Inserting Grievous in AotC: good idea or bad idea?

Good idea, as long as all he is is scenery.

Probably have him standing against a wall during the Seperatist meeting Obi spies on. And then have him walk across the hangar as Dooku hops on his bike.

And that would be it.

Strilo edit: We have several "what would you change?" type threads already.

 

They should add in a scene of him in the Geonosian Catacombs killing Jedi & Clones since that's where he was.

 

But why would it be necessary? Its not, theres no point to it, leave him out.

I'm fine with his character in RotS (frankly, it was much better than I'd feared when I first heard about 'droid general named grievous who fights with four lightsabers'), but he wouldn't really serve any true purpose to be in AotC.

 

Yeah, but it'd be cool to see him actually killing some Jedi.

 

If you want to see him in action, theres also the Clone Wars Cartoons - he appears at the end of chapter 20, and I think again later in 21-25, although I haven't seen the latter.

 

That's a cartoon though, it'd be ever cooler to see it in live-action.

 

Theres a lot of stuff it would be 'cool' to see, though, and if you added it all in, we could have 6 6-hour plus movies.

Although that really wouldn't be all that bad...

 

I don't know. It might be cool, it might not. I think it would be unnecessary though.

That's a cartoon though, it'd be ever cooler to see it in live-action.

You know, personally, I thought Animated Grevious was alot cooler the CG grevious. Somehow in ROTS he lost some of his intemidation. He was well done, but the Cartoon version I felt was FAR more menacing.