Anakin, Dark Master or Light Master?

As we all saw, Anakin did an amazing job handling Dooku as a Jedi but he could Not defeat Obi-Wan as a Sith apprentice.

My question for you guys....

Do you think Anakin is stronger as a Jedi or a Sith?


I think Anakin fought better as a Jedi even though he held his anger and frustration in check. The fact that Padme loved him, made him that much of a better fighter.
Without her, he was lost both as a Sith and as a warrior in my opinion.

 

Anakin of course was a better Jedi. As a Sith the two times he fought Obi-Wan he acted like he had something to prove.

But in the end he's a Jedi anyway so he's a Master Jedi.

 

If Anakin had stayed a Jedi,and actually applied himself fully to the training,he would've been stronger than he ever could've been as a Sith.

When he was a sith,he was too emotional and brash. Thats what got his limbs cut off and thats what put him into the suit. That also kept him on the Emporer's leash.

If he was able to control his fear,he could've continued to rise to the most powerful jedi. GL even said if Anakin had not been placed in the Suit, he could've destroyed Palp.

He just needed patience.

 

I felt that he was better as a Jedi becuz being a Sith made him blind and overconfident and almost got him killed.

 

Anakin, Dark Master or Light Master?

Neither.

Anakin was always trying to become a master, but he never really did. As Obi-Wan stated in RotS, it's what he wanted. Anakin wanted to be on the council, believing he would become a master by default. Anakin/Vader boasted to be the master in ANH when he faced off against Obi-Wan just to further prove he was better than him because he was a Sith. Still, he was the apprentice and he knew it. He tried to become the master by attempting to get Luke to join him, but that didn't go well. Even when Darth Sidious was killed, he didn't become the master as he had left the Dark Side to save his own son.

It's just another curse of his; he tries and he fails.

[]=====#[]<---------------- M_N! ----------------

 

Anakin as Sith = bitter cripple with asthma.
Anakin as Jedi = whole and at one with the force.

Light Master.

 

Anakin, Dark Master or Light Master?

Only a master of evil.

 

He was a master of both the dark and the light.

 

I agree, both.

Good Stuff

 

Well i almost have to say Dark because his big accomplishment as a Jedi was defeating Dooku, and he did that by giving in to his anger in that battle.

 

I disagree with that.

When he lost Padme, it made Anakin more insane and less of a fighter.
He was a much better fighter as a Jedi.

 

Considering he is the best Jedi ever, he would be good in both.

 

Anakin, Dark Master or Light Master?


Master of the force.

 

Anakin is a better Jedi if he uses his anger to a certain amount. The fight against Dooku wasn't PURELY Jedi, but I'm not saying it was a Sith way of fighting. He was just in the middle, and I think he does a far better job in limbo.

 

Yeah when anakin won battles he wasn't a sith but he wasn't exactly a jedi either, he used his anger to power him like when he fought dooku or even when he fought asajj ventress he was mad that Obi didn't trust him and used that anger on asajj