Anapad_Nabooine posted:~~~Happy (belated) Birthday, Qui-Dawn~~~ Qui-Dawn posted: She was, after all, *out* there - somewhere in that vast and endless, cruel and harsh, unforgiving brutal hell and inferno of a desert, trapped out there, captive and terrified and facing the Force only knew what manner of heinous pain and violence, in the wanton and merciless clutches of creatures whose only desire and intention was obviously just to inflict yet more hurt, and torture still further, and in general just treat her, *her*, his own *mother* above all, with such utter and appalling sadism....she was out there, facing precisely that for weeks on end... Dawn. There is something that still puzzles me. I get the strong impression that most people of the TFN fandom think that Anakin slaughtering the sand people was completely horrible and evidence of his own depravity. Maybe it’s not ‘politically correct’ to say but I don’t think the act was all that bad and some good actually came from it. If in the GFFA all life is a part of the Force and there’s a light and dark side, then surely the sand people were of the dark (very bad) side of the Force. (I say very bad because I'm of the school that thinks the dark side is the imbalance in the Force and not that light and dark are equally necessary for balance.) From what I’ve seen in the OT and the PT these life forms called Tusken Raiders attack and kill without provocation and evidently they can't be reasoned with. And if they capture other beings, well…there’s nothing else to do but torture them – for pleasure or for whatever other reason. So I think Anakin did everybody on Tatooine a favor by ridding the planet of at least one group of them. I realize in the heat of rage and grief that this wasn’t his motivation and that to let our passions drive our actions without thought is wrong and dangerous; but I don’t see this particular mass killing as some grave evil for which Anakin would deserve a grave punishment, such as a prison sentence or expulsion from the Jedi Order if the Council found out. I think he did need some grave counseling about the loss of his mother and the way she died as well as a little “passion-management.” And when I say counseling I mean something a little more substantial than being quoted Jedi words of wisdom like "you must learn to let go." Now I know I’m mentioning things that have certainly been discussed before around the forums but I've previously been away for a while and returned to find the same issues. I just feel like when I’m venturing into certain other threads – particularly those dealing with Anakin Skywalker or the Prequel Trilogy – that perhaps I am from a gffa because: (a) I like Anakin; (b) I like the Prequel Trilogy; (c) I don’t hate Jar-Jar Binks; and (d) I don’t dislike any part of the saga enough to make me dislike one of the films or the entire Prequel Trilogy. I realize that no poster is prohibited from posting on any given thread because of their likes or dislikes but I have a dream…that one day…a single thread where fans of the PT (The Phantom Menace and Attack of the Clones in particular!) can post without being molested by flamers, trolls and other haters – because it seems to me that the latter rule most of the film and character discussion threads on this site. Maybe this - like my alpha points above - are just 'from a certain point of view' but it's real enough to me. So my choice is ‘to read or not to read.’ To keep a negativity-free zone in my head, I’m going to have to stick to the kinder gentler threads. Although some interesting topics exist in nearby Mustafar-ian lands, I prefer now to stay with The Naboo. And after this I will complain no more. I’ll just cheerfully hang out with the happier minority and take trips in “neutral space.” And here’s my version of cheerfully hangin’ out!...
Qui-Dawn posted: She was, after all, *out* there - somewhere in that vast and endless, cruel and harsh, unforgiving brutal hell and inferno of a desert, trapped out there, captive and terrified and facing the Force only knew what manner of heinous pain and violence, in the wanton and merciless clutches of creatures whose only desire and intention was obviously just to inflict yet more hurt, and torture still further, and in general just treat her, *her*, his own *mother* above all, with such utter and appalling sadism....she was out there, facing precisely that for weeks on end... Dawn.
MissPadme posted:Anapad_Nabooine My view on the Tusken Raider scene really doesn't fit into any neat pigeon hole. I can understand Anakin's fury; if I were in his shoes I would at least feel like doing the same thing. He probably did the local moisture farmers a favor by removing them as a nuisance. But I'm not the Chosen One or a Jedi with mondo Force powers. I think the idea with these movies is that those with these extraordinary powers have to police themselves more than the rest of us do because they can cause so much more damage. Anakin, as he said, knew better and still acted out of his own pain and anger. It was the beginning of the end for poor Anakin, which is why it was referenced again in ROTS. ROTSFan I've read a few fan fics where in some ways Vader was still "fully functional" . If what PMT99 said was true, then why would Vader need that cod piece ? That said, I think that Vader was probably fed intravenously and used GFFA astronaut diapers. Poor guy. I'd be choking incompetent Imperial officers for laughs and giggles too. --MissPadme
Anapad_Nabooine posted:Now I know I’m mentioning things that have certainly been discussed before around the forums but I've previously been away for a while and returned to find the same issues. I just feel like when I’m venturing into certain other threads – particularly those dealing with Anakin Skywalker or the Prequel Trilogy – that perhaps I am from a gffa because: (a) I like Anakin; (b) I like the Prequel Trilogy; (c) I don’t hate Jar-Jar Binks; and (d) I don’t dislike any part of the saga enough to make me dislike one of the films or the entire Prequel Trilogy. I realize that no poster is prohibited from posting on any given thread because of their likes or dislikes but I have a dream…that one day…a single thread where fans of the PT (The Phantom Menace and Attack of the Clones in particular!) can post without being molested by flamers, trolls and other haters – because it seems to me that the latter rule most of the film and character discussion threads on this site. Maybe this - like my alpha points above - are just 'from a certain point of view' but it's real enough to me. So my choice is ‘to read or not to read.’ To keep a negativity-free zone in my head, I’m going to have to stick to the kinder gentler threads. Although some interesting topics exist in nearby Mustafar-ian lands, I prefer now to stay with The Naboo. And after this I will complain no more. I’ll just cheerfully hang out with the happier minority and take trips in “neutral space.”
MissPadme posted:As hot and sexy ROTS Anakin was, I still loves me some padawan AOTC Anakin . --MissPadme
Qui-Dawn posted:Mmmmmmmmm....don't mind me, I was just sitting here intently and rather thoroughly and, ahem, perhaps even also quite attentively, admiring and musing over....Anakin's lightsaber....and by that I think I do mean, of course (although, wait, just what do you think I mean, eh? *sly, teasing smile* ....
Qui-Dawn posted:....and, well, hey, in the interests of total honesty - you *are* quite right there, aye, most definitely,
Qui-Dawn posted:Just for the sake of, you know, seeing how much sensation is actually there, in this new limb not-perhaps-born-with-it-his, yet-meaningfully-and-fundamentally-now-it-*is*-very-much-his-anyway, and so considering all that, well, methinks indeed that it really *would* be something else he'd be quite keen and hopeful, and soon enough at that, to find out, to *try* out, for himself.... To, then, simply - see just how sensitive it might be, the spread of these new fingertips and this new broad palm and lower arm of gleaming gold and a marvellously complex and intricately interwoven array of wires and circuitry, connectors and leads....there would be, then, really only one viable way to find out, to properly and fittingly test it out fully....or at any rate, hrmmmm, surely only pretty much the one way that Anakin himself would be most hopeful and inclined to try it out, then, to know for sure....ahem.
Ani_Lover posted: I love me some handcuffed Padawan Ani.
ROTSFan posted:He looks really young in AOTC but still cute for that age. He's got great hands