CT A proposed new scene to ANH

Mod edit: No thanks

 

1. How did he get on Alderaan?

2. Why would he be on Alderaan.

3. This is, imo, a poor idea for several reasons. It would detract from the anxiety of the scene, completely ruin the suspense, and it contributes nothing to the story.

4. This is a joke thread, I know. But points 1-3 were reacting seriously to this.

5. In before the lock

 

1. Probably by a starship.

2. Everybody in the Galaxy hates him because he gave the Emperor emergency powers, except Bail, because he knows Jar Jar is just an idiot. And Jar Jar wants to celebrate his birthday with somebody who doesn't hate him. Although Bail probably hates him too, he's likely just too polite to say it.

3. Opinions need no rebuttal. Opinions are like a...ah....ahs...What's the rest of that quote again?

4. Who says this is a Joke? I would totally get on board with any scene including Jar Jar's death.

5. Why would this be locked?

 

1. Fair logic.

2. Plenty of people liked him though. Padme showed a clear positive relationship with him.

3. I agree entirely, which is why I said that this is poor in my opinion.

4. It seems to be a joke, given the rampant internet and all its contents.

5. Because I'd bet mods would deem it lock-worthy.

 

If I had a dream like this, first thing I'd do is see a therapist.