Discussion in 'Revenge of the Sith (Non-Spoilers)' started by cherryfunk, Feb 20, 2002.
AOTC will be nominated for, and win Best Animated Feature
Lol @ 5D2M1
Personally, I think it's high time Frank Oz was nominated for Yoda. That's some good acting! Not that I think he will be, of course, it's just something I'd like to see...
"Duckman - don't say your opinions are facts. There's no better way to lose credibility."
Me lose credibility? That's unpossible!
"My opinion: TPM's score was subpar. John Williams dropped the ball, and there's no way it even deserved an Oscar nomination."
Fine, but can you name FIVE better films scores from 1999? I doubt it.
"My opinion: The Matrix had mind-boggling, never before heard sound effects. TPM's sound was good, but The Matrix's sound was better."
The Matrix was overrated in every department.
"I agree with SFX. TPM was a landmark visually - way more impressive than The Matrix or anything else that came out that year."
Well, at least we agree on something
"FACT: People have different opinions, and your opinions are not always FACTS."
It is a fact that my opinions are more objective than most peoples.
Well I can't argue with that logic!
You're right, I can't think of 5 better scores, because 1999 is just too far out of my memory. The only movie I paid any attention to that year was TPM (and The Matrix). Maybe on the strength of Duel of the Fates alone I could possibly see it getting a nomination, but I still feel strongly that it wasn't Oscar-worthy.
I can't wait to hear AOTC's score. From what I've read about it, it seems to be much stronger than TPM's score, so hopefully it will rewarded justly.