Discussion in 'Star Wars: Episode VII and Beyond (Archive)' started by StarWarren, Jul 28, 2013.
Great post, I agree with this 100%.
I like where this is going. Continue.
Based on the PT, I think you are correct.
The Force is still the Force, an energy field generated by all living things.
The Midis are a microscopic lifeform and what they do, very basically, is act like middlemen. They provide a means for other beings to use the power of the Force and listen to the Force's will.
If you have loads of midis then you have an easier access to the Force or you can hear it more strongly.
If you have few midis, either you can not access the Force in any way, or only in a very limited way.
I don't think the midis themselves can regulate how easy their host can use the Force, it is simply a matter of numbers. Many midis, easy use, few midis, weak use.
Wheter the midis themselves are in any way sentient is unclear. They are microscopic and given that 20 000 of them can fit inside one cell, they would be very small indeed. Perhaps about the size of a starch molecule. Given that small size, sentience is unlikely.
If what Qui-Gon said is true, that Anakin was concieved by the midis then it is likely that this was done on order by the Force. So that means that the Force can "talk" to the midis and get them to do things. Perhaps the Force can not act on it's own in the physical world, it might need an agent in some fashion. If what Palpatine said is true then a strong Force user can also "talk" to the midis and get them to do things.
Questions that I have wondered about are, if number of midis matter, why is only the number per cell important? If all the midis in one cell can work together and provide a strong connection to the Force, why can't all the midis in your body to the same?
How would a blood transfusion work, would the midis in the donated blood imideatly alter their number to fit the new body? How would they know? If they can "talk" with all the other midis then we are back to the first question.
Why would the number of midis be constant? The midis are a separte life form, they would reproduce independent of the host. So if they lack "food" the number of midis would go down and vice versa.
Bye for now.
I think the Midi's are something that may or may not be seen in the ST.
One could look at them in Ep I simply as a way for Qui-Gon to recongize Anakin as "The Chosen One".
However, the mention in Ep III brings them back to the table as a possible element down the road in the ST. That being said, they could possibly be mentioned indirectly. Not ignored, but not a focus.
For example, should Darth Plagueis be involved, things could focus on the Midi's as an element both side are volleying for control of....
Plagueis could simply say something like "I CREATED THE CHOSEN ONE!!" (if in fact thats the case) We would all certainly know what he was referring to.......
If Plagueis were to turn out to be the baddie, I think midiclorians would definitely be in the story. Well, maybe not definitely, but it would seem a strong indicator
I'd love to, but I'm at work at the moment so can't spend too much time, and also, I haven't given it much thought yet as I only had the idea the moment I posted it. feel free to expand upon it yourself
Doesn't mean the Emperor wouldn't have secret programs going behind the backs of the Senate. It goes on in our own day.
Bye for now,
That is so you knowhattin' funny!
I was under the impression that all the midis in the body do work together to provide a strong connection to the force, and that the measurement per cell provided all the data required to gauge the strength of the average jedi. At least, this seems to be the case according to George Lucas, who stated that Anakin actually lost some of his ability to use the force when he lost parts of his body.
I've always seen it as a network, wherein the midis of a single cell are the most basic components of the network, but the same structure of communication exists between midis from cell to cell.
I actually like the way the book Darth Plagueis kind of tries to correct the Midi-Chlorians concept a little. He essentially discovers that they and their number have nothing to do with how force sensitive someone is, a human could have a very low count and be powerful in the Force. It kept both the Midi-Chlorians and by extension the Force a mystery which was a pretty interesting way to go about it.
Interesting. I never read that one.
This would seem the most logical approach. However this would mean that if you have more cells, ie a bigger body, then you have more midis in total and then your strength in the Force increases. This would in turn conflict with what Yoda said in ESB, how you should not judge him by his size.
I have heard of the Lucas quote as well and this would match the idea, more cells = more Force power. But I have also seen many deny this and argue that it is ONLY the conc per cell that matters, not how big your body is or the total number of midis in your body.
If body size matters then the space slug in ESB would have a HUGE amount of midis and thus be the most powerful Force user ever.
I don't know myself how this is supposed to work. If conc per cell is what matters, then body size would be irrelevant. But then you have the problem I mentioned and a possible problem with what Lucas said about Anakin loosing Force potential by loosing body parts. If the total number is what counts then the bigger you are, the better and we could very much judge Yoda by his size.
Bye for now.
That space slug just might be the most powerful force user ever! It might explain what his mynoks were feeding off of all that time
I think all the problems you presented here, might be why Bravesteel mentioned the Darth Plagueis novel tries to correct the midi concept. Perhaps his use of the word correct was well chosen? I haven't read it, so I don't know the details, but perhaps the whole mess is cleared up a little in that. The short answer is that I don't think GL put all that much thought into the concept. So no matter how hard we try to answer these questions, it really won't stand up to a lot of scrutiny, which probably just reinforces a lot of people's opinions that midis were a bad idea.
Also, I would have to wonder, if the midis in one cell are all that matters, what determines which cell does all the work? It seems impossible that if all the cells were working to achieve a common goal, that they wouldn't multiply the potency of the communication.