Amph A Song of Ice and Fire Discussion Thread

Hmmmm... I don't remember him poisoning Tywin at all; or was that the cause of his intestinal distress which leads to a crossbow colonic later?

 

Here's a detailed explanation.

Like I said, it's debatable.

 

The Red Viper is awesome, also my favourite minor character. I was mentally cheering during his Mountain fight.


ELIAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA OF DOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOORNE

I haven't watched much of the show...however I did have to laugh at SD's post about Robb being smarter than Littlefinger and Varys. Littlefinger is probably the smartest man in the plot, I think.

 

I don't much like the Red Viper, but I appreciate his loyalty to his sister. This was honorable.

 

I just found it amusing because how Robb (along with Ned) is probably the most clueless and naive characters in the book. Seeing how almost all his political decisions seem to be made with the intended fact of helping him lose the war.

 

Well SD will soon find out that Tywin and Littlefinger are far above Robb in terms of plotting. lol

 

It is shame through that HBO seems like it has been going out of its way to make the event much less tragic.

 

Oh that's a bloody lovely little theory.

 

Concerning the "guest rights" discussion in the TV thread, I found this and was amused:

 

Nice.

I still hate the ****ing Freys, though.

 

LOL

 

I am eagerly awaiting Walder's gruesome death.

 

Yeah, they're all the ***holery of the Greyjoys with none of the cheesy fun.

 

Nah I want him to die of old age after his house has been brought to ruin. As in no heirs left. His plans all come to nothing.

Perwyn or Olyvar could inherit though, they seem okay.

 

Roslin Frey also seems okay, meybe they could have it so her and Edmure's second child can receive the Twins after the Tullys are restored to power alongside the Starks.

 

Yeah, the only thing stopping me from buying into that is the couple decent Frey kids. So I'll stick with "eaten by direwolf."

 

I think Lady Stoneheart deserves the honor of taking down the Late Lord Walder Frey, especially seeing how there is an upcoming wedding between the Lannister and Frey family coming up in Riverrun. Where I might add BWB member Tom of Sevenstreams is currently residing.

 

I feel bad for Daven though, he's one of those okay Lannisters.

 

Yeah, he's taken that title from Kevan now.

 

Who's the Lannister heir after Kevan anyway? Lancel?

EDIT: Oh wait, he's not in the line of succession either. I guess it would be Martyn then.

 

Tommen is the best of the Lannisters.

 

Cersie is the current Lady of the Rock, with Tommen being her heir and then it being Myrcella, as she is the only child of Tywin that can inherit seeing how Jaime is Kingsguard and Tyrion is a kinslayer.

 

I forgot that Kevan acknowledged her for some reason even though he's the closest living male heir.

 

I think female children are still preferred to uncles except for the Targaryens.

 

Oh.