Favortite PT Movie

Attack of the Clones is my favorite PT film. I dug the love story, which was opulent and chaotically flawed all at once, and thought Lucas did a particularly deft job of portraying Anakin as a deeply flawed hero easily fueled by anger, aggression, and lustful urges. Also, Williams? main love theme was hauntingly beautiful and tragic, a perfect musical expression of emotions so integral to Anakin?s fall.

Ultimately, I found both Episodes I and III a bit disappointing, with the former seeming like a loosely related prologue and the latter a forced, rushed jumble of some very good and very bad ideas.

 

I enjoy each STAR WARS episode and each STAR WARS trilogy and the STAR WARS SAGA fully and equally.

STAR WARS is the best.

 

Got to be ROTS for me.

I really like TPM and AOTC but feel ROTS is superior.

 

Revenge of the Sith ;D i don't exactly know WHY, i just like it the most ;D

 

Easily ROTS. I loved the opening space battle, the humor, Anakin's turn, Order 66, the duels...incredible film and a fitting end to the trilogy.

 

ROTS
TPM
AOTC

 

All good stuff

 

I really love the other two as well, but I have to say it's Revenge of the Sith.

 

It's Episode III because it had so much emotion and great scene's.

 

Revenge of the Sith pwns in every aspect!

 

"Revenge of the Sith pwns in every aspect!"

Nice answer!

Good Stuff

 

every movie is pretty much tied to me... but if i had to say my favorite no matter my opinion... ROTS... great duels, great lines, great actors, great costumes...
though, yes, it wouldn't have been nearly as nice if TPM and AOTC weren't involved

 

I agree.

Good Stuff

 

All the movies are great but my personal favorite is definitely ROTS (which may even be my favorite all time movie)

 

Let first state my position by saying that I don't like to pick favorites. I view the PT as one big film, broken down into 3 acts, each broken down into 3 smaller acts. They each rely on the others to work.

Probably more so than any movie series, the PT is a COMPLETE trilogy.

Anyway, the point I wanted to make was that it is REALLY REALLY interesting to see how many people are now coming out and saying that TPM is their fav PT film. I remember when AOTC came out, most people said it was waaaaaaaaay better than TPM. Now, the reverse seems to be true. Funny isn't it, how ROTS has suddenly placed TPM into perspective. Just as GL prophecised.

I admit, I watched TPM again soon after ROTS came out and viewed it in a totally different light. Mind you, I always loved TPM and defended it ad nauseum, knowing that when the trilogy was complete it would be regarded as being as important as the other SW films.

Having said that, I think AOTC is narratively the most important film in not only the PT but possibly the whole saga.

Bottom line: the whole is greater than the individual parts.

 

Bah, never mind. I already said that.

 

I say ROTS. The only downer is the depressing ending.

 

ROTS is the best.

 

"Revenge" gets my vote. The best action, and story as well
as the best acting since probably TESB. Although the charactors
and story seem to be rushed at times, it is still more sorted out than the other two prequels. The score was magnificent also.

There is no way "The Phantom Menace" out does this movie.

AOTC was okay, but I really can't stand the "Obi-Wan investagates
while Anakin tells Padme she's softer than sand" editing.

 

Revenge of the Sith.... no doubt about it.


The action is amazing. The lightsaber duels are incredible and the story is really good. Even the acting is quiet good I think.

My favourite scene in ROTS (and among my 3 favourite Star Wars scenes) is the scene were Mace and his posse have gone to arrest Palpatine. Anakin is back in the Council Chamber and there is this great connection between him and Padme. You feel their connection, Padmes sorrow. Anakins pain and the weight of the universe upon his shoulders without a single word being said. Palpatines words "you do know if they kill me any hope..." and John Williams' music makes this scene perfect.





Applause for George

 

Revenge of the sith of course
The special effects were great and everything in it was so awesome!!!!