As a Star Wars fan, I don't see why on earth other Star Wars fans are so against other films like LOTR and Spiderman? I agree with you, we are all supposed to be fans of 'film' and there is no law against being a fan of all types of movies... I guess though, what's hjappening, is alot of people come here and say things like "LOTR is the movie AOTC should be or Spiderman is 10 times the movie AOTC is" so there is a natural tendancy to fight back and there is a sort of backlash against those movies... So comparing any of those films, in my opinion is like comparing a car to a motorocycle - they will both get you from point A to point B, but whih ride to you enjoy more? Everybody's answer is different.