Discussion in 'EU Community' started by Jordan1Kenobi, Aug 27, 2013.
This isn't even a question, Skywalker easily defeats Windu
I wouldn't say easily necessarily...but yeah, Luke wins. Vaapad isn't as useful against a light-sider, leaving aside the immense power difference.
Going with Luke, but it would be a fun battle to watch.
I do think IMO that Windu was the best ever lightsaber duellist, he was definitely the best at battling the Sith, but I think they would most likely be equals.
In the Force, Luke is clearly the most powerful between the two, however, when does Luke ever go all out? he has only done so once I believe and that is when he soloed an army of Vong, Windu however has no qualms about overtly using the Force, Shatterpoint is his main ally here and the Grand Master has been known to make mistakes, against Darth Caedus this nearly cost him his arm, against Windu however this would be fatal.
Windu cannot press Luke so strongly that Luke calls upon his immense Force power, he has to be patient and wait for Luke to make an opening that Windu can perfectly exploit with Shatterpoint.
Plus I wouldn't mind seeing someone else win one of these for a change and I think Windu would be a worthy Grand Champion, so....
My vote goes to Windu.
Luke wins bc Windus weakness are power converters from toshi station.
My top ten force users.
1 Kyle Katarn
2 Kyle Katarn
3 Kyle Katarn
4 Kyle Katarn
5 Kyle Katarn
6 Kyle Katarn
7 Kyle Katarn
8 Kyle Katarn
9 Kyle Katarn
10 Kyle Katarn
I made it back in time for the final battle? Yay!
I vote for Luke here.
Luke again. Its a shame the last two battles were rematches though.
Don't worry, they're not the last
Since we all know where this is gonna go, I'm gonna stand firm with my original vote for greatest Force user of all time, Luke Skywalker's prodigy, Anakin Solo.
In the next match up, we should probably add Nihilus, Sidious and Luke to that list, seriously all three are more powerful than the Sith Emperor, etc.... realistically they can beat everyone but each other cleanly.
Luke over Mace
Top 10 most powerful Force users:
1. Luke Skywalker
3. Jacen / Caedus
4. Anakin/ Vader
6. Darth Bane
7. Mace Windu
8. Satele Shan
9. Exar Kun
6-10 were really hard to decide.
Was corran horn ever in the comptition?
Creator of Vaapad vs the person who possibly rediscovered it? Luke.
Getting to the point where i'll agree. It's commonly accepted that Luke and Sidious are the pinnacle of power among mortal Force Users. It's not even interesting to really debate about them facing another opponent anymore. Best to just note them along with the Ones and move on.
Yeah, he beat Eeth Koth in round one and was defeated by Exar Kun in round two.
I'm also starting to make a list of competitors for the next 'Battle of the...' game. Let's just say we're either going to be having battles like HK-47 vs. R2-D2 or Pre Vizsla vs. Captain Panaka.
Observation: This sounds awesome.
Agreed just leave them out of the equation from here on out.
I'll vote for Luke Skywalker, I knew he'd win this competition. He's fought some really powerful enemies to claim his victory, including Yoda, Mace Windu twice, Darth Bane twice and Revan, who are all some of the most powerful Force users of all time, so Luke definitely deserves to win. He was the most powerful Jedi of all time, and I doubt there'll ever be a Jedi as powerful as him. Windu and Yoda were the most powerful Jedi of their time, so Wind would put up a great fight, especially if he has what it takes to defeat Sidious, but Luke would just over power him.
It's noted that he achieved Oneness then. If I remeber corectly in Fury before he fake his death, Jaina thought about: if realy anybody knows what Luke can do, what are his limits, and cocluded, that probably he doesn't know himself. Luke is as strong as he needed to be so I don't know that we could say there are single one moment, when Luke was in his absolute, but realy absolute (in every philosophical meaning) peak.
I sensed some bias in this list
List of most powerful Force-users - ahh - in every posibly SW forums, there is always at least one such a thread I remember that on official SW forum, before it was closed, there was a thread about most powerful Force-user, it was two times repeated due to posts number limit per thread as I recall properly. There was hardly a common conlusion, but especially since Legacy novels were out, it become more and more toward Luke as most powerful. Its hard to make such a list, even considered your own vision of SW Universe. For me is clear that Luke is first and I always want to see Leia with him on stage after some years of training between those two, and Jaina by some good development to be third... Nevermind - maybe sometime in the future I prepare my list with porper explanations
And this duel. Luke use sun djem in first inhuman fast move - Windu quickly draws his secret second lightsaber - Luke use tutaminis overloaded this weapon to the point its useless - Windu facus on shatterpoints - but guess what: Luke can use it too and counter attack - Luke use unlit lightsaber to knock down Windu...
Some exaggerated example? - or maybe not? - but yes Luke wins
Top ten force users
1. Lord Vitiate
2. Luke Skywalker
3. Darth Sidious
6. Darth Nihilus
7. Darth Bane
8. Anakin Skywalker
9. Darth Plagueis
10. Satele Shan
I vote for Windu. Although, I seem to be the only one voting for him.
Great job hosting the game Jordan1Kenobi
*cough* i even put in a reason for why he could win.
Cough... For one moment, I thought I heard Vader around the corner...
Sometimes, it is difficult to keep up with what is being posted. Still, I am glad you agree.