anakin_girl ...you're welcome to present some options to me and ask if I think it's going too far. Which of the following would not be allowed? 1) The idea you presented is wrong. 2) The idea you presented sucks. 3) Your idea conflicts with the general philosophy of the movies. 4) Your idea is pathetic. 5) Your idea is horrible. 6) "Again, so unbelievably wrong. How on Earth can you guys talk about that which you have no clue about." - very recent 3SA quote from you-know-who. 7) That's an asinine theory. I would say that if you even think you're going to offend someone, don't say it. There are some that are so extremely sensitive that the only way for me to do this would be to never post here again. It's too restrictive. The only reason anyone would have for posting "That's the dumbest theory I've seen yet" is to hurt someone's feelings. No, the other reason is because it's the dumbest theory I've seen yet and I'm expressing my opinion. There are entire threads in 3SA devoted to the worst (and best) ideas heard so far. -------- Syntax Oh, right. So... on page 21 of this thread, when you were asking anakins_girl if she found a specific phrase offensive, you weren't doing it KNOWING it would offend her...? That's rich. You are openly accusing me of lying. Should I not be offended? Doesn't this violate the very rules you are pushing? By the way, I am not offended. I've never been offended by anything said to me here because none of you know me. I was not trying to offend her. I wanted her honest opinion on MeBeJedi's statement. Previously, I had asked her about one of his statements and she refused to comment. So this time I tried it without identifying the poster. If you think something is a bad idea, you could always just ignore it, or keep it to yourself, no? Astonishing. Now we have someone trying to suppress all criticism whatsoever. How far will this go? 1984, here we come. Calling the idea "horrible" does not fall under this category. I am amazed that if someone says Elton John should sing the closing theme song of AOTC, that I can't say it's horrible.