Discussion in 'Archive: Census and Games' started by The Gatherer, Jun 19, 2001.
I am going to have to give it an 8. I really like the story, and the space battle is amazing IMO, the only thing holding me back from giving it a higher score is the Ewoks.
All Star Wars movies are 10s. To the 3 of you that gave it a 1, what the heck is wrong with you?!! You have committed blasphemy, and should be banned forever. I scoff at thee.
9, my favorite SW movie after ROTS. It was done wonderfully and everything ran smoothly- though there were a few scenes I wasn't too thrilled with. Leia pretty much disappearing (in character) annoys me a bit.
I didn't love it, didn't hate it. Okay, I loved it more than I hated it.
it have a bad finale!
Unlock and up.
10 - Star Wars blinders all the way.
This one holds some of my most fond movie memories, however.
10. A perfect ending to a perfect saga!
I saw nothing wrong with this film; nothing at all. In my opinion it was perfect.
A perfect 10. I don't see how anything could've been done differently.
8- I'm of the crowd that discounts for Ewoks
I give it an 8.
10. Perfect the way it is.
I'd give it an 8 - does have a few niggling issues here and there for me, but is still a satisfying end to the original trilogy.
I gave RotJ 9, although I considered 8. It has lots of flaws, but 8 feels too low.
10. It's always been my favorite.