Well, I voted okay on the PT, and that is because there are things about the PT I liked and other things I don't. TPM is kinda so bad it's good for me. If I watch it, I totally switch my brain off to enjoy it. While I do have fun watching the movie ... I don't respect it. I can't take it seriously. It is like watching Flash Gordon, only Flash Gordon is more fun. AOTC I hate with a passion. Awful, awful movie. The only worthwhile part was the escape scene in the beginning. Padmé marries a mass murderer and Dooku tells the Jedi his entire plan. Nothing in the movie really makes any sense. ROTS is a good movie though bogged down with some stupidity. Stupid character behavior and stupid characters. But at the same time it contains a lot of good scene, so on total I like the movie. It might even be on par with ROTJ ... no, who am I kidding? It isn't. As for the whole political plot, it doesn't work for me. Palpatine is either too lucky or the other politicians/Jedi order too dumb. Politics (especially in TPM) often don't make any sense. Why couldn't they have done politics like in Babylon 5? As for Anakins arc, it works somewhat, but on many levels it fails. Too much has been omitted that would've been important for the story. Also he goes bad way too soon (AOTC). He has already fallen in that movie which makes ROTS a farce. For that reason, I try to ignore AOTC.