Just stopping by to say I love your discussion... You're all nailing Vader perfectly and I just love this analogy with the yin and yang. Really fitting. The idea of a test for the Jedi is something I never thought about. But it makes sense. I don't necessarily believe that the Jedi were completely at fault because let's face it, Anakin's responsible, but it's funny how with all their talks about Anakin being arrogant, only Yoda noticed that they were all getting arrogant... I wonder if Yoda will not be the first to understand how they all failed in ROTS.