Discussion in 'Star Wars And Film Music' started by General Kenobi, Apr 7, 2007.
Battle of Endor II
The Battle Endor II
The Battle Of Endor II 7
The Clash Of Lightsabers 4
<img width="400" src="http://www.fvaathletics.org/mo/finalduel8.jpg">
Thanks to all who participated!
While it might not be everyone's choice as the best (especially the long SE track edit) it's a great track with "The Dark Side Beckons" and "The Emperor's Death", loved by most everyone who posts here.
Now we must vote on the worst star wars track!!!
That's "Lapti Nek."
Oh, well. I listened to "The Battle of Endor II" yesterday, and was absolutely blown away by its finale... still... it's a sequel score, and it doesn't possess the vitality and originality of the original.
No way is it Lapti Nek. That's an awesome track. Retract your insanity!!!
Well done to Battle of Endor II! It was a hard tournament, and I honestly thought that The Throne Room would have won it. My personal choice, "Rescue from Cloud City/Hyperpace" Got knocked out fairly late in the game. Although I knew it would get far, would have never picked BOEII to actually win it though. But it has and it THOROUGHLY deserved it. I am listening to it as I type this, in fact.
Worst track? I might have to go with Jabba's Barouque Recital on that one...
I would never have thought that the finale would be between Clash of Lightsabers and BoE2. Strange combination. But then, there were a lot of those.
Worst? Yub Nub, followed by Den of the Rancor. I am SO sick of that, yet iTunes keeps jumping to it.
I can't believe no one has said "Jedi Rocks" is the worst yet.
We had two strong finalists. I would have picked "The Hologram/Binary Sunset", "Throne Room/End Title", "The Battle Of Hoth" or "The Battle Of Yavin" for the final matchups.
Yeah, Jedi Rocks isn't exactly a favorite of mine either. There's some other music inside Jabbas palace, that isn't source music, that completely bores me.
That was a great and fascinating tournament! I'm surprised no one thought "Duel of the Fates" would make it towards the end; I certainly thought it had a shot.
As somebody already said, this tournament was definitely hard at stages. BoE2 is an interesting winner. I would never have been able to name it as so, which is great, in a sense.
Thank you ever so much for doing a fine job hosting this tourney, General!
I thought so, I just didn't say it.
DotF, AniFree, AtS, RotS, A'sBetr., ImpAtt., TIEAtt., Yavin, Ice Planet, Hoth, Carbon Freeze, Hyperspace, BoE1 and VicCeleb. were my top candidates. Yes, no Binary Sunset. It could win Best Cue, but not Best Track. The AotC track with it should have (had?) a better chance than BS alone. Yes, no ImpMarch because it's all over the place anyway. Darth Vader's Death is a better ImpMarch than ImpMarch is. Or Approaching Endor.
I'd totally post my personal tournament results if it was less work