TheBoogieMan posted:I'll say it again: If Harry is a Horcrux it was entirely accidental and Voldemort does not know it, although he may suspect. Notice no attempts by Voldemort to kill Potter since GOF? In fact, his death eaters appear to be under orders not to attack him, and save it for the Dark Lord.
JEDI_TEEGIRLOO posted:I do like the Mirror of Erised theory makes alot more sense to me than Harry being a horcrux.
PadmeLeiaJaina posted:Well according to Mugglenet, these are the only CONFIRMED debunked items from JK herself about book 7: Listen carefully, I shall say this only once: the only sources you should trust concerning information on the Half-Blood Prince are official spokespeople for my publishers and my official website. - JK Rowling, JKRowling.com * The title of the book will not be "Harry Potter and the Pyramids of Furmat." * There will be no character named "Icicle," and JK said that she didn't recall saying there ever would be. * Dumbledore is not a relative of Harry. * Harry is not related to Voldemort and he is not related to Salazar Slytherin. * Lily Potter is not alive. * Lily was not a Death Eater. * No prequel books are planned (no books before Harry's time at Hogwarts). * Crookshanks is not an Animagus. * Neville is not the son of Peter Pettigrew. (Where do these people come up with this stuff?!) * Remus Lupin does not have a twin brother. * JK does not have any parts in the films. Note, nothing about Harry being a Horcrux, however I swear I read an article w/ her somewhere that she flat out stated that Ginny nor Harry are horcruxes...she said it just wasn't possible. I'll have to hunt for the article.
Moleman1138 posted:I am totally backing the Mirror of Erised as a horcrux Jo doesn't throw things in haphazardly. I continued to analyze and analyze and everything is starting to fit. 1. Sorcerer's Stone Horcrux: (Mirror of Erised - Ravenclaw Heirloom) "Only something who wanted to find the stone and not use it could get it through the mirror" DADA: Quirell (Wanted to use the stone) 2. Chamber of Secrets Horcrux: (Tom Riddle's Diary) "Used to manipulate Ginny into opening the Chamber of Secrets" DADA: Lockhart (Sent down into the Chamber due to his "expertise") 3. Prisoner of Azkaban Horcrux: (Hufflepuff Cup? or Gryffindor Heirloom?) "Don't know the relation of Hufflepuff to Lupin and Sirius / Gryffindor heirloom would work" DADA: Lupin (He was the leak that brought Sirius the POA to Hogwarts/Hogsmeade) 4. Goblet of Fire Horcrux: (Voldemort himself) "Moody manipulated TriWizard Tourament to get Harry to the Dark Lord (what soul was left)" DADA: Moody (Really Barty Crouch Jr. who manipulated the GOF and sent Harry to Voldemort) 5. Order of the Phoenix Horcrux: (Slytherin Locket - Slytherin Heirloom) "At #12 Grimmauld Place, Headquarters of the Order of the Phoenix" DADA: Umbridge (some relationship to the locket and OOTP) 6. Half-Blood Prince Horcrux: (Gaunt Ring) "Dumbledore destroyed the Gaunt Ring" DADA: Snape (Killed the destroyer of the Gaunt Ring and is the Half-Blood Prince) 7. (Unknown Title) Horcrux: (Hufflepuff Cup, Gryffindor Heirloom or Nagini) "unknown how horcrux will be related to DADA and title" DADA: Unknown (somehow will be related to the title and the horcrux) Everything is starting to fit quite nicely now. There's a few small things to be ironed out, but I think I've got this down.
Moleman1138 posted: I am totally backing the Mirror of Erised as a horcrux
Moleman1138 posted:3. Prisoner of Azkaban Horcrux: (Hufflepuff Cup? or Gryffindor Heirloom?) "Don't know the relation of Hufflepuff to Lupin and Sirius / Gryffindor heirloom would work" DADA: Lupin (He was the leak that brought Sirius the POA to Hogwarts/Hogsmeade)
