Discussion in 'London UK' started by Yoshee, Sep 3, 2003.
Lord of the Rings for me, hands down, with The Matrix coming in a close second!
Ooh... that's SO hard! It's really a tie between the OT and LotR... but I voted for the OT, just 'cause Yosh voted for LotR...
or Debbie does Dallas????
OT all the way!
why no crocodle dundee films?
OT of course... nothin even comes close to OT...
Tough choice between LOTR and the PT (yes I do like it). I mean, Legolas or Anakin?
But in the end the fact that I have LOTR music going round in my head swayed my judgment.
For me, personally it's Star Wars PT. I know that's an odd choice and I do LOVE the OT but PT was where I came in... AotC was the first SW movie I saw in the cinema and the PT just kicked off this whole SW obsession (yes I said obsession Yosh )
I adore LotR too though, so that comes a VERY close third after the OT
Jebus, but LotR is the superior trilogy! For starters, at least the cast can act!
And to all those OT fans, i do love those films, just not as much.
Be off with you you fake Star Wars fan
Hello Mr Lucas
Sorry G man, but common....this PT of yours.....cardboard cut outs could give a better performance!
*looks at his first post in this thread and awaits reply*
I forgot to add them....sorry lol
EDIT// What you OI'ing at Nic?
The cast of the PT can act! I mean, there are some really cringe-making bits, but there are bits like that in the OT too, and I like it just the same.
Anyway, I don't want to start that now.
The OT and then Back to the Future
Roads? Where we're going, we don't need any roads
(probably badly misquoted)
Nope, ya got it right mcr!
Fantastic trilogy, which, being the nerd i am, watched all 3 back to back (in 1 evening) the other week lol
EDIT// but I voted for the OT, just 'cause Yosh voted for LotR...
You can copy my voting if ya want Enji, i won't hold it against you!
Oh, I didnt see Indiana Jones in the list. That will go in my top 3.
It's too early to tell for some of them though as they only have 2 films:
PT: First one ****, second one pretty good
LOTR: First one excellent, second one not so excellent
Harry Potter: First one not very good, second one quite good
Matrix: First one great, second one...well I'm still not sure about that
Aye, although i did like the Matrix Reloaded, it's an odd situation where you cant really say wether it's really any good until we get to see Revolutions.
In all honesty I find it impossible to choose between the prequel and the original trilogies. Particularly since the haven?t finished making the prequels yet.
I went on a bit of a rant on the Washington DC board about how I love all of the Star Wars films equally, as a parent would do their children. I?m sure I left them all thinking that I am a bit of a mentalist.
Anyway, I voted for the prequels since only one other person had done. I?d also like to second Livi-Wan?s point, I think that most criticisms of the prequels can also be made of the original films.
Oh yeah, and why?s Blood Sport not in the poll? Surely everyone needs a bit of van-damage in their life.
Don't get me wrong, i love the SW movies, particularly the OT.
And you are right in that i guess it's a bit early to really critisize the PT until EP3 has been released, and we can get to see the whole story. But i just find, that i am only liking the PT for the SFX, which just seems wrong to me, as normally, the effects should be secondry. That sounds wierd..but i'm sure you know what i mean
As for Blood Sport....you've given me an idea for another poll! As i just thought of some other series i haven't included.
LOTR, OT and Matrix are about equal for me right now. about a Year ago there would be no contest for the OT, but i've drifted from it somewhat recently. so i voted for the Matrix because nobody else had yet
Hmm, I haven't even seen Matrix: Reloaded, most people I know says it's rather bad, so I haven't bothered seeing it. But I really liked the first one...