Drewton posted:

---

nett40 posted:

---

Drewton posted:

---

Didn't hate Star Trek at all (at least the Kirk era stuff), but wasn't a big fan of it. The new film, as the posters above me have said, was amazing.

---

And that is why you wan't another Star Wars movie instead of a LAS?

---

You're misunderstanding me once again. In fact, this is basically the same question you asked me yesterday. I'll repeat my answer.

I do want there to be the live-action series, I just don't want TV to be the only future of Star Wars as George Lucas says it is.

---

Gry Sarth posted:

---

Interesting that now you're using the "GL said it" card. So when GL says there won't be more films, you accept that as fact. But when he says the LAS will be Jedi-free and that after the CW he doesn't want to tell any more stories around Anakin and Co, you feel he's bound to change his mind as he has before...

---

nett40 posted:

---

Gry Sarth posted:

---

Interesting that now you're using the "GL said it" card. So when GL says there won't be more films, you accept that as fact. But when he says the LAS will be Jedi-free and that after the CW he doesn't want to tell any more stories around Anakin and Co, you feel he's bound to change his mind as he has before...

---

Haven't you used that CARD against me countless times during our small discussion, all I get from you is, that I'm wrong... You haven't even once given your idea about what the LAS should be about.

---

Drewton posted:

---

Oh please.

What we're saying is is that YOU'RE simply giving your idea of what the LAS should be and completely unrealistically. Why would he give his idea of what it SHOULD be like?

---

nett40 posted:

---

Drewton posted:

---

Oh please.

What we're saying is is that YOU'RE simply giving your idea of what the LAS should be and completely unrealistically. Why would he give his idea of what it SHOULD be like?

---

Well, the thread is "What's going on with the Live Action show"

---

Drewton posted:

---

nett40 posted:

---

Drewton posted:

---

Oh please.

What we're saying is is that YOU'RE simply giving your idea of what the LAS should be and completely unrealistically. Why would he give his idea of what it SHOULD be like?

---

Well, the thread is "What's going on with the Live Action show"

---

...which is completely different from the question of what the live-action show should be like.

---

nett40 posted:

---

Drewton posted:

---

nett40 posted:

---

[quote=Drewton]Oh please.

What we're saying is is that YOU'RE simply giving your idea of what the LAS should be and completely unrealistically. Why would he give his idea of what it SHOULD be like?

---

Well, the thread is "What's going on with the Live Action show"

---

...which is completely different from the question of what the live-action show should be like.

---

nett40 posted:

---

Haven't you used that CARD against me countless times during our small discussion

---

nett40 posted:

---

You haven't even once given your idea about what the LAS should be about.

---

nett40 posted:

---

I've tried to reason and answer the same question countless times, to no avail.

---

nett40 posted:

---

Whenever I say that GL tend to change his mind, I'm being unreasonable.

---

nett40 posted:

---

But it has to have a beginning, don't say it already has that with the extended universe and countless books... GL doesn't care about the EU, he wants to tell a good story...

---

Gry Sarth posted:

---

nett40 posted:

---

But it has to have a beginning, don't say it already has that with the extended universe and countless books... GL doesn't care about the EU, he wants to tell a good story...

---

I'm not saying the beginning is in the EU. The beginning is in Prequel Trilogy and the CW series. What you're proposing is that even THAT is not enough, it all has to be retold yet again...

---

Article posted:

---

The show is assembling high-quality writers from the Aussie TV industry, including writers from the Love My Way and Secret Life of Us, who have been approached by Lucas' longtime producer Rick McCallum.

---

tf.net posted:

---

"Currently, the favourite to be announced as one the TV series’ scribes is Australian TV producer and writer, John Edwards. If appointed, Edwards, who has been responsible for a clutch of successful domestic shows, including Out Of The Blue and Fireflies, will likely find himself under intense scrutiny from the most dedicated fanbase in the world."

---