Discussion in 'Star Wars: Episode VII and Beyond (Archive)' started by LANDO_ROCKS, Nov 30, 2012.
Would love for him to be included!
Yes!!! Yes!!! YES!!!
In that article he said everything I've been saying about the CGI characters. I want to see more realism with CGI enhancements. Sign him up!
Ditto. The brain head guy wouldn't last long in a fight lol
I agree with him to a point. As Echo-7 said, if you can mesh the two elements together practical and digital effects can be magnificent. I disagree however with the comment about having too much space action or whatever. I love the opening scene of Revenge of the Sith just as much as the Battle of Endor.
Baker raises his head every few years to have a moan.
Lucas "lost reality"???
Baker sounds like he has lost touch with reality!
It's called Star Wars. You don't want less spaceships fighting, you want more.
That's like saying there should have been less bombs to disable in The Hurt Locker or less soldiers on the beach in Saving Private Ryan!!!
There was plenty of make up and prosthetics in the Prequels, but Lucas was more interested in CGI.
Star Wars is old fashioned storytelling with old fashioned heroes and villains.
But the technical side of the films has always been about pushing the boundaries of film-making, not about getting stuck in the past.
Yes, and since ROTJ, not one filmmaker has ever matched it (have any even tried in fact) until Lucas made ROTS.
Great! His work hasn't faltered a bit. Loved his work on MIB3. I also would like to see Phil Tippet back in the mix.
I totally agree with him. You gotta balance it.
The most recent example, within Star Wars, would be the new cg Ewok eyes. I thought they looked good, and wouldn't mind if they are done like that in the future.
He's totally right, the practical effects and real costume/makeup aliens just looked more real and there needs to be more of a balance.
He's hugely talented, I expect Lucasfilm would jump at the chance to have him aboard.
I just tingled with excitement.
Dear Rick: Even the original movie had a massive space battle! Maybe he got up after the Cantina sequence? I'm also sure the best way to compete with Avatar 2 will be lots of quickly made rubber masks Love ya RB, but the past is over. I'm all for less digital for VII but going all the way back to Ewok costumes isn't such a hot idea.
This just isn't going to be a fun thread.
I agree 100%!
I think the space battle from ROTJ is 100% more realistic than that in ROTS, in which I felt like I was watching a video game!
It's supposed to be about story telling, which in the PT came a very far second to CGI overkill!
A thousand times yes. Practical makeup is much better than CGI when it comes to alien characters.
It's called Star Wars, but it still has to retain a basis in reality. "more is better" is like saying there should be 3 or 4 people in the OT lightsaber duels, or that the opening of ANH should have thousands of spaceships instead of just two.
2 people in a duel works in the OT because the participants were people with history, with a reason to fight. One of which were very easy to relate to, the other was clearly evil.
More in a lightsaber fight did not work in the PT, because the participants were either unknown, bland, not needed or they had no known history with each other.
Two ships in the opening of ANH works because it brilliantly sets the stage and lets you know who the antagonist and protagonist factions are, and their strength in numbers/equipment.
Thousands of ships in the opening of ROTS did not work, because nobody knew what the hell was going on.
More people in Saving Private Ryan works because... well, that's how it really was in reality. That's how they fought wars back then.
See, it's not about numbers, it's about how emotionally invested the audience gets.
CGI is great, make-up and prosthetics are great, but too much of any of them will not work unless the director is excellent.
I disagree, to me; the prequel aliens are way more real. In the same way the ships have a more worn look, in the OT because of the PT; I think it’s the same with the characters.
I've never once heard anyone ever say that they were confused by the opening to RotS. And there's plenty of masks & puppetry in the PT.
Bull - and unoriginal!!!
I suppose next your going to tell me you thought Tubridy was relaxed and in his element on the Toy Show last night?
There was a story - and Lucas told it well.
Sticks fingers in ears
A "basis in reality"???
Have you ever actually seen a Star Wars movie?
And the reason why there is "less" (as you and Baker call it) in the OT is because the technology didn't exist for there to be "more".
Baker has been whinging for years because for sone reason he seems to think he was entitled to a pay day for the Prequels.
He wasn't - he should get over it.
There was plenty of masks, prostethics and the likes but over a decade later there is still the same old waffle.
Tell me where there wasn't a story?