I said TPM. I'm not really sure though, it was a tough call. I did love FotR (seen it twice) and I intend to see it again this week. In FotR the acting was great, the effects were great.....but TPM is Star Wars. FotR is certainly a lot darker. I think Darth Maul is cool, and the end duel is tense, but in terms of emotional involvement for the viewer I don't think it really compares with the hobbits being pursued by the Nazgul (or Ringwraiths or Black Riders, whichever you prefer). Also, the end when Samwise follows Frodo (trying to say the bit I mean without spoiling it for people who haven't seen it yet), that is far more moving to me than QGJ dying (oops, sorry, spoilers! ) Anyway, in terms of Darkness and emotion we will have to see how AotC and ep III shape up. FotR is great but I see it as tiding me over till AotC. Can't wait for The Two Towers, too. I want to see the Ents!