MissPadme posted:As for what Anakin does to Padmé, it was important to show the wages of choosing the Dark Side. He loses Padmé and it's because of the path Anakin chose. --MissPadme
ROTSFan posted:MissPadme posted:As for what Anakin does to Padmé, it was important to show the wages of choosing the Dark Side. He loses Padmé and it's because of the path Anakin chose. --MissPadme Very true. The answer to the story is "plot" (conflict/resolution) and it is epic in nature. Also, Anakin failed to realize that Yoda, while unaware of his/Padme's marriage, was giving him very sound advice--if he had "let go" and had faith the Emperor couldn't have gained control and Padme would have lived. But he wasn't emotionally strong enough to do the right thing, and the wages of sin are death (sorry I'm just on a Biblical kick or something ) he was already on the dark side and he believed when the emperor told him he killed padme(even though vader said he felt her alive) so what was the point of force choking padme? I'm not sure exactly what you mean....I don't really think there was a point to force choking Padme. I think he saw her with Obi-Wan, surmised they were both against him, and in his anger lashed out to teach her a lesson. I don't believe, however, that he choked her to kill her, just to silence what he perceived to be her "lying" excuses (kind of like a husband beating his wife). He could still feel that she was alive on the platform, and indeed the Polis Massan droids confirmed that there was nothing biologically wrong with her.
anakinandpadmedoomed posted:If only I could write like dawn..she at least can get her thoughts down
anakinandpadmedoomed posted:Does anybody else get sad when they watch ROTS?
anakinandpadmedoomed posted:I wish george would of done a alternative ending..does that sound like a good or bad idea?i know this is an anakin thread so I will say..could george of made an alternative ending concerning anakin not force choking padme? that was harsh.and i think unneeded..he was already on the dark side and he believed when the emperor told him he killed padme(even though vader said he felt her alive) so what was the point of force choking padme?
Darthana posted:anakinandpadmedoomed posted:Does anybody else get sad when they watch ROTS? Yup. Me. Every time when I watch it. But only after a half an hour into the movie, because then is when things get ugly, when Anakin starts falling deeper and deeper into Palpatine's web of lies, where he and Padme grow more distant from each other, when the Dark Side really starts working. ROTS is a tragic movie, with the elements of an ancient Greek tragedy and 18th century romantism in Europe. George did well by combining all that into a science fiction story, it's just that so many people (bashers) don't understand the beauty of it all. ROTS never ment to have a happy ending, we all knew that even before the movie entered production, but still, this makes me somehow even sader when I watch it. I just didnt feel the full impact of the sadness until I watched the OT again..that makes it sadder.. anakinandpadmedoomed posted:I wish george would of done a alternative ending..does that sound like a good or bad idea?i know this is an anakin thread so I will say..could george of made an alternative ending concerning anakin not force choking padme? that was harsh.and i think unneeded..he was already on the dark side and he believed when the emperor told him he killed padme(even though vader said he felt her alive) so what was the point of force choking padme? I'd definitely go and see that! But no, it's not a good idea, that I'm sure. It's the story, it never ment to have a happy ending, no matter what I would prefer to happen in the end. But as an alternative, I'd really want an Anakin and Padme novel. I mean, the deserve it! Just a tiny bit of happy time in their lives. How about that? I agree.That is a silly idea of an alternative ending..just wishful thinking maybe..sorry. YES..a novel with just padme and anakin..there is the fanfics ,but I would want to include things I would want in there ..you know? I dont know what I was expecting out of ROTS I'm just feeling the impact of the unhappiness now..like a delayed reaction or something. I am glad GL didnt go with the novel of ROTS and had anakin choking her and throwing her.(i might of remembered that wrong..please correct if it is)that would of been bad enough..plus she was pregant!If thats true, I cant believe the author did that to A/P.but I go by the movie and not the novels thankfully..Im just saying Im glad GL didnt do that to her in the movie. If only I could write like dawn..she at least can get her thoughts down I agree. I wish I could do that so nicely as well.
anakinandpadmedoomed posted:that's terrible ,I hope you can find another one or something just as good.