Yeah, all that Chosen One business was and still is a bit confusing. Even though Vader killed the Emperor, personally, I still feel that Luke was the Chosen One. At least that's what I'm going to tell my niece when she's old enough to watch the SW Saga, as I'll be playing the movies to her in the order in which I saw them--IV-III, VII-IX. Who cares what GL officially decrees. =) Having said that, the SW Saga obviously still works for the Gen Y/PT crowd. I wonder if instead of experiencing two of the biggest cinematic reveals of all time (the 'Luke, I am your father' and 'YOU'RE Yoda' scenes, respectively) this gen experienced a slow, delicious build-up to those very same moments? As someone who grew up on the OT I can only wonder, but as a student of the SW films I find this question fascinating.