I finished it last night. Whilst I can understand why some people are disappointed with it, I enjoyed it very much. I especially enjoyed Theon's, Davos, Asha's, Jon's and Barristans chapters, whilst Tyrion's were solid. Connington, Jaime and Cersei also had good chapters, although I would have liked more of them. Dany's last couple of chapters really made up for her first few in terms of action and suspense. Arya's were dull for me, but then I didn't like her Faceless man training in AFFC either. What I really enjoyed from this book was all the background info and different perspectives we got on a variety of characters. Particularly, I was stoked with Jon's death scene, simply because it matches the prophecy of Azor Ahai so well. Similarly, it seems that Mirri Maez Durr's claim about Dany's ability to bare children has concluded, with Quentyn's death acting as the sun setting in the East. 8.5/10 for me.