DUGGY posted:BothofUs posted:I love that DSinister just comes in with the 'real answer' then he reveals that it's just from a book. Fact is, when it's not on screen, you can have it be any reason you want. Stop stealing people's imagination, Sinister. Is this forum not to include EU? Ouch! , But yeah, i was always under the impression that EU does not count here. does it?
BothofUs posted:I love that DSinister just comes in with the 'real answer' then he reveals that it's just from a book. Fact is, when it's not on screen, you can have it be any reason you want. Stop stealing people's imagination, Sinister. Is this forum not to include EU?
The_Chibi_Kiriyama posted:It's jsut odd that she's a little more than 5 months preggers with twins and doesn't even have the trademark bump. Either she was anorexic when they bumped the buoy or that dress of hers is the secret staging area for the Death Star as well.
voodoopuuduu posted: When Anakin meets Padme behind a column in the Senate office building hallway, one of the things he says to her is : "If the Chancellor hadnt been kidnapped, I dont think they would have ever brought us back from the Outer Rim seiges". A few scenes later in the Jedi council chambers, we see Mace, Yoda and Eeth Koth basically sitting on their butts. Yoda later volunteers to go help the Wookies, a task which IMO, is of lesser importance than saving the Chancellor. My question is, why drag Anakin and Obi-Wan half way across the galaxy to save the Chancellor when Yoda, Mace and Eeth are only 70 miles away ? The Outer Rim was still under siege as Kashyyyk is somewhere around there. And if they suspected Dooku along with Grevious was holding Palps, Anakin and Obi-Wan would not be the best decision to send, ie AOTC. Yoda should have been the one to go. So what is it, Yoda, Mace or Eeth cant pilot a ship ? Or are they just plain lazy ? Or prima donnas ? Any thoughts ?
voodoopuuduu posted:Is this forum not to include EU? Unfortunately, thats about as close to canon as were going to get. The thing is, the line "If the Chancellor hadnt been kidnapped, I dont think they would have ever brought us back from the Outer Rim seiges" wasnt necessary at all for the movie. I think it was just to tie up the Clone Wars cartoon. A better line may have been "I didnt think we would ever get back" period.
voodoopuuduu posted:that called for reinforcement from whereever they could get ... Yes, but my point was why drag Anakin and Obi-Wan half way across the galaxy to save the Chancellor when Yoda, Mace and Eeth are only 70 miles away ?
voodoopuuduu posted:Was'nt it? If that line was'nt there I bet a lot of people would'nt have gathered that Anakin was away from Padme a long time. It would have just seemed that Obi and Ani lifted off from Coruscant to rescue the Chancellor Good point, and I agree somewhat. But as it is now, we have the people wondering about the outer rim seiges and why he was away. Maybe explaining the fact that he was away for a long time could have been worked in with the previous scenes with Obi-Wan.
