Custom Icons Submission Thread Version 2.0

There is nothing wrong in sticking up for your friends. However, it is advisible you do so in a respectiful manner. If you attack a mod with anger, chances are you'll earn yourself a spanking, which really doesn't help your friend at all. Also, if they feel that, they should come in here and give their opinions or PM them to Kadue. He's been very willing to listen.

~*~Bria

Guess I have to say goodbye to my icon. But don't see this as a plea, I'm just a sock and my owner hasn't stood up for my icon, I can also understand the objections against it.

It was fun to have a really aggressive icon, with my team's colours in the background.

If you have to get rid of a Vader get rid of this one

[image=http://www1.theforce.net/icons/publicicons/darthvader.gif]

I can't believe that Qui-Gon and TPM Anakin are going to have 2 icons each, yet there are 5 Jar Jar icons. Kyle Katarn has 2 and he's from a video game!

Save the 2 Qui's on the list and axe the one with him holding his lightsaber and the close up. Both are kinda grainy. The photo one on the list to be removed is much clearer and the JA cover one is just more interesting.

My Cuts Suggestions
Chewie Choking Lando - lack of use
Count Dooku with lightsaber - quality (can't really see him due to glare)
The Shield Generator - quality, lack of use
Tatooine w/ Jawa - lack of use
Bespin - lack of use
Michonne Bourriague - Blink and you miss her in the movie, yet she has an out of character icon?
Imperial Shuttle - lack of use
Vornskr - lack of use
Padme AotC (In the outfit she greets Ani and Obi in in the FL trailor) - quality, lack of use
Look Sir, Donuts! - too many stormtroopers and it just isn't that funny
AT-ST - lack of use
2-1B - lack of use
R4-P17 - lack of use
Tey How - lack of use
One of the Naboo N1 Starfighters - lack of use
One of the TIE fighters - too many
Lobot with eyes closed - lack of use, there is another (better) icon
One or 2 of the Battle Droids - lack of use and there are 3
One or 2 Jar Jar's - THERE ARE 5!
A Lando one - There are 4
Some of the Artoo's - I love him, but he's got too many and he never looks any different
Bongo - beautiful icon, rarely used
Hoth Speeder - lack of use
Teebo - Too hard to figure out who it is
A Jabba - There are 3
Joh Yowza - lack of use
A couple of OT Ben's - There are 8
Edcel Bargane - lack of use

Get rid of a lot of those EU ones that half the people don't know what they are, like that one Ringwraith or whatever it is, demon thingy...

As for the Salacious Crumb one, I've not seen anyone use the green one, but I've seen many use the yellow one, so please get rid of the Green Salacious Crumb icon.

I can make some nice icons. Unfortunately I don't have a website, so uh, I was sorta looking for some help. Maybe I could e-mail one of em to you guys and see what you think! Except can you tell me who would be the right person to send em to? Thanks a million.

Kardue,

First off have you even looked through these icons?or have you just picked them at random. Although I may not have an icon up on the board, I speak for everyone who has an icon up on that list. Yes, I can see getting rid of the grainy ones but some people have a mission to use one icon ever since they have been on?and now you plan to take that fun away from them. All I have to say is that you are a MEGALOMANIACAL little ****. How dare you do this to us.


1. It is KADUE. Get it right.

2. Notice how others gave thought out answers? Learn that that is the way to go.

Can someone please answer my question? Thanks again!

I'm a bit confused on your remarks about the Pyre icon. What do you mean that it's hard to make out? Anyway, it's a powerful scene that many users use.

Besides, it leaves me with only one icon at TFN, and.. the other one is the one I have now, and NO ONE besides me uses it.

I think what Kadue meant was that if you didn't know which scene it was, a person might not be able to tell exactly what it is they are looking at. I don't totally agree with that as it's what I consider to be one of the most powerful scenes in the O.T., but I think that was his point. On that and on Vader getting electrocuted...

If that is the reason, then Floating Yoda should still go because it very hard to tell what is happening.

Errr.. but I don't think that's it. If I hadn't seen ROTJ, I would have no idea what I'm looking at when I see your icon. And there's quite a few icons in the EU which I have no idea what's going on.

My point is, I think everyone knows what the scene is.

I still would rather see the

"Han/Leia almost kiss"

and

"the kiss from Endor"

icons *stay* and lose the one where they are facing away from each other. I think it's very obvious that Han and Leia are from two separate pictures in that icon and I'm not thrilled with their expressions either. I'm willing to bet that I'm not alone when it comes to this opinion.

I totally agree with boushh2187. The red was nice at first, being the first Han/Leia icon, but it's has the least quality of the three.

Emperor_Dan: I agree with you, but I really think that Kadue was saying that if you didn't know what it was, you might not be able to recognize it. Then again, it is one of the most powerful (IMHO at least) images in the OT...

Oh, and on Vader... I think the blue Vader on Kadue's list (not the one in the shadows) is the one to go. I can't say the last time I saw someone use it where as I've seen people this very night using the original Vader icon (darthvader.gif).

~*~Bria

Nevermind.

I added two new icons (Leia and Padmé) to my new Geocities site: http://www.geocities.com/the_lady_ex. Whoever's responsible for updating the Icon Makers List please update mine to the new adress. Thanks!

Okay, gone through the icons, taken suggestions, gone through 'em again, taken more suggestions......

Unless I'm going to absolutely crush someone's whole world with one of my choices, this is the list of those being cut.

Now, as I've said above, some will be replaced by other icons of the same theme, so don't worry too much if there are too many of one icon type going, just tell me of it.

Also, the Celebration ones will go after CII has finished.

Bria - On the Yoda's you missed the "Concentrate" one.

I have one humble request. Please save the "Ani Racer" icon. Instead, you could delete this one...

[image=http://www1.theforce.net/icons/publicicons/anilaugh.gif]
which has an almost identical, but better, alternate. That would help preserve a little variety.

I'm still a bit sad some of them are going(loved the RL Porman one with the single strand over her face ), but thats a lot better

Yes, that horrible Senator Padme one should be deleted and never seen again. Lack of quality. What about those handmaiden ones? We are going to introduce new ones, right?

R2RNOT: I agree about variety. But that older Anakin icon is utterly adorable.

I have two simple requests:

Top Row: End - One of the best Padme ones, especially considering she actually smiles.

6th Row: End - One of the most popular Han icons. Why not delete 'stormin' or whatever it is?

Am

Just a quick note I forgot to add, I'll be doing the deleting this time tomorrow.

It's adorable but it's almost exactly like this one...
[image=http://www1.theforce.net/icons/publicicons/FLSmileAni.gif]
Which, I have to admit, is better and more popular.