"You've failed, your highness. I am a Jedi, like my father before me." - Luke Skywalker *POSSIBLE SPOILERS* Can we say that Anakin was ever really a Jedi? He learned the Jedi ways, yeah, but in the ROTS novel he starts to not want to be in the Order and says he's never fit in or believed in everything a Jedi believes. If you don't believe in the basic Jedi principles, how can you be a Jedi?...he was never really a Jedi until Luke saved him...he never truly believed in the Jedi principles until that point, self-sacrificing, selfless care for another human being; even knowing and accepting that he could (and did) die. What do y'all think?