ZamWesell44 posted:and he was not more powerful.
Rossa83 posted:Farrelg: If you think the possee was good, then surely you can't believe that Anakin can beat Mace? seeing that Mace bested Sideous!! I must admit though that I think the possee came off as rather pathetic... it was bad choreography really. The emperor was powerful, no doubting that, but that would be just a better reason to move some!!
Rossa83 posted:There really isn't much proof that turning to the dark side will in fact make you stronger.
ZamWesell44 posted:How is Mace a different matter than Dooku who beat Kenobi twice, which is not easy, and he beat him in ROTS like he was a clonetrooper.
-HD-YaebGinn posted:ZamWesell44 posted:How is Mace a different matter than Dooku who beat Kenobi twice, which is not easy, and he beat him in ROTS like he was a clonetrooper. you are contradicting yourself. You just said it is not easy to beat Kenobi twice. Anakin couldn't even do that. He ended up at the bottom of a fiery hill. Yet 'he (anakin) beat him (dooku) in ROTS like he was a clonetrooper' Yet you insist his trying to work within Sidios's plan of keeping Anakin alive had anything to do with him losing. And you still havent addressed any of my points in my previous posts. (pages 14 and 15 if you need to recap) The books are not canon. You should not take them as so.
farrellg posted:Rossa83 posted:Farrelg: If you think the possee was good, then surely you can't believe that Anakin can beat Mace? seeing that Mace bested Sideous!! I must admit though that I think the possee came off as rather pathetic... it was bad choreography really. The emperor was powerful, no doubting that, but that would be just a better reason to move some!! I never said Anakin can beat Mace. I think Mace is more powerful during ROTS. The posse didn't have a chance to move because the Emperor was so fast. Rossa83 posted:There really isn't much proof that turning to the dark side will in fact make you stronger. Lucas says that it will make you stronger. We saw how the Emperor's powers completely overmatched Luke's "feeble" Jedi skills.
Master_EdgeCrusher posted:may I ask which ones are false? Lucas woud tell them what to write!
ZamWesell44 posted: Sidious could not have planned Anakin cutting off Mace's arm? Yeah ok, he just became emperor and worked with the jedi for years without them knowing he was a sith but he could not plan that. He was faking when he was on the ground clearly, saying he was too weak, after seeing him throw pods as Yoda while floating on another, and shooting lighting so intensly it took his saber out im thinking he could have taken Mace out without the saber. And Dooku was trying to kill Anakin, he figured out in the middle of the fight what was going on and tried to beat him but could not,b/c he kept getting stronger. And kenobi beat Anakin not because he was stronger, he trained him. Anakin does not know his a$$ from his elbow? whatever that means, i guess its lucky for Kenobi that pathetic Anakin was there to save his life 10 times, and carry him over his shoulder after he got smoked by Dooku.
Ani_Lover posted: People can say what they want, Anakin DID lose to Obi-Wan because of emotion. That was his best friend, brother, father figure, everything to him. Hate and love are two sides of the same coin. If Anakin would have had his head together in The Duel like he would have fighting anyone else, HE WOULD HAVE WON. Anakin could take Mace out in a heartbeat. As for Sids- Mace DID NOT have him beat! As said above me, Sids was faking it.
