A huge disappointment. Luke's characterisation was nowhere near accurate (how did he suddenly become so egotistical?), Kyp was boring and one-dimensional, and the twins could not possibly have annoyed me more (what was the point of that whole sub-plot, anyway?). I thought the ideas behind this book (this whole trilogy in fact) were really good. Luke needs to continue the Jedi so starts a Jedi Academy, deals with the different kind of students that pop up etc, including one that has eery throwbacks to himself, and his father. Meanwhile another leftover Imp Admiral pops up and starts screwing with things. So how is it possible to take every one of these possibilities in precisely the wrong direction? Ugh, this book frustrates me. I give it a 1, only because there's no 0.