Author Topic: Knights of the Old Republic #35, "Vindication" Part 4 (of 4)
Grey1  1709 posts
Registered: Nov '00
8038_Qui-Gon and Obi-Wan
Date Posted: 11/19/08 10:53am Subject: RE: Knights of the Old Republic #35, "Vindication" Part 4 (of 4) - Date Edited: 11/19/08 10:56am (1 edits total) Edited By: Grey1
I posted most of my initial thoughts as an edit to the post above...

As for the ending as an ending, I'll be honest - I'd really like more. But maybe it's better if you read the whole arc back to back (either Vindication or 1-35). Also, I think it beats an ending with one issue of action and one issue of just talking - if you've seen the Deep Space Nine finale...

But I don't think it sucks. Most if not all elements are done in a plausible way. Best read it yourself, maybe a summary without all the little interactions can't live up to it.

 

-----signature-----
Jacen had learned that one can meet the Universe [...] with fear, or with hatred, or with despair.
Or one can choose to meet it with love.
Jacen had chosen.
But still, he was astonished to discover that the Universe could love him back.
Locked Topic | Active Topic Notification | Private Message | Post History
Ackbar_Van_Gungan  1297 posts
Registered: Oct '04
6318_Ackbar
Date Posted: 11/19/08 11:13am Subject: RE: Knights of the Old Republic #35, "Vindication" Part 4 (of 4)
I just got the issue as well and surprise, It's the same as Grey's.

I think the issue itself is a little anticlimactic, mostly as the resolution occurs about halfway through the book and the rest is just clean-up, medal celebration, Ewok party type stuff.


Zayne's quote is great.

Zayne: "I'm having a vision. A vision of the future"

Haazen: "A seer too? Wonderful. Tell me. Tell me your vision of the future."

Zayne: "You're not in it"

Some absolutely gorgeous art. Particularly the full page depiction of Haazen's end via turbolaser from across the city.

Other notes:

-Zayne looks very Anakinesque in his knight get up.
-Lucien ends up "Someplace Else" which is a moon he owns (orbiting a red planet that appears to be volcanic).
-There are other Jedi there one of whom is wearing The Freaking Sweet Hat.
-It looks like Lucien could have been Darth Sion but he chose another path and is not going to be the Lord of Pain after all which has me relieved.


Any questions?

-The Rebel Gungan

 

-----signature-----
My SFF blog: http://www.yetistomper.blogspot.com/
1st Post= Golden Ewok™ No Prize!
Unfortunate Sacred Slab of the Church of Waru
-Curator of the Byss Orbiting Holographic History of Space Flight Museum
Locked Topic | Active Topic Notification | Private Message | Post History
Grey1  1709 posts
Registered: Nov '00
8038_Qui-Gon and Obi-Wan
Date Posted: 11/19/08 11:25am Subject: RE: Knights of the Old Republic #35, "Vindication" Part 4 (of 4) - Date Edited: 11/19/08 12:12pm (2 edits total) Edited By: Grey1
I prefer the other Zayne quote, the one when he's getting out of the tank... wink

As for Anakin, that's why I said vaderish. Total Ep3 Anakin. But based on future covers, I think this was just his "look like a Jedi while stepping before the Concil" dress, and we probably won't see it again...

And yeah, anticlimatic is right, there was so much killer stuff in the last issue that I think that both together would offer a better story flow. The cleanup was rather short concerning the amount of stuff that needed to be cleaned up - as I said, imagine a whole issue just cleaning up, now that would have taken steam out of the series. I doubt that DH would have done that (and hey, maybe this is why we didn't get 36 issues, meaning three full years...? thinking Will the conspiracy theories ever stop?) thinking thinking thinking tongue tongue

 

-----signature-----
Jacen had learned that one can meet the Universe [...] with fear, or with hatred, or with despair.
Or one can choose to meet it with love.
Jacen had chosen.
But still, he was astonished to discover that the Universe could love him back.
Locked Topic | Active Topic Notification | Private Message | Post History
Ackbar_Van_Gungan  1297 posts
Registered: Oct '04
6318_Ackbar
Date Posted: 11/19/08 12:07pm Subject: RE: Knights of the Old Republic #35, "Vindication" Part 4 (of 4) - Date Edited: 11/19/08 12:16pm (1 edits total) Edited By: Ackbar_Van_Gungan
I think it's a bit of a let down because we have been in high octane mode for months and each month was "WHAT'S GOING TO HAPPEN NEXT?" or "HOW IS ZAYNE GOING TO ESCAPE FROM THIS?". At this point, all of the questions appear to have been answered. Or at least answered in typical JJM style. There is very little in terms of discussion points left. I think this was a great ending but a poor single issue. All the trade-waiters are going to have something special coming there way.

So all in all, we have one conclusive death (if that), 1 of the 5 Sith (Malak), and everything from the first arc is tied up with a neat little bow.

We are used to thinking in terms of the larger story arc. However, the story arc is done and tied up and I must say it's been a great one. Truly epic, and very true the original feeling of SW.

I look forward to seeing where the series goes from here. The Revanchists and Mandalorians and the Sith are still out there and its only a matter of time until Zayne gets involved again.

Great work, JJM. Keep it up!

-The Rebel Gungan

 

-----signature-----
My SFF blog: http://www.yetistomper.blogspot.com/
1st Post= Golden Ewok™ No Prize!
Unfortunate Sacred Slab of the Church of Waru
-Curator of the Byss Orbiting Holographic History of Space Flight Museum
Locked Topic | Active Topic Notification | Private Message | Post History
Ackbar_Van_Gungan  1297 posts
Registered: Oct '04
6318_Ackbar
Date Posted: 11/19/08 12:12pm Subject: RE: Knights of the Old Republic #35, "Vindication" Part 4 (of 4)
I had another thought on the last 2 or 3 pages. Aside from the references to buying the moon, Lucien could very well be dead and in a Force netherworld with other deceased Jedi. The Hellish world in the sky could be the home to the darksiders. There would be something simplistic and elegant in that duality that I would love. More from a metaphorical perspective than a physical place.

And if we never see Lucien again that might be my personal retcon.


-The Rebel Gungan

 

-----signature-----
My SFF blog: http://www.yetistomper.blogspot.com/
1st Post= Golden Ewok™ No Prize!
Unfortunate Sacred Slab of the Church of Waru
-Curator of the Byss Orbiting Holographic History of Space Flight Museum
Locked Topic | Active Topic Notification | Private Message | Post History
SithStarSlayer  8619 posts
Registered: Oct '03
40005_Quinlan Vos
Date Posted: 11/19/08 12:57pm Subject: RE: Knights of the Old Republic #35, "Vindication" Part 4 (of 4) - Date Edited: 11/19/08 1:02pm (2 edits total) Edited By: SithStarSlayer
Charlemagne19 posted:
As odd as this may seem

I find that a tremendously sucky ending.

I just finished reading it.
It takes contrived, dovetailed and tucked-in to whole new levels.

In one fell swoop we have Malak's name change and Scion's revised/altered/tweaked backstory as the Lord of Pain. Or did I miss something, Rebel Gungan? I didn't get the same vibe about him as you did.


The art was fantastic, Zayne was as good as ever... it just feels, oh I don't know... hollow I guess is the best word.

 

-----signature-----
Lucas didn't ruin my childhood but he sure wrecked Vader's
^^Foolish men mistake transitory semblance 4 eternal fact^^
o[]||]ooooooooo[0]||[]{
Gal: 5:19-21
Philippians 2:9-11
Locked Topic | Active Topic Notification | Private Message | Post History
Master_Keralys  6378 posts
Title: Manager Emeritus
Registered: Oct '03
39907_Obi-Wan Kenobi
Date Posted: 11/19/08 12:58pm Subject: RE: Knights of the Old Republic #35, "Vindication" Part 4 (of 4)
To John Jackson Miller:

applause applause applause applause applause

 

-----signature-----
God made man. Man rejected God. God became the man Jesus Christ, died and rose again to life, saving man from himself.
The craziest story ever told.
The truest.
Locked Topic | Active Topic Notification | Private Message | Post History
PointGiven  734 posts
Registered: Dec '06
6466_Soontir Fel
Date Posted: 11/19/08 1:12pm Subject: RE: Knights of the Old Republic #35, "Vindication" Part 4 (of 4) - Date Edited: 11/19/08 1:13pm (1 edits total) Edited By: PointGiven
SithStarSlayer posted:


In one fell swoop we have Malak's name change and Scion's revised/altered/tweaked backstory as the Lord of Pain.


What are you talking about? Malak's name change makes sense in the story and it's pretty much established that Lucien isn't going to go all Sion. He was "swimming" towards the dark and becoming the "Lord of Pain" but he reflected on his father and mother and decided to not take that path

Question for anyone else who read the issue:

In the end when Lucien is with the farmer Jedi on the moon, did anyone else think the tall black, white bearded Jedi was Jolee Bindo? Cuz I sure did


Charlemagne19 posted:
As odd as this may seem

I find that a tremendously sucky ending.


Why so?


 

-----signature-----
Think you can name the most important Sith Lords? Test your knowledge: http://www.sporcle.com/games/Caedus/sith_lords
Also test your SW military knowledge with the Wars of Star Wars: http://www.sporcle.com/games/Caedus/wars_starwars
Locked Topic | Active Topic Notification | Private Message | Post History
cbagmjg  431 posts
Registered: Jul '06
41233_Darth Nihilus
Date Posted: 11/19/08 1:12pm Subject: RE: Knights of the Old Republic #35, "Vindication" Part 4 (of 4)
Grey1 posted:
I'm the first one who's read it and posts here? Tee hee...

Oi, spoilers... I normally don't like these, but I guess some general developments are okay to post... the best part are the little details and the actual character interaction anyway.

It starts right in the duel between Zayne and Lucien. During a break, Zayne tries to talk Lucien into going after Haazen instead, going something like "ok, do what he wants, you've always only done what other people want" (no direct quote). Haazen gets a delivery of the Jedi Council's hidden Sith artifacts in the garden. Gryph flees to the same spot. Then comes the duel part from the preview, which ends with the Barrison statue falling onto Lucien. Zayne does another stab at the buried body, then kneels down before Haazen. Which is of course a ruse. Once Zayne cuts of the arm with the gauntlet, he and Gryph get catapulted away by the Force. By - surprise surprise - Lucien, who set up a con with Zayne. Lucien uses the gauntlet to command the ships to blow up the compound, which should take care of Haazen, Lucien, all known Sith artifacts, everything Covenant, and Zayne's lightsaber, while we're at it. Zayne and Gryph survived, of course, which allows Zayne for one of his best lines ever (which should be the new catchphrase for the series) and a nice Zayne/Gryph moment.

Everything else gets summed up on the next few pages while Gryph and Jarael listen to Karath's official speech - with the official story being in the interest of everyone involved, meaning not really truthful. Jarael says that Alek testified for Zayne, but left again because the Council is against additional Jedi groups more than ever. He's also calling himself Malak until peace has been restored (and we all know how that will turn out). Jarael didn't go with him, even though she wanted to, but rather looks after Rohlan. Gryph thinks he'll lose Zayne to the Jedi, but here's the big surprise - he doesn't. Zayne leaves the Jedi to become Gryph's partner, but took a new saber and one of those black vaderish knight outfits with him. Party on, Zayne! Party on, Gryph!

Meanwhile, back on a ranch on a distant moon, Lucien has gone into exile, having survived thanks to that Sith artifact. Which showed him the way to become a Lord Of Pain. Which he didn't, thanks to Daddy, who always didn't do what others expected. So Lucien goes to this secret private moon where he formed his own hidden Covenant of farmer Jedi. Everyone (including Big L) is wearing the brown simple-man-Obi-Wan-robes, and Lucien says the Jedi will live on even after troubled times, finally having seen his future.

Tadaa.


So come on, I want to discuss this thing.

First of all, as for Lucien, I suppose we won't see him again in the comic - his arc seems to be over for good. Finito. An Ex-arc.

That said, it still toys with Lucien being Sion, the Lord of Pain - Lucien gets hurt, even though not nearly enough to look like Sion. He's got more resemblance to Kreia, by the way... thinking wink

His private moon is orbiting a Mustafar-like planet that hangs in the sky, I'm not sure if that has to mean/foreshadow anything. However, in personal canon, we can still assume that he started down the dark path and that it dominates his destiny forever... grin I was one of the first to invest into this theory, so I'll defend it until JJM explicitly states that he never, ever thought about Lucien being similar to Sion until the fan speculation was there, and that he only did these final two Sion mentions as a tease or a nod or something. It's not hard to do, is it? wink

Zayne's choice isn't really that surprising, and I guess it won't affect the stories as we already have the concept of the wandering "freelance-Jedi" who's still doing good. I wonder why he got a replacement lightsaber, though... I mean, ok, OOU it was the intention to shuffle things up with a new saber(colour, presumably, judging by future covers). IU, however, if the Jedi let him go with all that training and all, why let him have a saber (and look like a real Jedi to the outside world) at a time when they explicitly want to totally control the flock?

The huge Lucien and Zayne con can be seen coming as soon as Zayne kneels down. It's a bit strange when we last see Zayne getting through to Lucien, then the next time they come around, they fight again. And when Zayne goes totally out of character, we know that something is up. Although the smashing and stabbing once again nourished hopes for Lucien becoming Sion. mischief

Some really iconic imagery in there, and even though lots of the cleanup happens only in expository dialogue, it's a fun "final issue" for the arc. Judging by the letter column, the plan is to have about a year of random adventures for the CarGryph Crew right now. I guess they'll finally sneak a new arc into that material, but as for now, we can go a bit slower on the conspiracy theories.



Zayne's new lightsaber was Lucien's old one.

 

Locked Topic | Active Topic Notification | Private Message | Post History
Jeff_Ferguson  1664 posts
Registered: May '06
42357_Antares Draco
Date Posted: 11/19/08 1:19pm Subject: RE: Knights of the Old Republic #35, "Vindication" Part 4 (of 4)
An interesting issue. I think I agree with the assessments that the ending to the story was good, but that the issue itself wasn't particularly fantastic (save for the first half!). Let's start from the beginning and then progress to the letters column, shall we? happy

The cover looks gorgeous with the logo and such added onto it. It looks even better than it does by itself, with the light purple colours complementing it wonderfully. It's a shame that the Barrison statue is blocked out, but the cover is still great.

The Lucien-Zayne duel at the beginning was very, very good. Lucien was in command, but Zayne was definitely holding his own. I'll admit, I was fooled by their second duel, right up until Zayne stabbed Lucien. At that point, I was staring wide-eyed at the page, thinking "No! Zayne would never kill anyone like that!" When he knelt before Zod --- er, Haazen, I was sure that he had something up his sleeve (but still very worried), which is what made his "You're not in it." line on the next page all the more awesome. JJM had me very nervously wondering right up until that point. Bravo. applause

Lucien's line, after recovering from the fallen statue, was simply magnificent. "My father would never hurt me, Haazen -- And I would never let what he stood for fall. Not really." Seriously, that was awesome. As was what Lucien did next --- but I have a question about it...

How certain was Zayne that the Kressh gauntlet would protect Lucien from the turbolaser blasts? This seems like the kind of con that Zayne would only participate in if he was absolutely certain that Lucien wouldn't die or be grievously injured by it. Then again, if Lucien wanted to risk his life in order to stop Haazen, Zayne would probably understand and allow it. It was a pretty elaborate ploy to come up with in such few desperate moments, but it ended with a really cool payoff. peace

Something about Gryph standing there eating a drumstick made me smile. grin But it kind of sucks that so much of the resolution happened off-screen and then was mentioned by Gryph --- I mean, the whole thing about the cover-up, the bounties being paid off, etc, sure, cool, but it was disappointing not seeing either Alek or Vrook Lamar. After being confronted by Xamar at the end of Turnabout, the only resolution we get to the two of them happens offscreen. sad Though I did enjoy that it Alek's storyline did get resolution, rather than an Invincible being pulled... mischief

What was up with Zayne looking and dressing like Darth Caedus? Seriously, minus the Sith eyes, he looked a lot like this:




I really like that he turned down the offer to be a Jedi in order to go with Gryph. "I'm free --- just not cheap." applause Wonderful!

I still have an unanswered question, though... Is Q'Anilia definitely dead, then? She didn't die in the original vision, and a line by Gryph last issue indicated that she was still alive... but I guess she really did drink the poison.

Onto the letters column! It does seem like they'll have some random adventures in the coming year, but I suspect they'll lead into something big. Seems like the Moomos are gone, based on the line from Gryph stating that they were paid off and now have reputations, but with the Covenant stuff out of the way, it seems like we'll be seeing more/learning more about Rohlan... thinking

And for the record, I've grown to love this clever clan of galactic misfits. I'm not begrudgingly tolerating them in hopes that they'll run into more Mandalorians. happy peace

So, yeah, good ending, but the issue itself wasn't "OMG AWESOME!" like last month's was. And I do wish that we could have seen Alek at the end, and maybe Zayne appearing before the council, too. Those are the only off-screen resolutions I wish had been on-screen. Er... on-page. Especially since Alek and Zayne met in Issue 0 --- a meeting of them at the end would really have brought everything full-circle.

Looking forward to the next year! Can't wait to see what these adventures will bring. Knowing JJM, they'll lead to something great.

 

-----signature-----
"We are Imperial Knights. We do our duty by the Emperor and by the Force—no matter the cost." --- Sigel Dare
"In the name of the true Emperor, Roan Fel, we come bearing greetings to our Jedi cousins." --- Marasiah Fel
Locked Topic | Active Topic Notification | Private Message | Post History
SithStarSlayer  8619 posts
Registered: Oct '03
40005_Quinlan Vos
Date Posted: 11/19/08 1:29pm Subject: RE: Knights of the Old Republic #35, "Vindication" Part 4 (of 4) - Date Edited: 11/19/08 1:38pm (3 edits total) Edited By: SithStarSlayer
PointGiven, I didn't like how the name change was done.
It was too... off the cuff, for my tastes.
And with the wussy called Draay, an elitist he is... dark his destiny will remain.
No matter how noble he thinks he is.


A couple pics to whet some appetites:


Zayne's get-up is a cross between ROTS Anakin and ROTJ Luke.
I don't see the Darth Dumb-Solo connection. tongue

 

-----signature-----
Lucas didn't ruin my childhood but he sure wrecked Vader's
^^Foolish men mistake transitory semblance 4 eternal fact^^
o[]||]ooooooooo[0]||[]{
Gal: 5:19-21
Philippians 2:9-11
Locked Topic | Active Topic Notification | Private Message | Post History
Grey1  1709 posts
Registered: Nov '00
8038_Qui-Gon and Obi-Wan
Date Posted: 11/19/08 1:41pm Subject: RE: Knights of the Old Republic #35, "Vindication" Part 4 (of 4)
Some things I forgot...

- Lucien's exile planet: As I mentioned the Jedi there wearing Obi-Wan robes, and Lucien mentions the future after coming tribulations, it seems as if this might be an important core of the Jedi Order after Nihilus. Also, I like how Lucien and his new friends are all about facing the future with humility like Krynda wished for - with simple servant's robes.

- Zayne leaving the Jedi: In the same vein, the fact that Zayne isn't technically a Jedi opens all doors for a happy end with the Exile still being the final Jedi and Zayne living to a high age, something some of us were afraid of wouldn't happen because KOTOR 2 explicitly has the whole Order dead.

Ackbar_Van_Gungan posted:
I had another thought on the last 2 or 3 pages. Aside from the references to buying the moon, Lucien could very well be dead and in a Force netherworld with other deceased Jedi. The Hellish world in the sky could be the home to the darksiders. There would be something simplistic and elegant in that duality that I would love. More from a metaphorical perspective than a physical place.

And if we never see Lucien again that might be my personal retcon.

Oooooooh nice. I doubt that it was intended, but I think you won't have trouble taking it on as personal canon.

PointGiven posted:
In the end when Lucien is with the farmer Jedi on the moon, did anyone else think the tall black, white bearded Jedi was Jolee Bindo? Cuz I sure did
Yeah, I did too, but he's a bit too muscular. And he would also be in the wrong place, so it's just artistic coincidence, like all those Nautolans from issue 33 suddenly disappearing again... wink

cbagmjg posted:
Zayne's new lightsaber was Lucien's old one.
Really? I missed that. It looks familiar, but I don't know where he should have gotten it, though...

 

-----signature-----
Jacen had learned that one can meet the Universe [...] with fear, or with hatred, or with despair.
Or one can choose to meet it with love.
Jacen had chosen.
But still, he was astonished to discover that the Universe could love him back.
Locked Topic | Active Topic Notification | Private Message | Post History
Charlemagne19  26812 posts
Registered: Jul '00
6408_Jedi Outcast
Date Posted: 11/19/08 1:42pm Subject: RE: Knights of the Old Republic #35, "Vindication" Part 4 (of 4)
Zayne's choice rubbed me the wrong way on countless levels.

 

Locked Topic | Active Topic Notification | Private Message | Post History
Zorrixor  4299 posts
Registered: Sep '04
42757_Prince Xizor
Date Posted: 11/19/08 2:08pm Subject: RE: Knights of the Old Republic #35, "Vindication" Part 4 (of 4) - Date Edited: 11/19/08 2:08pm (1 edits total) Edited By: Zorrixor
Hmm...

I'm not sure what to feel. Part of me agrees about it being somewhat anti-climactic, but the other part of me knows that was inevitable no matter what happened.

And another part of me wonders whether this is just the tip of the iceberg, if DH are confident KOTOR sales figures warrant another mega arc like this. For, in such a case, this could very well be the Episode I to a much more sinister plot (*cough* Kreia *cough*).

I believe the references to Sion and the Lord of Pain, etc, are almost certainly an OOU fan service more than anything... but... there is just the potential for something more sinister going on. Haazen was potentially working to establish the Malachor Three. In the ESB to KOTOR's current ANH, I could possibly see the "real bad guys" behind all this being revealed as the group who warped Haazen in the first place.

Only time will tell. Bring on the next arc!

 

Locked Topic | Active Topic Notification | Private Message | Post History
Ackbar_Van_Gungan  1297 posts
Registered: Oct '04
6318_Ackbar
Date Posted: 11/19/08 2:13pm Subject: RE: Knights of the Old Republic #35, "Vindication" Part 4 (of 4)
Charlemagne19 posted:
Zayne's choice rubbed me the wrong way on countless levels.



Which choice? Not to be a Jedi?

I maintain that this wasn't nearly as interesting an issue as 32, 33, or 34 but you have to look at the big picture. If you read the whole Draay Estate battle in one fell swoop its would flow smoothly and not seem as abrupt as this issue made it seem. As I said before, the trade-waiters are going to have a whole different experience reading Vindication because as a whole it’s fantastic.

And Lucien is not Sion. He acknowledges that he could have been a Sion, BUT he chose otherwise which was what the ending was all about. Now, he still could be Sion (ignoring the obvious campaign guide conflicts), but right now he is a simple farmer in a pacifist Jedi covenant. Everything points to it being the original Sith marauder at this point. That creates significant plausibility issues as we would have a Darth Sion existing independently of Haazen trying to name Lucien Sion.

Imagine what would have happened if Lucien Sion and the real Darth Sion met up. It’s the Sith equivalent as wearing the same dress to the party.


As the last issue it’s anti-climactic because the rising action occurs throughout multiple issues (mostly in 34) and we get the climax early on in Issue 35 rather than towards the end. If you look at it like A New Hope, Issue 34 would end with Darth Vader’s TIE bearing down on Luke and issue 35 would feature Han and Chewie coming back to save Luke, the Death Star exploding and then the Rebel Medal Ceremony.

Look at it as a part of Vindication which is a part of a large story arc rather than a stand-alone issue. Because it’s not a stand alone, and shouldn’t be judged as one.

-The Rebel Gungan

 

-----signature-----
My SFF blog: http://www.yetistomper.blogspot.com/
1st Post= Golden Ewok™ No Prize!
Unfortunate Sacred Slab of the Church of Waru
-Curator of the Byss Orbiting Holographic History of Space Flight Museum
Locked Topic | Active Topic Notification | Private Message | Post History