I was really excited when I read the Graphic Novel. But what started the dislike was that they left out key scenes were dropped. Palpatine's annoucement of Padme's death, Anakin's extended confession, the mission into the core ship. Instead we were treated to childish C3PO antics. And that's your problem. You are criticizing the movie for something that was not in the movie. I hope you read the entire script, novelization, and comic for Episode 3 so you hate it just as much. BTW, did you forget all of the "childish C3PO antics" from the OT???