Now let me preface by saying that I actually do really enjoy AOTC. However my feelings toward the film can be broken down into more of a "love/hate" relationship. So the rules of this game are....well just look below and you will see for yourself. LOVE: Dooku v. Yoda (Yoda in action rocks) HATE: Dooku as a character (too one-dimensional) LOVE: The Detective story HATE: The fact that Lucas will never allow the mystery to be solved regarding who erased the Jedi Archives. LOVE: The courtship of Padme HATE: The INSTANT courtship of Padme LOVE: Anakin's adult character HATE: Anakin's dialogue LOVE: Jar Jar Binks limited role HATE: Jar Jar Binks LOVE: The pit fight on Geonosis HATE: The fact that Padme never gets dirty LOVE: The suspense of Padme in the smelting pot HATE: The fact that Padme never gets dirty in the smelting pot. LOVE: The Coruscant chase of Zam Wessell HATE: The dialogue exchange between Obi and Anakin during the chase. LOVE: Obi Wan as Anakin's master HATE: How they never are truly established as friends LOVE: The events on Kamino HATE: Nothing about Kamino...everything on Kamino rocked. LOVE: How Lucas shows a computer diagram of the Death Star plans on the wall of the Geonosis Headquarters just before they are going to evacuate. HATE: How Lucas has to have Dooku show the plans one more time just to make sure the audience didn't miss it the first time. LOVE: Dooku dueling with Yoda HATE: The "..but our skills with a light saber" line..seemed too hammy. Suggestion: Just draw the saber don't tell the audience what you are going to do. LOVE: Padme's sexier outfits HATE: That her outfits weren't sexy enough. LOVE: Padme and Anakin on Naboo HATE: Anakin's poorly written line of "everything here is soft and smooth" LOVE: Padme's line "I call it aggressive negotiations" HATE: The fact that there aren't more wittier exchanges like this....they were all over the original trilogy. LOVE: Where Padme tells Anakin she actually loves him before they are wheeled out into the Arena. HATE: The fact that Anakin didn't say, "Well NOW'S a good time to tell me that." Would have been a funny moment. LOVE: Yoda, Obi Wan and Mace talking together in the Jedi Temple. HATE: Yoda's stupid little floating pod. Hey George, if you can't make Yoda walk fast enough then change the scene and have the standing still somewhere. LOVE: Qui Gon speaking to Anakin from beyond. HATE: That it was constructed of a cut line from Phantom Menace. "Anakin....DROP" (see deleted scenes) That's about all I can think of for now. Have fun.