Yes, I believe that... she says "You'll always be that little boy I knew on Tatooine." Her first impression sounds like it comes from a mature woman who's not on the same level as our young dark hero. The Novel..let me see if I can find it... no well anyway I think I remember her fiddling around with the Japorsnippet and remember how kind and genuinly good Anakin was a little boy, so as far as the book goes, you are very correct. Maybe there's a deleted scene that shows Padme remember Anakin in his younger years, how much she like him etc.. This doesnt seem like a polarizing question, more a question of what one felt upon viewing the whole thing. I said what I felt. And I can't change how I feel when watching something like that. Also, I want it to improve. I want GL to look at the movie and say... well maybe this needs a tweak or two. He's bound to at some point, and if he does, my hopes lay firmly on his seeing the P-A relationship as one of them.