You make more sense there, Krash. But I too think that the Sidious/Palp thing is just not qualified as a "major plot point". Well, at least not an unknown one. I thought your opinion was that they can't be the same because of that EU map, and that's why I said your logic was flawed. I don't mean that your *opinion* that these planets won't turn out to be one and the same is flawed. Some more to chew on; Ever thought "what's that" about the concrete doorway visible in the cave on Dagobah? Ever thought "what's a concrete structure doing underground there"? TPM tells you why; In the swamp scene you can see the statues and buildings are slowly sinking into the swamp or being "eaten" by the vegetation. Hey, there's too much here!