When watching ROTS at the theater the first time I thought Hayden did one of the best jobs I have ever heard delivering the line,"I HATE YOU!!" Thinking about the way it was filmed on a stage with green screen and finding that emotion must have been a challange. It helped capture the emotion of the dark place and pain he was in. Having said that, Afterwards while discussing the film with my brother I don't know how we got to it but he refered to the line,"I HAD TO!!" I just tried to nicely say that isn't what he said. He disagreed and we have joked about it a few times back and forth who was right. I was of course . So again I had to show him in captions to give him a hard time. This brings me to my point. The reason he would have thought he yelled I had to is that it would have made sense. So I thought I would ask you guys that love to find things to discuss on these boards which you prefer. I always thought that the line "I HATE YOU!!" summed up the line from the databank I always read that said Anakin was left for dead but his burning rage and hatred were the only thing that kept him alive. I personally always saw the line as him projecting what he felt about himself at that moment on to Ob-Wan and he was truly hating himself and what he became. On the other hand, "I HAD TO!!" shows his tunnel vision that caused him to do the atrocious things he did. It would show it how truly obsessed he was to do these things and how much of a slave he was to it. Heck if enough people like the line that way it could be one of the first things changed in an SE PT Anyway I'd like to here everyone elses thoughts.