Discussion in 'Archive: Census and Games' started by The Gatherer, Jun 19, 2001.
I'd give it 9 now
8 -- ROTJ, a flawed film, but bloody fantastic!
I think my stock in it went higher with the DVD - I can skip directly to my favourite scenes now! JOY!!! JOY!!! JOY!!!
9, a beautiful and fun movie with a slight pacing problem.
Has the best ending and tear-provoking i've ever seen though (dvd-version)
9 - don't judge them too high before ROTS is out. Other than that, it's my favourite.
It was FANTASTIC! Of course 10!
ROTJ is excellent. 10
8. It's my least favourite movie in the saga, but it still deserves an 8 in my book.
10! ROTJ is a great movie- I give it points just for having ewoks kick stromtrooper butt.
8- great film, the confrotnation with Luke and Vader was great. I loved it
8 or 80%
100% for being a Star Wars film.
-20% for some ewok silliness.
10, of course. The Emperor! He rules!
Ten out of ten.
A big fat 10 - for the sheer fact that Palptine is finally seen in the OT (forget about that hologram crap). And those scenes with him are spectacular.
I rated Return of the Jedi a seven!
9 Has the misfourtune of following 'Empire',
hilighting it's flaws even more.
9 - Great but flawed.
ROTJ was always my favorite Star Wars film
Great film but the weakest of the original three. I give it an 8.5 but since there is no 8.5 rating I gave it a 9.
Weakest of the OT, but still a solid 8!
Perfect 10, it was so emotional, just classic