Discussion in 'Literature' started by TypoCelchu, Oct 30, 2012.
If we take TPM and ANH as the model, Luke is the only one with any huge reason to kill.
actually I'd love it on three conditions:
1) true Obi style: meaning he disappears before lightsaber even ever hits him, willing complete joining with the Force! not at natural death or after death by lightsaber
2) It is to make a point to the next generation as it was with Obi Wan. multiple points even
3) he does not wear black and never ever have a beard
If Han's child is a major character, killing Han could always be a viable option, for the emotional effect on the character(s) and the audience. It'd almost be assured if Whedon was directing
Star Wars: Episode VII: Attack of the Beards!
he can trim his chest hair up so it looks like a beard if you like... but Hamill and beard are two things that just do not look good together...well Obi beard that is..
I make an exception for only 1 beard style:
keep it long and wizard and I accept it. all short beard styles suck on him. And I say that while sporting myself a good shorter beard.. so nothing against those in general
edit: PS: and have him wear something under that robe... unlike Joruus there
And he still has those incredible eyes
beard on him looks very bad.. especially this style here
I really don't want to see Luke die, personally. What is it that makes audiences constantly demand the blood of their heroes?
Ask Obi-Wan 36 years ago.
Indeed. S'one of the reasons I hate it when people are all "Obi-Wan and Vader's ANH duel is terrible!"
No, it's the duel where they both finally look like they know what they're doing.
Again, agreed. I really don't want Nick Gillard anywhere near the thing, if I'm honest. Ideally they'd resurrect Bob Anderson, but such things are beyond us at present.
@CeiranHarmony, if you don't want THIS:
... then you need to ignored forever more.
Though I agree I'd rather not have him black. Honestly, I'd like his Jedi robes to be more reminiscent of his Tatooine farm gear in colour. Actually, something kind of like this:
Spoiler (Move your mouse to the spoiler area to reveal the content)
Would seem appropriate for Luke.
seen that bearded Luke picture elsewhere already.. and that is the prime reason why I do despise the idea actually... it looks horrible! no offense, my friend. he looks like an aged Ewan McGregor clone and nothing like Luke himself. it looks forced, he never had a beard before, never was his style. without a nametag I'd never have recognised him as Hamill or Luke in there even!
we had some nice aged Luke pictures in the EU that would fit his facial look and hairstyle I think.
and yub agree with you on the matter of clothes I do
Here, most likely. Since I posted it before.
Yeah? Most men have never had a beard before they first have a beard. The only reason it isn't Luke's style is because the EU decided to keep him chean shaven and lame.
Man, every single aged Luke picture in the EU is crying out for a beard. EVERY SINGLE ONE OF THEM.
I would very disappoint if episode VII Luke doesn't have a beard......it is the ultimate sign of wisdom and respect.
a beard okay... but not Obi's beard... come on, there are more styles than "Jedi standard"... one could even make a Monty Python parody out of Jedi getting handed robes, sabers and fakebeards upon becoming a Master
actually I want Hamill to sport Kol Skywalker hairstyle with true Wolverine sideburns we need a bit of retro hairstyles and looks to OT Sequels anyway.
poor Yoda... not wise he was, eh?
or Palpatine... or Plagueis THE WISE?
all had no beard same goes for prime example of a balanced Jedi QUI GON JINN
then there is Mace Windu
well.. beards are exceptions, not the rule heck you can find more jedi with a mustache than a beard in the visual dictionaries
Please, if Yoda had a beard he would saw the Sith plot years ago.
Of course there only needs to be at least one big lightsaber duel per movie, but I'd personally love to see lots of lightsaber conflict throughout each of the movies.
And it's not just the lightsabers, like I said, I want to see awesome contests of the Force.
Jabba's sail barge, in fact the entire opening sequence for all the OT movies, are dreadfully boring. The sail barge had absolutely no tension once Luke had his lightsaber (except for the Han/Lando/Sarlacc part). Oh, and not once in the entire OT do we see a lightsaber slash through a stormtrooper. I can hardly recall any scene with the stormtroopers and the battle droids having tension (just the Droidekas in TPM, and Order 66).
Obi-wan and Vader did, though. And that was only the first time we'd seen them in use.
And yeah, I never liked Thrawn as a villain, Tarkin was ruthless but not dangerous, and (before ROTS) I always wished that we had seen Palpatine fight in ROTJ. Still kind of wish we had seen that.
Well, except for TPM, they were all PART of an epic war... as you said. And even in TPM, you knew the seeds were being sown for something much larger. You need to feel like the entire galaxy is at stake.
Yes, before the ST was announced, I was getting tired of the books always puttng the galaxy at stake... but this is the Sequel Trilogy we're talking about. In order to justify it, everything the heroes have worked for and won in the previous 6 movies needs to be at stake.
On the beard discussion: myself, I don't like beards. I don't have one. But still, it just feels... right for Luke to have one. Plus, I think older Hamill does look a lot better with a beard.
But of course, there's no way either side can win that argument. I've never believed that a beard can make you look wiser or smarter, but dammit, it does on Hamill . Plus Hamill's face has become a bit more wrinkly in recent years. Solution: beard.
I know! Luke's son can have a beard. He'd be all like "All the cool Jedi have them" to which Luke would be like
Fangirl moment. Beards are hot.
Hypnosis and nanomachines midi-chlorians.
To be honest i think beards just don't look good on him because he's simply not a good looking guy.