[HCSF] Tell me how good it was!

I got a break in the afternoon on Friday and went to see it.

WOW. I need to see it again. Thanks all!

 

I felt very indifferent after seeing it. Not sure if I loved it or hated it.

Strange. Still trying to figure out my emotions now.

 

How long has it been since your viewing? I felt that way for a bit, too.

 

Yes, It was only last night. I remember your first review thread and you explained this feeling. I had no clue it would hit me like that too. Really don't know what to think about it.

 

Dunno about it being better than Empire - I think my rating would go something like this:

TESB
ANH
ROTS - tied 3rd place
AOTC - tied 3rd place
ROTJ - tied 3rd place
TPM

That said, this may change on the 2nd viewing, but there were many scenes that *could* have been the best of the six, but were let down by one reason or another. Of course, with a film like this, its always hard to differentiate between not liking the film an not liking how the film made you feel (think saving private ryan or schindlers list) - there are many heart breaking moments indeed ;_;

 

It was much better the second time. I was able to enjoy it much more.

My rankings have even changed with the second viewing.

TESB
ANH
ROTS
ROTJ
TPM
AOTC

-Seldon