Discussion in 'Revenge of the Sith (Non-Spoilers)' started by joehahn000, May 19, 2005.
Aww, this is tough. I'm going to wait until after I rewatch every episode (including 3 this weekend) to gather a whole scope of things.
Plus I simply couldn't ever name a definite list. No 1st-6th place. More like A is better than B, which is better than C. However C is better than A. Doesn't make sense but that's how I feel.
It's one big 12 hour movie now.
It was very hard to rate them this way because they are all great (IM), more some then others (AOTC! )
After seeing RotS, i have no idea anymore.
Well, right now ROTS is obviously very close to my heart, but I do believe it will hold the top position for me even after the first novelty have worn off.
Some people think my list is weird, but there ya go!
I think ROTS will not stay on top after repeated viewings, but for now the heartbreaking tragedy can't be topped. Also, interesting that it shook up my opinions of all the other ones.
Sadly, ANH doesn't hold up anymore. The pacing is just too slow compared to ROTS, and The Duel Rematch looks horrid by comparison.
(these WILL change again very soon, I will bet)
At the moment it goes.
I can't rank them definitively yet. Where ROTS falls in my rankings can't be determined until I see it a couple more times.
[blockquote]I can't rank them definitively yet. Where ROTS falls in my rankings can't be determined until I see it a couple more times. [/blockquote]
Same for me, I have seen the others so much, that I couldn't accurately put ROTS in any ranking yet since I have only seen it once so far.
Whilst I always hoped that Sith would go beyond Empire, I never truly believed it would... that is, until two hours ago!
I think that Empire is still my favorite. Where Sith falls, I do not yet know. I need to see it a few more times to fully digest it.
revenge of the wind!
Never mind what I said earlier. Changed my mind about ANH after finishing it.
My new rating is:
1) Star Wars Saga
I'm not going to rate the movies anymore.
I have to agree with 1)Star Wars Saga
but if I must
Upon my first viewing...
I love them all, though.
My new rating is:
1) Star Wars Saga
Lol! I totally agree. I have a list of my all time fav movies and it has always said Star Wars OT on the first place. However, I changed that earlier today to Star Wars Saga.
I have a hard time ranking these, and having only seen it once, I don't really have a full perspective on the movie.
But I also agree with stormcloud that the Saga as a whole is in a class of its own.
[hl=darkslategray]Strilo[/hl] edit: Those comments came too close to spoilers.
ROTS is my favourite out of them all.
For me it is,
This may change, however it is how I feel currently. That is in order of what films I consider to be best.
In terms of enjoyment, I like TPM more than ROTS.
Revenge is an emotionally charged and dark film (as expected.) It isn't the type of movie that I would just casually watch. Emotions are invested, and feelings torn apart. This is all as it should be. In many ways it is a nightmare, and I just don't enjoy it as much as any of the other films. I have very mixed feelings about the film and will have to see it more times to get an accurate picture of it.
I used to have a pretty definite list of favorite Star Wars movies. But now that I've seen Revenge of the Sith twice, it's so much harder to put that list together. Right now, I think it goes like this:
But to be honest, I love them all. And putting that list down was really hard. I wasn't sure if I liked ROTJ or AOTC better. Same with ANH and TPM. It really just depends on my mood. Gee, why did Revenge of the Sith have to go and mess up my list!
I can no longer do my list, because I don't have one I am willing to put in the bottom spot anymore.
They're all new and fresh. One saga to rule them all.
After seeing ROTS twice, (I think it improved on the second viewing!) right now I'm ranking them like this:
I can definitely envision ROTS improving with repeated viewings and time. I still need to completely process how ROTS affects the rest of the saga, I don't fully comprehend it yet.
ROTS and ROTJ- what can I say I love the fall and redemption
I almost put AotC above RotS because I was dissappointed in how some things were handled, most notably battles and Jedi deaths, but in the end I like the story and darkness enough to edge it over.
Just realized I like them backwards.