I'm not particularly interested in a "what if" scenario. This entire discussion got started under the premise of someone saying that Mace sucked because he "made" Ahsoka leave the Order, and my point was that I didn't see anything wrong with the way Mace behaved and I have no sympathy for Ahsoka when she folded Anakin's hand around her braid. I actually did have some sympathy for her during the trial process, but lost every bit of it during that final scene, and my anger during the trial was directed at Tarkin, never at the Jedi. Tarkin is the one who mistreated Ahsoka and gave her the "kangaroo trial". @Legolas Skywalker , yes, I think the Jedi were obligated to hand Ahsoka over for trial because they were under Republic orders to do so and they have not been shown to refuse a direct Republic order. Not even one to put Anakin on the Jedi Council.