NickLitYouAFlame posted:I don't think that he means the character needs to be average or mediocre. But, even a super-genius or nearly all powerful being has dreams, and hopes and wishes. But you have to be able to express all of the complexity of human, or even alien, emotions in the way a functioning human would. Recreating that balance of emotion is difficult, even more so when you think about the different species involved with Star Wars.
LightWarden posted:Why is it that so few heroic characters around here are genuinely flawed (and the related issue: so many villainous characters are simply boring)?
LightWarden posted:I'm not talking about kicking puppies here, I'm talking about characters having actual blemishes on their personalities. Things like laziness, tendency to procrastinate, refusal to admit to failure, gullibility, vindictiveness, short attention span, love of... ooh, shiny things. Or just things that make a character somewhat odd. I'm also annoyed by the people who just graft things on because they feel as though they need a quirk. It feels fake. One thing I am seriously annoyed with is the flow of information in the game. I mean, everyone seems to know about Tatooine and Hoth, despite the fact that one is an out-of-the-way sun-blasted rockball and the other is a desolate frozen wasteland that didn't have anything resembling a survey until the Rebellion scouted it out after Yavin. They know everyone of any major importance in the history of the Republic. They know everything about the Jedi and what they do, with nothing resembling any form of misinformation, despite the fact that there are more planets in the Republic than there are Jedi. They know about the Sith and their red lightsabers, despite the fact that they were blown to bits a thousand years prior, and they know about the Rule of Two despite that being a rather top-secret bit of cryptic information passed to the Jedi council by an otherwise insane Padawan. I know that there's a limit to your knowledge, but seriously guys... make things up. The movies were full of what originally were throw-away references to absolutely nothing in particular that conveyed a general idea. They didn't spend the whole film talking about things you had already seen. So make mistakes, be confused and ill-informed, talk about things no one else will understand (especially if you're not from one of the major planets covered by the movies/EU). Hold completely groundless beliefs (The "Hero with No Fear" was killed by Vader, the Jedi eat babies, the Empire has mind-controlling space termites, the Potentium is a legitimate philosophy, Mandalorians are honorable warriors, etc.) I'm just sick of trying to smack people for doing things like referring to Wampas during the Old Republic era.