Discussion in 'Archive: Census and Games' started by The Gatherer, Jun 19, 2001.
4 (2 points for being a SW movie)
I give it a 6. Okay in spots, but overall uneven, IMO.
Every SW movie gets a 10. No matter what.
It?s the second best SW movie, IMO.
Definitely a 10. My favorite of the series so far, and probably forever. Luke is my hero, so I love the ending. It's just incredible to me.
10, its my favourite
a 10 rotj is my favorite star wars movie
9. My favorite after AOTC.
Every SW film gets 10 from me.
9 one of the best
In 1983, ROTJ instantly became my favorite movie of all time. Since then, I'd put ESB & ANH ahead of it as whole films. The beginning of ROTJ doesn't stand up as well. But man, all the DSII scenes are the best.
For sure a '10' it's the best SW movie ever made.
The only reason I had to replace my first set of Original Trilogy VHS tapes was because the sound and picture quality of ROTJ were becoming warped due to over-use. The main theme at the beginning sounded horrible simply because I had watched that video over 30 times.
Last Christmas I got the widescreen version of the OT. Time to start wearing THOSE down!
This is without a doubt the worst of the 5 films imo. Thankfully. Luke/vader scenes saved this from being a total let down.
I think it is much better than TPM - probably on the same lines as AOTC (since AOTC had terrible dialogue --see Anakin). I still really like the movie though but it pales in comparison to ESB (best) and ANH (2nd best).
RotJ is my fav Star Wars film
I heart you!
I would rate in nine because it is close to perfect, however i have never seen the perfect movie.
Return of The Jedi was great EXCEPT for the Ewoks, that was some marketing stunt right there for GL, he shoulda went with his original idea...the wookies. As a Star Wars movie I give it an 8, as a whole a 10 because it's Star Wars.
9 I give it.
I gave it a 10.
10. After seeing the PT, the ending to ROTJ is just so amazing.