If condensing hate is the rule of the land now, think it could apply to the movie forums as well? We could just lock up all the movie and GL haters in exactly one place per forum? If the general idea is that hating is redundant if it's in more than one thread, maybe we can overhaul the whole JC! At any rate, I agree with epic. This isn't an issue of redundancy, otherwise there should only be a handful of threads in EUC that each deal with all the characters in the books. The question is whether the whole hating vibe, so to speak, is allowed. That's a more interesting question to me, and personally, would be far more interesting if its application were not limited to EUC.