That's irrelevant to me. Regardless of whether Anakin is the Saga's redeemed Chosen One or ROTJ's redeemed villain, he's still redeemed. And that was a mistake on Lucas's part. We should never have been given a glimpse of Anakin in ghost form. All it says is that a mass-murderer, torturer, sadist (and yes, child killer, which I had already suspected based on his despicable nature in ANH and TESB) ascended to Jedi Heaven just for saving his own kid's life. The redemption sucked in '83, and it still sucks now.