But each SW film is like another kind of soup. If ANH was chicken soup, then ESB was clam chowder, ROTJ was shrimp bisque, TPM was cream of mushroom, and AOTC was beef stew. You can't expect all the soups to taste the same. You may not like all of the soups, but just because someone doesn't like cream of mushroom doesn't mean the cream of mushroom soup was made wrong. Especially if the people who normally like cream of mushroom like it. If nobody liked it, even the people who like cream of mushroom soup, then you might have a basis for the idea that the soup was in fact made "wrong".