Discussion in 'Community' started by VadersLaMent, Apr 17, 2011.
the winterfell plot sucked
so does this neverending convo
The concept of agreeing to disagree is apparently not something everyone here is familiar with.
I'm happy stopping here. I trust the point is made.
I think it's fair to say the Vale Lords, esp Royce didn't care much for Littlefinger. So they were prepared to accept a fairly low standard of evidence. Even testimony from a boy seeing visions via a magic tree.
If someone says "these people are dead bcs they got in my way" I'd call that pretty close to an admission.
How would Sansa know that? It's just as likely that she had her husband & father killed. She had after all just tried to kill Sansa! Why would Sansa doubt her given that fact? Now you're the one using book/show knowledge & expecting a character to know what you know.
Wrong, he wasn't even looking for it bcs he wasn't aware of it. What seems clear is that Bran can look back at something if he knows what to look for. There's absolutely no reason to assume he's incapable of answering the question "did Lysa & Baelish kill Jon Arryn". You're just making up these restrictive rules for Bran's abilities to suit your argument. Your assumptions are irrelevant.
What's obvious is that the Starks got together, shared information & pieced several things together. In order to build a case against Baelish. They had 3 important clues:
1. That the dagger used to try to kill Bran belonged to Baelish.
2. The letter Lysa wrote to Cat where she blamed the Lannisters for Jon Arryn's death.
3. That Lysa had insinuated that she & Baelish killed Arryn for getting in the way of their relationship. Added to that the common sense deduction that since Lysa was crazy about Baelish, & they were openly having loud sex in the castle, then surely they'd been having an affair for a long time. In that circumstance the prime suspect for a dead husband is always the wife & her lover.
The picture all of this painted is that Baelish was using Lysa to manipulate events & play the great houses against each other. Also that they very likely killed Arryn, a crime that they tried to frame the Lannisters for. If this was true it would be of great use to get the Vale Lords on board to support LF's execution. The whole arc for Sansa this season is that by the end she'd become sharper & more intuitive to this sort of thing. Like she said, she'd learned her lessons well. So between them all & using Bran's abilities they put it together. I'm not sure what you're even arguing about. The Baelish trial scene confirmed all of this. They laid out all of the truth, & they had the knowledge & the means via Bran to find that truth.
Hopefully this discussion will end before season 8 begins in 2019
Good. Yes it is.
I can't help but think of Monty Python and the holy grail now tho :
Speaking of which, I immediately thought of this when Wocky unveiled his Bitey the Sharp-Toothed Dragon idea.
All your anti-undead dragon arguments are invalid.
Yes, because a secondary actress with a weird mouth is clearly the definitive expert on the ASOIAF/ GOT universe.
I think Montie was more seeking the deference of the android.
If I'm not discussing your silly show please do not remark on her jaw structure. Those are the terms of our truce.
Can Bran watch past events faster than real time?
Can he watch multiple past events simultaneously?
Was there ever a three eyed raven who just used his powers to watch people doing it, (like wot you'd do)?
Apparently Bran has events indexed by type/description, individuals involved, or even just inidividuals who are affected politically. Can be searched/accessed via Boolean parameters.
Because anything less is us making too many assumptions.
Does he get recommendations, like on Netflix?
So epic, how about that wager?
Bran needs to flashback and get some critical plot information from a final season-running subplot involving the past actions of Margery Tyrell just so we can have Natalie Dormer back on the show.
Apologies if posted earlier, I can't bring myself to skim the last few week's pages.
As a teenage male, I would assume Bran would be using his Crow-O-Vision to watch porn non-stop, better known as "Margaery does Westeros. "
That is also a personal favourite of mine.
Leave poor Margaery alone!
At the end of season 6, Margaery's gaping hole was transformed into an even larger gaping hole!
You allow this, Jabba-wocky ?
You are not the man I thought you were.
I liked Ros , is she still alive ?
I'm trying my best. I will defend your honor.
Why would you lie like that?
Multiple endings to be filmed to foil spoilers
It does say that HBO "could not confirm".