be prior to the Knighting rather than after it (making the montage be about "Anakin as a Knight" rather than "Anakin during the war", which fits even better given the themes of Volume Two).
"Anakin as a Knight" and "Anakin during the war" are not at all mutually exclusive, and in fact should be more-or-less synonymous. Hopefully, now they will be.
-----signature-----
"Play is going to be for the 21st century what steam was to the 19th century."
Julian Dibbell
"You gotta love an elite killing force that you can fool by putting on a hat."
Gryph
|
|
|
Quote Reply |
Active Topic Notification |
Private Message |
Post History
|
Thrawn McEwok
Title: TFN EU Staff
Registered:
May '00
|
Date Posted:
5/12 7:43pm
Subject:
RE: Continuity implosion in process
- Date Edited:
5/12 7:45pm (1 edits total)
Edited By:
Thrawn McEwok
|
I'm feeling... oddly indifferent.
Partially, it's because a lot of the Prequel material wasn't great with continuity ANYWAY. Rogue Planet gives us a new backstory for Sienar Fleet Systems. Jedi Trial doesn't seem well-informed on established character biographies or the established locations of planets. Dark Rendezvous creates a new spaceship type, and describes it as a single-seat fighter and a larger ship with a galley and lounge within the same book. The Boba Fett kids' books have Ventress in action when she should be in bacta, and Nightsisters and Noghri running around on Coruscant before they were known to the Galaxy. There's a different characterization of Dooku in almost every story he's in, and people have already mentioned the issues with Vader's knighting and his scars.
Partially, though, my shrug is because my interest in Star Wars has been undermined - though that, in turn, is due in no small part to recent problems with holding canon together.
The normal argument in favour of detailed continuity is that inconsistencies kick the reader out of the story, but it's not just a matter of geekery. A coherent canon adds a level of integrity to the product: it means that the character-arcs from previous stories are going to continue, and the underlying situations of the story aren't going to be changed to suit the plot of the latest novel, or because some geek thought a six-foot-tall Luke Skywalker would be "cooler".
All of those things, I think, harm the reader's enjoyment of the franchise: the major issues people have had with Star Wars stories since forever have been characterization that doesn't match previous novels, and plots that ignore what's been established in previous adventures.
I have nothing against Alternative Universe and "Infinities" stories... except that the experience of Star Wars Tales suggests a lot of "Infinities" stories end up being basically the same. Respecting canon helps prevent that, too.
I find myself agreeing remarkably much with patchworkz7 AND dp4m, which is a sure sign that the fandom has gone boom.
But I'm not really feeling any emotion about the issue, any more.
I still think flow-walking could be used to fix the inconsistencies, though:
Blame Jacen Solo for the Prequel Era!!
And bring back Anakin Solo, while you're at it!! 
- The Imperial Ewok
-----signature-----
A/T = OTP  Today's A/T recommendation: "Teetering", by *Kidan* http://boards.theforce.net/beyond_the_saga/b10477/28653420/
|
|
|
Quote Reply |
Active Topic Notification |
Private Message |
Post History
|
The2ndQuest
Title: :
-Games
-LACWAC
-Lit Mod of Death
Registered:
Jan '00
|
Date Posted:
5/12 7:50pm
Subject:
RE: Continuity implosion in process
|
dizfactor posted:
It's all done to preserve the way-too-late date of Anakin's knighting...."Anakin as a Knight" and "Anakin during the war" are not at all mutually exclusive, and in fact should be more-or-less synonymous. Hopefully, now they will be.
I'm actually curious as to the nature of the decision of when to place Anakin's knighting, as that strikes me as a Lucas decision since LFL could have easily set Anakin's knighting earlier if he wanted it to be. The retcon for the cartoon ends up fixing the mistake the cartoon made, not the other way around, in other words.
I suppose I could have described the two montage interpretations better- I meant more "Anakin in action now that he's a Knight" vs " Anakin during the war, oj his way to becoming a Knight".
-----signature-----
K'Kruhk, 140 ABY: "Why haven't I come forth earlier to share my Jedi knowledge with Skywalker?
Well, it's kinda a long story, see, I had this freaking sweet hat..."
"If I don't die, I don't feel like I'm getting my money's worth." - Drew_Atreides
|
|
|
Quote Reply |
Active Topic Notification |
Private Message |
Post History
|
dizfactor
Registered:
Aug '02
|
Date Posted:
5/12 8:04pm
Subject:
RE: Continuity implosion in process
- Date Edited:
5/12 8:06pm (1 edits total)
Edited By:
dizfactor
|
The2ndQuest posted:
I'm actually curious as to the nature of the decision of when to place Anakin's knighting, as that strikes me as a Lucas decision since LFL could have easily set Anakin's knighting earlier if he wanted it to be. The retcon for the cartoon ends up fixing the mistake the cartoon made, not the other way around, in other words.
My guess is that it had more to do with real-world timelines than story ones. My guess is that after AOTC, LFL told the licensees they couldn't knight Anakin until they said so, and they couldn't touch the last few months of the war. They start dutifully rolling the timeline forward, but got caught up in delays and whatnot, and never advanced much further than a year or so into the EU timeline.
Then, sometime fairly late in the ROTS production period, they gave the green light on that and on ROTS content (new trooper armor, new ships, etc), along with the mandate that they handle a few major points in the last few months of the war. The licensees said "Oh, ****, we're behind schedule, and jumped forward to the end and crammed everything into the last six months. Also, GT was probably given more leeway with canon than the others, so they had to contort everything to fit the cartoon into their schedule.
In short, I don't think it's likely that LFL ever said "You can't knight Anakin until six months before ROTS", but rather LFL didn't give the licensees permission to knight Anakin until the same (real-world) time the licensees needed to be covering the last six months of the war.
-----signature-----
"Play is going to be for the 21st century what steam was to the 19th century."
Julian Dibbell
"You gotta love an elite killing force that you can fool by putting on a hat."
Gryph
|
|
|
Quote Reply |
Active Topic Notification |
Private Message |
Post History
|
ThrawnRocks
Registered:
Apr '04
|
Date Posted:
5/12 8:08pm
Subject:
RE: Continuity implosion in process
- Date Edited:
5/12 8:11pm (1 edits total)
Edited By:
ThrawnRocks
|
I can't say I'm happy about this. It could be the start of a bad habit concerning the show and canon. I hope we're misinterpreting this. Either way, how this plays out will more or less make or break Filoni's claim to being canon conscious and in general fighting to maintain it. Lets hope that ends up being true.
One thing that would make me happy would be some sort of indication that there are parties within LFL that are unhappy about this. As of late they've been putting on the face of "anythings fine if it makes a cooler story" which is annoying, and not a mindset that I subscribe to.
Help us Abel (and Dan), you're our only hope...
And after they're done smoothing it out, I fully expect Luceno to write canon rich novels set in the clone wars that tie it all together again.
Time to roll up our sleeves boys and girls, it's damage control time! 
-----signature-----
My Icons: http://www.powow.com/thrawnrocks/icons.html  Impeach President Bush Roan Fel's badassery knows no bounds. "The next Allston book should be all Syal and Myri, all the time." - Jello
|
|
|
Quote Reply |
Active Topic Notification |
Private Message |
Post History
|
patchworkz7
Registered:
Mar '04
|
Date Posted:
5/12 8:35pm
Subject:
RE: Continuity implosion in process
|
ThrawnRocks posted:
One thing that would make me happy would be some sort of indication that there are parties within LFL that are unhappy about this. As of late they've been putting on the face of "anythings fine if it makes a cooler story" which is annoying, and not a mindset that I subscribe to
If there were parties that were unhappy about it, do you think they'd ever be allowed to say so?
Even freelancers are bound by certain agreements, and one of the rules of any company is that you toe the company line and step out front to say that you are 100% behind this product/service even if you went through hell getting it out the door and feel like you got screwed in the process.
I could go on my LJ right now and tell some horror stories about the hospital I work at...and if anyone from that hospital found them I'd be out on my butt or in serious poodoo. I could complain about editors I've dealt with in the past when writing fiction and non-fiction, and I'd never sell to them or anyone they know again.
Also, Havac made the point before, what's the point of having someone come up behind and clean up canon if the clean-up will just get scrapped with the next round of changes or whenever someone wants to change it anyways?
-----signature-----
Original Fiction & essays "Does God Limp?" in HOUSE UNAUTHORIZED http://www.smartpopbooks.com/allbooks/2007.html#house "All Her Suicides" appears in: Vestal Review #31 Winter Issue On Sale Now
|
|
|
Quote Reply |
Active Topic Notification |
Private Message |
Post History
|
Havac
Title: Lit Mod of War
Registered:
Sep '05
|
Date Posted:
5/12 8:38pm
Subject:
RE: Continuity implosion in process
- Date Edited:
5/12 8:39pm (1 edits total)
Edited By:
Havac
|
Yeah, I strongly doubt Abel and Dan are happy with developments on this front, and I'd be shocked if they weren't upset, but I'd never expect them to come out and say so.
Clearly, someone will have to get them roaring drunk at the next Celebration to get their opinion out.
Although it's kind of a rough spot for them, as even if they aren't bothered, everyone will assume they are and are just saying they're not for PR reasons.
-----signature-----
"If Havac was a pinata, when you beat him all that would come out is win." - Uli
Recipient of Thrawn McEwok's Sexually Ambiguous Tusken Raider™ and a Special Golden Ewok™
"Reality doesn't care if you believe it." - Boba Fett
|
|
|
Quote Reply |
Active Topic Notification |
Private Message |
Post History
|
The2ndQuest
Title: :
-Games
-LACWAC
-Lit Mod of Death
Registered:
Jan '00
|
Date Posted:
5/12 8:54pm
Subject:
RE: Continuity implosion in process
|
Havac posted:
Clearly, someone will have to get them roaring drunk at the next Celebration to get their opinion out.
I don't drink and even I did, they'd probably be more on guard around the guy pestering people with a video camera- so we'll need another volunteer!
-----signature-----
K'Kruhk, 140 ABY: "Why haven't I come forth earlier to share my Jedi knowledge with Skywalker?
Well, it's kinda a long story, see, I had this freaking sweet hat..."
"If I don't die, I don't feel like I'm getting my money's worth." - Drew_Atreides
|
|
|
Quote Reply |
Active Topic Notification |
Private Message |
Post History
|
