Blaine_The_Mono posted:The Jedi say that the Sith are extinct but they don't know everything.
r8hitman posted:[quote=Blaine_The_Mono]The Jedi say that the Sith are extinct but they don't know everything.
thechozn1 posted:r8hitman posted:[quote=Blaine_The_Mono]The Jedi say that the Sith are extinct but they don't know everything. But see it's implied in the movie that they would have known about the "legend of Darth Plagueis", so how do you answer that one? They knew about it? Anakin had never heard of it. It's one of two things, (1) Sids is older than dirt and dates back a millenia, or (2) and most likely it was a sith legend which meant only the sith knew about it. That would kinda narrow it down to Sids being the only one knowing. The novel says that Anakin wanted to become a master to get into the deeper parts of the library and find out about the legend, but who knows if it was there
RolandofGilead posted:There's no better weapon for a liar than the truth. Dooku used it to great advantage in AotC when he told Obi-wan everything only to have the Jedi disbelieve him. The same holds here I think. Plagueis was real, and in the original script Sidious admits that he killed him in his sleep. Whether he truly learned to conquer death we will never know. But Sids seemed to take great pleasure in explaining how he could save everyone execpt himself. That gleam in his eye tells me he knows all about Plaugueis and his death from a very personal level.
thechozn1 posted:All Anakin had to do was simply ask Yoda or go to the library and find out. Again, the novel has your answer along with my previous post. He was only a Knight. He could not get into the "deeper" parts of the library that talked about force powers of the dark side. Only masters could do this. He couldn't just run down there and check it out
